Urban Olympics

50 %
50 %
Information about Urban Olympics

Published on May 24, 2008

Author: james.kennell

Source: slideshare.net

Description

Professor Graeme Evan\'s presentation at the Olympic Legacy conference, Greenwich University, May 2008

Regeneration Games Olympic Legacy People, Place, Enterprise University of Greenwich 9 May 2008 Graeme Evans

Urban Olympics 1896 -1900s small scale : Athens, Paris, St Louis/ Chicago World Fair , London (ex-Rome) 1910 -1930 new facilities : Stockholm, Berlin 1930 -1950s flagships : Helsinki, Melbourne + legacies 1960s - large scale urban improvements , large scale events… and budget/over-runs: Rome, Tokyo… “ Problem” Games : Mexico, Munich, Montreal [ex-1967 EXPO], Moscow - politics, protest, costs … Commercial Games : Los Angeles, Atlanta [minimal] Regeneration Games : Seoul, Barcelona, Sydney (“Green”), Athens, Beijing, Vancouver/OWG, London ..

1896 -1900s small scale : Athens, Paris, St Louis/ Chicago World Fair , London (ex-Rome)

1910 -1930 new facilities : Stockholm, Berlin

1930 -1950s flagships : Helsinki, Melbourne + legacies

1960s - large scale urban improvements , large scale events… and budget/over-runs: Rome, Tokyo…

“ Problem” Games : Mexico, Munich, Montreal [ex-1967 EXPO], Moscow - politics, protest, costs …

Commercial Games : Los Angeles, Atlanta [minimal]

Regeneration Games : Seoul, Barcelona, Sydney

(“Green”), Athens, Beijing, Vancouver/OWG, London ..

City of Renewal Hallmark (Mega-) events – Fourth Period “City of Renewal” “ The hosting of mega-events is often deliberately exploited in an attempt to ‘rejuvenate’ or develop urban areas through the construction and development of new infrastructure..road and rail networks, airports, sewage and housing” (Hall, 1992) Contemporary Olympics – mega-events, alongside… International EXPOs / World [Trade] Fairs – C18/19 France, UK, colonies, USA; Regenerating Montreal, Seville, Lisbon World/Euro Cups (and smaller sporting & cultural events) European City/Capitals of Culture Regenerating Glasgow Liverpool ’08 [+ earlier Garden Festivals], Istanbul ’10

Hallmark (Mega-) events – Fourth Period “City of Renewal”

“ The hosting of mega-events is often deliberately exploited in an attempt to ‘rejuvenate’ or develop urban areas through the construction and development of new infrastructure..road and rail networks, airports, sewage and housing” (Hall, 1992)

Contemporary Olympics – mega-events, alongside…

International EXPOs / World [Trade] Fairs – C18/19 France, UK, colonies, USA; Regenerating Montreal, Seville, Lisbon

World/Euro Cups (and smaller sporting & cultural events)

European City/Capitals of Culture Regenerating Glasgow Liverpool ’08 [+ earlier Garden Festivals], Istanbul ’10

Barcelona 1988-1993 pre-post Games 1994-2000 Cultural Forum 2001- city extension, Poblenou

Beijing – 2008 a coming out party for a nation emerging from a century of humiliation and chaos to become one of the most powerful economies on the planet In north Beijing, the official Olympic site is called a “park”, a common Olympic site designation. However this was a busy residential and workshop area. Razed by bulldozers, for months afterwards traders with donkey carts scavenged in the rubble for bricks and timber before the soil was covered in plastic sheeting and fenced off behind corrugated walls (Sudjic, 2005: 116). Beijing is spending between 200-250 billion yuan on transport improvements - about 17 times its budget for sporting venues.

In north Beijing, the official Olympic site is called a “park”, a common

Olympic site designation. However this was a busy residential and

workshop area. Razed by bulldozers, for months afterwards traders

with donkey carts scavenged in the rubble for bricks and timber before

the soil was covered in plastic sheeting and fenced off behind

corrugated walls (Sudjic, 2005: 116).

Beijing is spending between 200-250 billion yuan on transport

improvements - about 17 times its budget for sporting venues.

Beijing - Rapid Urban/Westernisation

… and displacement

 

Vancouver Downtown Eastside

Walls…

Consultation

Legacy: Before & After

Futuristic Visions

and Past Visions…

Budget: Moveable Feast…

 

Regeneration Budgets 7% 19% (inc. 12% on hotels) Other site infrastructure inc. sports facilities 18% [11% excluding £1bn Security] 3% Operations [£1bn Security] 45% [inc. CTRL, ELL] 43% [roads, airport] New Transport 7% 11% [private dev] Olympic Village 23% 24% New Olympic sports facilities London 2012 £14bn. Barcelona 1992 Ptas 957 bn Budget

National, City or Local Event?

Stratford “City”

Major development areas

Thames Gateway-London region

Growth Areas

Amenity in Thames Gateway

 

 

 

 

In the “Olympic city” of Newham only 14.5% of residents participated in the recommended target of 30 minutes of moderate exercise three times a week, half the rate in the west London boro’s of Richmond & Kensington (29%) ( Sport England 2006) ‘ ..the journey of the Olympic torch in 2012 will end among some of the laziest and least sporting communities in the UK..the least likely to leave their couches to take some form of recreational exercise’ ( Curtis , 2006: 9) ‘ Sporting and cultural opportunities can play an important part in re-engaging disaffected sections of the community, building shared social capital and grass roots leadership through improved cross-cultural interaction ’. Building Cohesive Communities (Home Office 2002) Olympics  coach potatoes or mass participants ?

In the “Olympic city” of Newham only 14.5% of

residents participated in the recommended target of 30

minutes of moderate exercise three times a week, half

the rate in the west London boro’s of Richmond &

Kensington (29%) ( Sport England 2006)

‘ ..the journey of the Olympic torch in 2012 will end among some

of the laziest and least sporting communities in the UK..the least

likely to leave their couches to take some form of recreational

exercise’ ( Curtis , 2006: 9)

“ mixed picture.. difficult to attribute it to Olympic Games” (Veal 2003) Olympic sports  7 [small] increases  9 declined Non-Olympic sports : similar patterns Biggest increase in non-competitive walking Impact of Sydney Olympics on sports participation Game Plan “ ..it would seem that hosting events is not an effective, value for money, method of achieving… a sustained increase in mass participation “ Manchester Commonwealth Games : negligible local impacts

“ mixed picture.. difficult to attribute it to Olympic Games” (Veal 2003)

Olympic sports

 7 [small] increases

 9 declined

Non-Olympic sports : similar patterns

Biggest increase in non-competitive walking

Give communities the freedom to decide for themselves how they want to use each part, each space…the measure of success is the way that spaces are used, the diversity of activities which they attract, and the opportunities they provide for creative reinterpretation (Hertzberger, 1991)

Housing: Growing Ambitions Ever increasing housing targets in London Thames Gateway - 46,000 London Plan - 59,000 ODPM Sustainable Communities - 91,000 Thames Gateway Development Framework New Housing Capacity Study: 100,000 dwellings TG London by 2016/17

Ever increasing housing targets in London

Thames Gateway

- 46,000 London Plan

- 59,000 ODPM Sustainable Communities

- 91,000 Thames Gateway Development Framework

New Housing Capacity Study: 100,000 dwellings

TG London by 2016/17

Changing townscape, and Community?

Leamouth, Providence Wharf

New East Enders New housing it is hoped, will also attract residents to 3,600 apartments in the Olympic village and 9,000 in the Olympic Park area as a whole . However, the regional masterplan for the swathe of east London along the Lea Valley plans new housing and amenities which allows for facility standards to be designed at only 60% of the national standard

Employment If the Lower Lea Valley is to be transformed - socially as well as physically - then these are the people who need to access new employment opportunities. Sustainable regeneration will require a genuine increase in the local employment rate - not just the result of highly skilled population moving in and displacing the indigenous lower skilled one (Vigor 2006).

Deprivation 20% of the adult population in the Thames Gateway have no formal qualifications and half of the children live in workless households… 2007 IMD

London told: 'Don't expect a boom from the Olympics' Study is sceptical about impact of 2012 Games May 13, 2007 Observer “ Assurances that the London Olympics in 2012 will create a boom in jobs, tourism and sports participation are unlikely to be fulfilled, warns a report commissioned by the capital's political leaders. Promises that the event will bring 50,000 jobs, affordable new housing on a large scale and contracts for small businesses in east London where the Games will be held will prove very difficult to honour, according to the study prepared for the London Assembly” Olympic benefits experienced by the past 4 cities - Athens, Sydney, Atlanta and Barcelona - suggests that London will find it hard to realise its ambitions of regenerating boroughs around the Olympic area, which rank among the poorest places in Britain. 2012 may struggle to make any serious difference to unemployment in London: Long-term unemployed and workless communities were largely unaffected by the staging of the Games in each of the 4 cities. Much of the employment was temporary, and there was also little evidence that volunteer skills transferred to the post-Games economy MacRury 2007 Greece actually lost 70,000 jobs in the three months following the [2004] Games, mostly in the construction industry. However, Sydney in 2000 and Barcelona in 1992 did enjoy some growth in jobs and inward investment from firms relocating. Legacy -it will be 'very challenging' for London to meet its goals on employment, sports participation, skills, tourism and disability awareness. Aims for urban renewal, environment and the economy are 'challenging', while only community participation plans are deemed 'feasible'.

London told: 'Don't expect a boom from the Olympics'

Study is sceptical about impact of 2012 Games

May 13, 2007 Observer

“ Assurances that the London Olympics in 2012 will create a boom in jobs, tourism and sports participation are unlikely to be fulfilled, warns a report commissioned by the capital's political leaders. Promises that the event will bring 50,000 jobs, affordable new housing on a large scale and contracts for small businesses in east London where the Games will be held will prove very difficult to honour, according to the study prepared for the London Assembly”

Olympic benefits experienced by the past 4 cities - Athens, Sydney, Atlanta and Barcelona - suggests that London will find it hard to realise its ambitions of regenerating boroughs around the Olympic area, which rank among the poorest places in Britain.

2012 may struggle to make any serious difference to unemployment in London:

Long-term unemployed and workless communities were largely unaffected by the staging of the Games in each of the 4 cities. Much of the employment was temporary, and there was also little evidence that volunteer skills transferred to the post-Games economy MacRury 2007

Greece actually lost 70,000 jobs in the three months following the [2004] Games, mostly in the construction industry. However, Sydney in 2000 and Barcelona in 1992 did enjoy some growth in jobs and inward investment from firms relocating.

Legacy -it will be 'very challenging' for London to meet its goals on employment, sports participation, skills, tourism and disability awareness. Aims for urban renewal, environment and the economy are 'challenging', while only community participation plans are deemed 'feasible'.

Assessing Impacts Government appraisal guidance recognises that as well as external economic factors, there is a need for longer term evaluation in order to capture their sustained impacts, as the HM Treasury review noted: ‘ The value of long-term benefit need to be brought into the appraisal process’ (2003). From a regeneration assessment perspective, the main issues which should be borne in mind are: Valuation in this area tends to be highly context specific and requires bespoke investigations. There are limited possibilities for the use of techniques such as benefits transfer, CBA.. As with environmental impacts, irreversible impacts can be of significant importance How and which costs and benefits are valued is of particular importance, including less tangible factors and perceptions. Valuing benefits requires greater consideration since as the Review concluded this aspect has been done poorly in the past and the NAO has criticised many projects for not describing, and managing the realisation of benefits, i.e. there is endemic over-optimism in project feasibility and projections, notably on capital costs….

Government appraisal guidance recognises that as well as external economic factors, there is a need for longer term evaluation in order to capture their sustained impacts, as the HM Treasury review noted:

‘ The value of long-term benefit need to be brought into the appraisal process’ (2003). From a regeneration assessment perspective, the main issues which should be borne in mind are:

Valuation in this area tends to be highly context specific and requires bespoke investigations. There are limited possibilities for the use of techniques such as benefits transfer, CBA..

As with environmental impacts, irreversible impacts can be of significant importance

How and which costs and benefits are valued is of particular importance, including less tangible factors and perceptions. Valuing benefits requires greater consideration since as the Review concluded this aspect has been done poorly in the past and the NAO has criticised many projects for not describing, and managing the realisation of benefits, i.e. there is endemic over-optimism in project feasibility and projections, notably on capital costs….

Key issues Regeneration is a long term project and decisions and impact measurement long term also – c.25 years (beyond political horizons = non-political governance systems needed) Transparency and attribution (costs, outcomes) are fundamental to “ownership”, but lacking in practice… Mega-events as regenerative projects are not good value (facility after-use?) - infrastructure e.g. affordable/ accessible transport & housing and programmes are most effective

Regeneration is a long term project and decisions and impact measurement long term also – c.25 years (beyond political horizons = non-political governance systems needed)

Transparency and attribution (costs, outcomes) are fundamental to “ownership”, but lacking in practice…

Mega-events as regenerative projects are not good value (facility after-use?) - infrastructure e.g. affordable/ accessible transport & housing and programmes are most effective

www.citiesinstitute.org [email_address] Each story of regeneration begins with poetry and ends with real estate (Kunzman 2004).

Add a comment

Related presentations

Related pages

Urban Olympics - YouTube

How fun would an olympics like this be! LOL Except for the part where he gets hit in the head from that angry guy with the plank of wood ...
Read more

Urban Dictionary: Olympics

The Urban Dictionary Mug One side has the word, one side has the definition. Microwave and dishwasher safe. Lotsa space for your liquids. Buy the mug
Read more

Urban Dictionary: bme pain olympics

The Urban Dictionary Mug One side has the word, one side has the definition. Microwave and dishwasher safe. Lotsa space for your liquids. Buy the mug
Read more

Urban Olympics - shutterstock.com

See a rich collection of stock images, vectors, or photos for urban olympics you can buy on Shutterstock. Explore quality images, photos, art & more.
Read more

Urban Olympics : gifs - reddit

reddit: the front page of the internet ... This comment has been overwritten by an open source script to protect this user's privacy.
Read more

Urban Olympics - Flipping off a Cop Car - YouTube

Want to watch this again later? Sign in to add this video to a playlist. Giving him the finger would've been inappropriate. (Streakrunning ...
Read more

London Olympics: How the Games Help Urban Development

The Olympics have begun to transform previously-neglected sections of East London. The grand Olympic Park—to be renamed the Queen Elizabeth Olympic Park ...
Read more

Escaping the Olympics via Rio's Magical Urban Jungle - NBC ...

RIO DE JANEIRO — The idea to create the first long-distance trail in Rio was born in Atlanta, when a group of Brazilians headed to the 1996 Olympics to ...
Read more

www.Urban-olympics.de - Britaus.ru - urlm.de

In Deutschland, rangiert Urban-olympics.de auf Platz 7.641.183, mit geschätzten < 300 Besuchern im Monat. Klicken Sie hier um mehr Informationen zu dieser ...
Read more

urban-olympics.com - Domain geparkt

Domain geparkt Diese Domain wird von easyname.com verwaltet. Sollten Sie der Inhaber dieser Domain sein, klicken Sie bitte im easyname Controlpanel unter ...
Read more