33 %
67 %
Information about Verdi

Published on October 8, 2007

Author: Kestrel


Management Forecasts, Disclosure Quality, and Market Efficiency :  Management Forecasts, Disclosure Quality, and Market Efficiency Jeffrey Ng, İrem Tuna, and Rodrigo Verdi What do we do?:  What do we do? We examine short-term and long-term market reaction to management forecasts We test the effect of disclosure quality on the long-term market reaction Motivation:  Motivation There is substantial evidence of market underreaction to news events e.g., PEAD (Bernard and Thomas, 1989, 1990) Conservatism theory (Barberis et al., 1998) Rational structural uncertainty (Brav and Heaton, 2002) Is there a post-management-forecast drift? Is underreaction to earnings news a function of perceived credibility of the news (e.g., stronger underreaction to good news)? Motivation:  Motivation Management forecasts constitute an interesting setting to study reaction to news because of credibility concerns (voluntary disclosure) Stronger short-term market reaction for bad news forecasts despite no difference in bias (Rogers and Stocken, 2005) Management forecasts allow us to examine whether disclosure quality affects the market reaction to news Overview of Results:  Overview of Results Figure 1a – Annual earnings forecasts Anilowski, Feng, and Skinner (JAE 2007):  Anilowski, Feng, and Skinner (JAE 2007) Kato, Skinner, and Kunimura (WP 2007):  Kato, Skinner, and Kunimura (WP 2007) Hypothesis I:  Hypothesis I PEAD literature provides evidence of underreaction to earnings surprises Both conservatism and rational structural uncertainty can explain an underreaction phenomenon We hypothesize that credibility concerns related to management forecasts can exacerbate underreaction to earnings news H1: Future stock returns are positively associated with management forecast news Hypothesis II:  Hypothesis II Larger stock price reaction to bad news forecasts than to good news forecasts (e.g., Hutton et al., 2003) Typical explanation is that bad news forecasts are more credible than good news forecasts No difference in the forecast bias between bad news and good news forecasts (Rogers and Stocken, 2005) H2: The magnitude of the future returns is larger for firms forecasting good news Hypothesis III:  Hypothesis III Better disclosure may help investors understand the future cash flow implications of an information signal Prior literature provides evidence that better disclosure mitigates the magnitude of market inefficiency PEAD (Francis et al., 2005; Kimbrough, 2005) Accruals anomaly (Richardson et al., 2005; Levi, 2007) H3: The magnitude of the hedge portfolio returns from the PMFD trading strategy is lower for firms whose forecasts are of higher quality. Sample Description:  Sample Description Follow Anilowski et al. (2007): 17,184 (14,890) forecasts of annual (quarterly) EPS 6,369 (5,859) annual (quarterly) forecasts that do not overlap with earnings announcements Ordinary shares listed on NYSE / AMEX / NASDAQ from 1996 to 2005 Key Variables:  Key Variables Surprise= (Manag. Forec – Analyst Forec) / Price Abnormal returns: Size-adjusted buy-hold returns Size-BM adjusted buy-hold returns Factor alphas (3-factor, 4-factor, 5-factor) Short-term: 3-day around the forecast Long-term: 12-month subsequent to the forecast month Short- and long-term reaction:  Short- and long-term reaction Return = β0 + β1 Good News + β2 Surprise + β3 Surprise x Good News + ∑ βj Surprise x Controls + ∑ βm Controls + ε Return is either: - AbRet3d (3-day return around forecast) - AbRet (future 12-month return) Fama-MacBeth regressions with Newey-West corrected standard errors Table 3 – FRC Regressions:  Table 3 – FRC Regressions Hedge Portfolio Analyses:  Hedge Portfolio Analyses We sort the observations into quintiles based on the previous year’s distribution of forecast surprises Hedge portfolio strategy: Buy shares of firms in Q5 (extreme good news) Short shares of firms in Q1 (extreme bad news) Abnormal returns: Size-adjusted and size-BM-adjusted buy-hold returns 3-factor, 4-factor, and 5-factor alphas Hedge Portfolio – Annual Forecasts:  Hedge Portfolio – Annual Forecasts Short- and Long-term returns:  Short- and Long-term returns Mean Returns by Quarter:  Mean Returns by Quarter Median Returns by Quarter:  Median Returns by Quarter Factor Alphas – Annual Forecasts:  Factor Alphas – Annual Forecasts Conservatism vs. Structural Uncertainty:  Conservatism vs. Structural Uncertainty Analyst forecast dispersion Proxy for precision of pre-forecast signals Lower dispersion, greater conservatism Intraday return volatility Proxy for the degree of uncertainty generated by the disclosure signal Higher volatility, more structural uncertainty Research Design:  Research Design AbRet = β0 + β1 QSurprise + β2 QSurprise * Dispersion + β3 QSurprise * Intraday Vol + β4 Dispersion + β5 Intraday Vol + ∑ βj Risk Controls Prediction: β2 < 0 and β3 > 0 AbRet (future 12-month size-adjusted return) Fama-MacBeth regressions with Newey-West corrected standard errors QSurprise is a quintile variable re-scaled from 0 to 1. Dispersion and Intraday Vol are dummy variables based on median. Table 6 – Theories:  Table 6 – Theories Disclosure Quality (H3):  Disclosure Quality (H3) Accuracy = -1*|Earnt-1 – Man Forecastt-1| / Price Precision: Point versus range forecasts Horizon: # of days between forecast and Fiscal-year end Research Design:  Research Design AbRet = β0 + β1 QSurprise + ∑ βi QSurprise * Disclosure Quality + ∑ βj Disclosure Quality + ∑ βm Risk Controls Prediction: βj < 0 for Accuracy βj < 0 for Precision βj > 0 for Horizon QSurprise is a quintile variable re-scaled from 0 to 1. Disclosure Quality are dummy variables based on median. Table 7 – Disclosure Quality:  Table 7 – Disclosure Quality PMFD vs. PEAD:  PMFD vs. PEAD Summary of Findings:  Summary of Findings The short-term reaction larger for bad news The future long-term reaction is larger for good news A hedge portfolio earns annual abnormal returns above 25% Both analyst forecast dispersion and intraday volatility explain the cross-sectional variation in the PMFD Hedge returns smaller for firms with higher prior forecast accuracy Implications:  Implications Significant underreaction to management forecasts. Results consistent with behavioral theories of conservatism (Barberis et al., 1998) and rational structural uncertainty (Brav and Heaton, 2002) Disclosure quality appears to reduce the market underreaction to management forecasts An unresolved question is why the effect is not arbitraged away – As Merton (1987) states: “…an anomaly must uncovered and learned before one can arbitrage…even when learned, there are limits to arbitrage…”

Add a comment

Related presentations

Related pages

ver.di – ver.di

ver.di ist die Expertin für gute Arbeit, faire Löhne, Vereinbarkeit von Familie und Beruf, Gleichberechtigung und mehr. Noch Fragen? Mach mit!
Read more

Giuseppe Verdi – Wikipedia

Giuseppe Fortunino Francesco Verdi (* 9. Oktober oder 10. Oktober 1813 in Le Roncole, Département Taro, Französisches Kaiserreich; † 27. Januar 1901 in ...
Read more

Vereinte Dienstleistungsgewerkschaft – Wikipedia

Die Vereinte Dienstleistungsgewerkschaft (kurz Verdi, Eigenschreibweise: ver.di, Aussprache: [ˈvɛʁdiː]) ist eine deutsche Gewerkschaft mit Sitz in Berlin.
Read more

ver.di – ver.di-Mitgliederservice

Der ver.di Mitgliederservice bietet ver.di-Mitgliedern exklusive Angebote aus den Bereichen: Beraten, Vorsorgen, Finanzieren, Reisen und Freizeit.
Read more

ver.di – Handel

Das ist die Startseite des Fachbereichs Handel in ver.di. Wir sind für alle Beschäftigten im Einzelhandel, Groß- und Außendhandel zuständig.
Read more

ver.di – Berlin-Brandenburg

Internetseite des ver.di LBZ Berlin - Brandenburg ... 2016 ist es 150 Jahre her, dass die erste Gewerkschaft gegründet wurde.
Read more

ver.di – Landesbezirk Nordrhein-Westfalen

Über 500 Betriebs- und Personalräte haben am 19. Mai in der Düsseldorfer Stadthalle über gute und faire Arbeit 4.0 gesprochen. Landesarbeitsminister ...
Read more

ver.di – Bezirk Berlin

2016 ist es 150 Jahre her, dass die erste Gewerkschaft gegründet wurde. Die ist auch die erste Vorgängerin von ver.di, die ihren 15. feiert.
Read more

ver.di Mitglied werden

Ich ermächtige ver.di, Zahlungen von meinem Konto mittels Lastschrift einzuziehen. Zugleich weise ich mein Kreditinstitut an, die von ver.di auf mein ...
Read more

ver.di – Landesbezirk Sachsen, Sachsen-Anhalt, Thüringen

ver.di Landesbezirk. Sachsen, Sachsen-Anhalt, Thüringen. Bessere und gerechtere Bedingungen für gute Arbeit. Gemeinsam stark für unsere Region!
Read more