Traditional Chinese Vs Western Conceptions Of Space2

50 %
50 %
Information about Traditional Chinese Vs Western Conceptions Of Space2

Published on January 1, 2009

Author: ponzart



Examines Traditional Chinese Vs Western Conceptions Of Space by looking at scrolls created during Qing Dynasty China.

“Journey Through Space” What the Kangxi and Qianlong Southern Inspection Tour Scrolls reveal about Chinese and Western Concep'ons of   SPACE  Robert Ponzio  Chair, Fine Arts  Oak Hall School  Gainesville, FL 

Website studies Qing Dynasty History and Culture by examining  Southern InspecGon Tour scrolls commissioned by   Emperor Kangxi and Emperor Qianlong 

The Manchus were foreigners who established the Qing Dynasty after conquering the Ming. Kangxi Emperor   Reigned 1662‐1722  Portrait of the Kangxi Emperor as a Young Man, Anonymous

Tradi'onal Western   One Point PerspecGve System   Depic'ons of Space   •Concerned with reproducing how the eye sees  • Image has fixed edges  •Organized based on receding vanishing points  •ArGst controls viewer vantage point           GenGle Bellini’s “Procession in Piazza San Marco”, 1496 

Tradi'onal Chinese Depic'on of Space   ArGst Wang Hui’s  hand scrolls uGlize tradiGonal Chinese depicGons of space.  

The Hand Scroll Format 

TradiGonal Chinese Maps:    Experience of the journey is more important than Scale             

SpaGal TransiGon Point 

Mist / TransiGon‐ Kangxi Scroll 7  Working with the tradiGonal Chinese concepGons of shi]ing space,   Wang Hui uGlizes a thick fog to fade out from one scene to the next.    This creaGve means of transiGoning impressed upon the viewer   the percepGon of the passing of Gme.   

Mist / TransiGon‐ Kangxi Scroll 7  Elements of the landscape and architecture are subtly revealed as they peak out of  the mist, allowing the viewer to gain a sense of traveling over a great distance.    As the mist ulGmately disappears, we then find ourselves in the next town. 

Mist / TransiGon‐ Kangxi Scroll 3   Wang Hui shows travelers disappearing into the mist as they embark upon a long journey…  

Mist / TransiGon‐ Kangxi Scroll 3   …they eventually reappear a]er an immeasurable passage of Gme and distance. 

Expansion of   Qing  Empire  Qianlong Emperor  Reigned 1736‐96  Inaugura'on Portrait of Qianlong (Detail)  Giuseppe Cas'glione (Lang Shining), 1736 

Qianlong Emperor as the BodhisaDva  Manjusri  (Detail), face by   Giuseppe Cas'glione (Lang Shining) 

 Giuseppe  CasGglione,   (Lang Shih‐ning),  1688‐1766  Introduces  The  Vanishing  Point 

Influence of Western PerspecGve in  Qianlong Scrolls  Qianlong Scroll Number 4 by  Xu Yang  

Qianlong Scroll Number 4 by Xu Yang More concerned with reproducing how the eye sees than in Kangxi scrolls.  Xu Yang maintains consistent vanishing points throughout duraGon of scroll.  

Qianlong Scroll Number 6 by Xu Yang Figures diminish in size and number limiGng informaGon available to viewer. 

This presentation was complied by Robert Ponzio Chair, Fine Arts Department, Oak Hall School, Gainesville in response to the workshop: University of Florida - Asia Studies

Add a comment

Related pages

Comparative Philosophy: Chinese and Western (Stanford ...

... of traditions on their conceptions of the real ... traditional reference to a ... asymmetry between Chinese and Western philosophy.
Read more

Traditional vs. Western Medicine: Which One Is Easier for ...

... because Western and traditional Chinese medicine operate alongside each other there, ... "Traditional vs. Western Medicine: ...
Read more


CULTURE AND CONCEPTIONS OF HAPPINESS: INDIVIDUAL ORIENTED AND SOCIAL ORIENTED SWB ... a Western conception of SWB should ... ally oriented vs. socially ...
Read more

Traditional Chinese Medicine/TCM and Infertility 2

Many doctors of traditional Chinese ... Western medicine tends to approach conception as a full ... with Chinese medicine, but conception is ...
Read more

Western Human Rights in a Diverse World: Cultural ...

Western Human Rights in a Diverse World: Cultural Suppression or Relativism? ... The ethical non-Western conceptions of human ... Individual vs ...
Read more

Chinese Vs. Western Culture | eHow

Chinese Vs. Western Culture. The Chinese culture differs greatly from its ... The conception of self in the Chinese culture differs from the Western ...
Read more

God, Western Concepts of | Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy

Western concepts of God have ranged from the ... While Western philosophy has ... a trend in the conception of God that would increase along ...
Read more

Our Approach | Western Medicine, Functional Medicine ...

Our approach to wellness stems from our extensive training and ... I enrolled in a master’s program studying traditional Chinese ... Conception Wellness ...
Read more

Nature in Chinese Culture | Essay | Heilbrunn Timeline of ...

Nature in Chinese Culture. ... Early Chinese philosophical and historical texts contain sophisticated conceptions of the ... Traditional Chinese Painting ...
Read more