Trends In Leadership Thought

50 %
50 %
Information about Trends In Leadership Thought

Published on November 25, 2007

Author: Tudor

Source: slideshare.net

Description

Powerpoint slideshow with leadership quiz

Trends in Leadership thought

Quiz (1) How would you define leadership? Where would you expect to find the earliest recorded descriptions of leaders? Who wrote about the lives of great engineers? What assumption lies behind trait theories of leadership What do we remember as Stogdill’s contribution to leadership

How would you define leadership?

Where would you expect to find the earliest recorded descriptions of leaders?

Who wrote about the lives of great engineers?

What assumption lies behind trait theories of leadership

What do we remember as Stogdill’s contribution to leadership

Quiz (2) What assumption lies behind style theories of leadership? Suggest two contrasting leadership styles found in experimental studies What is a contingency theory What leadership style is associated with ‘New Leadership’ theories of the 1980s What is distributed leadership?

What assumption lies behind style theories of leadership?

Suggest two contrasting leadership styles found in experimental studies

What is a contingency theory

What leadership style is associated with ‘New Leadership’ theories of the 1980s

What is distributed leadership?

Quiz (3) What leadership concept was central to Weber’s social theorizing? How did the theory re-emerge in later leadership studies? What are usually listed as the historical periods of leadership thought? What led to changes in leadership thought?

What leadership concept was central to Weber’s social theorizing?

How did the theory re-emerge in later leadership studies?

What are usually listed as the historical periods of leadership thought?

What led to changes in leadership thought?

KEY STAGES IN LEADERSHIP THOUGHT Heroic leadership Trait based theories Transactional theories (style and situational approaches) The ‘New leadership’ movement (transformation leadership; vision, management of meaning)

Heroic leadership

Trait based theories

Transactional theories (style and situational approaches)

The ‘New leadership’ movement (transformation leadership; vision, management of meaning)

Definitions: It depends what you mean by leadership .. Influence processes Mobilizing resources to arouse, engage, satisfy the motives of followers Making sense [of what people are doing] …articulating purpose and values

Influence processes

Mobilizing resources to arouse, engage, satisfy the motives of followers

Making sense [of what people are doing] …articulating purpose and values

HEROIC LEADERSHIP Ancient ideas of leadership can be found in all cultures Heroic leaders were historic and mythic figures later analysed by Weber (Charisma) Other 8th/19th century studies examined contemporary and historic figures Influential accounts by Thomas Carlisle, Samuel Smiles, Friedrich Nietzsche

Ancient ideas of leadership can be found in all cultures

Heroic leaders were historic and mythic figures later analysed by Weber (Charisma)

Other 8th/19th century studies examined contemporary and historic figures

Influential accounts by Thomas Carlisle, Samuel Smiles, Friedrich Nietzsche

Weber Weber explained the formation and disruption of social institutions His model involved the influence of charismatic leaders These were believed to possess special powers and gifts

Weber explained the formation and disruption of social institutions

His model involved the influence of charismatic leaders

These were believed to possess special powers and gifts

THOMAS CARLYSLE History made up of accounts of heroic leaders Argued that all heroes were flawed … … but should be excused their flaws ‘ No man is a hero to his valet’

History made up of accounts of heroic leaders

Argued that all heroes were flawed …

… but should be excused their flaws

‘ No man is a hero to his valet’

SAMUEL SMILES Biographer of the hero-engineers of the Industrial Revolution He captured ‘Victorian values’ such as self-help and public duty Tended towards uncritical hero-worship

Biographer of the hero-engineers of the Industrial Revolution

He captured ‘Victorian values’ such as self-help and public duty

Tended towards uncritical hero-worship

FRIEDRICH NIETZSCHE Complex German Philosopher Believed the ‘great man’ (Uberman) was above normal laws of society

Complex German Philosopher

Believed the ‘great man’ (Uberman) was above normal laws of society

LIMITATIONS OF THE HEROIC VIEW Became regarded as ‘romantic’ and ‘pre-modern’ Leading figures (Carlisle, Nietzsche espoused by totalitarian regimes) Considered unsuited to modern organizations Concealed ‘the dark side’

Became regarded as ‘romantic’ and ‘pre-modern’

Leading figures (Carlisle, Nietzsche espoused by totalitarian regimes)

Considered unsuited to modern organizations

Concealed ‘the dark side’

TRAIT THEORIES Seek the essence of leaders (‘born to lead’) Francis Galton pioneered an empirical approach anticipating subsequent psychometric methods Studies produced many different traits, failed to establish a ‘universal’ theory Thurstone’s five factors proposal ignored for many years (but partially rehabilitated)

Seek the essence of leaders (‘born to lead’)

Francis Galton pioneered an empirical approach anticipating subsequent psychometric methods

Studies produced many different traits, failed to establish a ‘universal’ theory

Thurstone’s five factors proposal ignored for many years (but partially rehabilitated)

DECLINE IN TRAIT THEORIES The multiplicity of traits identified became a problem Stogdill’s Handbook called for a new approach (1960s) This helped in the rise of Style theories, and other Transactional theories [Co-editor Bass later associated with transformational leadership]

The multiplicity of traits identified became a problem

Stogdill’s Handbook called for a new approach (1960s)

This helped in the rise of Style theories, and other Transactional theories

[Co-editor Bass later associated with transformational leadership]

STOGDILL AND STYLE THEORIES Stogdill’s group at Ohio State pioneered style (what leaders do) over traits (what leaders are) Labelled main styles as consideration [towards others], and initiation of structure (‘People, and Task ‘ styles)

Stogdill’s group at Ohio State pioneered style (what leaders do) over traits (what leaders are)

Labelled main styles as consideration [towards others], and initiation of structure (‘People, and Task ‘ styles)

DECLINE OF STYLE THEORIES Approach failed to demonstrate a ‘universally effective leadership style’ It overlooked ‘situational’ or contextual effects (which made effectiveness ‘contingent’ or ‘sometimes influenced by’ non-style factors)

Approach failed to demonstrate a ‘universally effective leadership style’

It overlooked ‘situational’ or contextual effects (which made effectiveness ‘contingent’ or ‘sometimes influenced by’ non-style factors)

STYLE AND CONTINGENCY AS TRANSACTIONAL THEORIES Style and contingency can be seen as transactional theories A transactional leader is the term applied to leaders studied in terms of their behaviours, and specifically in their transactions with others .

Style and contingency can be seen as transactional theories

A transactional leader is the term applied to leaders studied in terms of their behaviours, and specifically in their transactions with others .

TRANSACTIONAL AND TRANSFORMATIONAL THEORIES Transactional theories were replaced trait theories (1960s – 1980s). They failed to satisfy needs in organizations for a change-centred theory This was provided by a series of studies by Bernard Bass and colleagues (1970s - )

Transactional theories were replaced trait theories (1960s – 1980s).

They failed to satisfy needs in organizations for a change-centred theory

This was provided by a series of studies by Bernard Bass and colleagues (1970s - )

BOTH AND … NOT EITHER/OR Bass and Avolio’s ‘Full Range’ leadership model indicated that transformational leadership was an ‘ add-on ’ not a ‘ replacement for ’ transactional behaviours The factors were important in developing a New Leadership era (1980s)

Bass and Avolio’s ‘Full Range’ leadership model indicated that transformational leadership was an ‘ add-on ’ not a ‘ replacement for ’ transactional behaviours

The factors were important in developing a New Leadership era (1980s)

Factors in the full-range model Idealized influence (Charisma?) Inspirational motivation Intellectual stimulation Individualised consideration Contingent rewards (carrots and sticks) Management by exception (active and passive versions) Transformational factors Transactional factors

NEW LEADERSHIP Term was coined by Alan Bryman Became widely-cited Focused on transformational change Regarded leaders as providers of vision Theory is an interpretative one

Term was coined by Alan Bryman

Became widely-cited

Focused on transformational change

Regarded leaders as providers of vision

Theory is an interpretative one

WHAT’S BEYOND NEW LEADERSHIP? New Leadership left a lot of issues unanswered These include ‘post-charismatic’ ideas such as 5 th -level leadership; distributed leadership; and leaderless groups

New Leadership left a lot of issues unanswered

These include ‘post-charismatic’ ideas such as 5 th -level leadership; distributed leadership; and leaderless groups

Post- charismatic ideas (1990S-) Fifth-level leaders (Jim Collins) were found to be ‘modest but of fierce resolve’ Distributed leadership suggests that a team ‘owns’ different parts of the leadership process Leaderless groups have been proposed as the ‘natural’ condition of informal social activities

Fifth-level leaders (Jim Collins) were found to be ‘modest but of fierce resolve’

Distributed leadership suggests that a team ‘owns’ different parts of the leadership process

Leaderless groups have been proposed as the ‘natural’ condition of informal social activities

Distributed leadership Model The Slone Distributed Leadership Model (DLM) is based on Sensemaking Relating Visioning Inventing (collaborative designing to realize a shared vision) DLM ‘seeks to help each leader discover a personal Change Signature (an individual approach grounded in personal beliefs)

How many quiz questions are easier to answer now?

To go more deeply Rickards & Clark (2005), Dilemmas of Leadership, Routledge, http://www.routledge.com/textbooks/0415355850/ Bryman, A., Leadership, h ttp:// www.amazon.com /SAGE-Handbook-Organization-Studies/dp/0761949968 http://sloanleadership.mit.edu/pdf/LeadershipinanAgeofUncertainty-researchbrief.pdf

Rickards & Clark (2005), Dilemmas of Leadership, Routledge, http://www.routledge.com/textbooks/0415355850/

Bryman, A., Leadership,

h ttp:// www.amazon.com /SAGE-Handbook-Organization-Studies/dp/0761949968

http://sloanleadership.mit.edu/pdf/LeadershipinanAgeofUncertainty-researchbrief.pdf

Add a comment

Related presentations

Related pages

Thought Leadership | Deutsche Asset Management - DWS

Thought Leadership. Was bewegt die Weltwirtschaft? Wo liegen jetzt die Chancen von morgen, welche Trends und Entwicklungen werden die Wirtschaft und die ...
Read more

Thought Leadership | Capgemini Deutschland

Thought Leadership. Hier finden Sie einige unserer wichtigsten Publikationen zu aktuellen Themen und Trends im Bereich Business und Technology.
Read more

The Thought Net – The Thought Leadership Connection

The Thought Bank is a Thought Leadership Consulting Firm in San Francisco providing comprehensive thought leadership programs to help companies build ...
Read more

Future Trends in Leadership Development - insights.ccl.org

Section 2–Future Trends for 1o Leadership Development Types of Development 11 Why Vertical Development 12 Matters for Leadership What the Stages of 13
Read more

6 Leadership Development Trends for 2015 - switchandshift.com

Among the trends mentioned in a report entitled Future Trends in Leadership Development published by the Center for Creative Leadership is the decline of ...
Read more

Seven Leadership Development Trends - Training Industry

Seven Leadership Development Trends. One ... If leadership is thought of as a shared process, rather than an individual skill set, senior
Read more

Thought Leadership | Business Trends & Insights | American ...

Find articles and thought leadership content by American Express about how corporate card programmes and payment solutions can help achieve business goals.
Read more

3 Leadership Trends of 2014 | Inc.com

3 Leadership Trends of 2014. ... What are the most innovative leadership methods being taught in business schools and implemented by CEOs?
Read more

CORE Education's Ten Trends 2016 | CORE Education

Each year, CORE Education’s experienced staff of researchers, educators, and digital technology experts pool their expertise and combine their ...
Read more