advertisement

Source evaluations

75 %
25 %
advertisement
Information about Source evaluations
Education

Published on March 3, 2014

Author: rayapapaya

Source: slideshare.net

advertisement

SOURCE EVALUATIONS

OKAY, I FOUND SOME SOURCES. NOW WHAT? You need to evaluate them to ensure high quality of scholarship, accuracy, usefulness for your research, and to detect any biases.

2 MAIN TYPES OF SOURCES Both types need to be evaluated, but in different ways…

5 CRITERIA TO CONSIDER 1. Author Authority 2. Audience and Purpose 3. Accuracy and Completeness 4. Footnotes and Documentation 5. Perspective and Bias

Author Authority • Who created the item? • What is his or her affiliation? • What is his or her relationship to the information contained in the source? SECONDARY SOURCE EVALUATION Presnell, Jenny L. The Information-Literate Historian . New York: Oxford University Press, 2007.

Audience & Purpose • Who is the intended audience? • Why was the item created? SECONDARY SOURCE EVALUATION Presnell, Jenny L. The Information-Literate Historian . New York: Oxford University Press, 2007.

Accuracy & Completeness • Is the evidence reliable and up to date? • Are the important points covered? • How does the source compare to other similar sources? • What may have been left out? SECONDARY SOURCE EVALUATION Presnell, Jenny L. The Information-Literate Historian . New York: Oxford University Press, 2007.

Footnotes and Documentation • Are the author's sources in secondary and reference literature clearly identified with complete citations to allow you to find the original source yourself? SECONDARY SOURCE EVALUATION Presnell, Jenny L. The Information-Literate Historian . New York: Oxford University Press, 2007.

Perspective and Bias • How do the author's bias and perspective inform the arguments and evidence presented? SECONDARY SOURCE EVALUATION Presnell, Jenny L. The Information-Literate Historian . New York: Oxford University Press, 2007.

To understand the value and limitations of a source, try to answer the following questions: • Is this source a firsthand account, written by a witness or participant? • Was it written at the time of the event or later? • Is the account based on interviews or evidence from those directly involved? PRIMARY SOURCE EVALUATION Bedford/St. Martin's. "Guidelines for Evaluating Primary Documents." Bedford/St. Martin's. http://www.bedfordstmartins.com/history/modules/guides/guide_documents.htm (accessed October 18, 2010).

To detect biases, try to answer these questions: • Did the author have a stake in how an event was remembered? • Did he or she want this issue to be perceived in a particular way? • Was the author writing for a specific audience? PRIMARY SOURCE EVALUATION Bedford/St. Martin's. "Guidelines for Evaluating Primary Documents." Bedford/St. Martin's. http://www.bedfordstmartins.com/history/modules/guides/guide_documents.htm (accessed October 18, 2010).

If possible, compare several primary sources against each other to determine reliability and accuracy. If they conflict, consider why this might be. PRIMARY SOURCE EVALUATION Bedford/St. Martin's. "Guidelines for Evaluating Primary Documents." Bedford/St. Martin's. http://www.bedfordstmartins.com/history/modules/guides/guide_documents.htm (accessed October 18, 2010).

TO RECAP, CONSIDER:

Add a comment

Related presentations

Related pages

Source of Evaluations and Expectations for Performance

Source of Evaluations and Expectations for Performance * MURRAY WEBSTER, JR. Johns Hopkins University In an experimental test of a formal theory relating ...
Read more

Evaluation - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Not all evaluations serve the same purpose some evaluations serve a ... with clear explanations of evaluation methodologies, approaches, sources of ...
Read more

Purdue OWL: Evaluating Sources of Information

Evaluating sources of information is an important step in any research activity. This section provides information on evaluating bibliographic citations ...
Read more

Source Evaluations - Simmons College

Source Evaluations. Purpose. The purpose of this assignment is to familiarize students with a range of standard and specialized reference sources and to ...
Read more

Conflicting Sources of Evaluations - JSTOR

Conflicting Sources of Evaluations* BARBARA I. SOBIESZEK University of Rochester MURRAY WEBSTER, JR. Johns Hopkins University A theory of the effects of ...
Read more

Topics Evaluations | EdSource

Teaching Evaluations. Requirements for teacher and administrator evaluations are loosely defined in California’s Stull Act, the evaluation law whose ...
Read more

Source code evaluations for Reliance Nitro, Reliance Edge ...

Source code evaluations for Reliance Nitro, Reliance Edge, FlashFX Tera and FlashFXe. Our products are available in ...
Read more

Course Evaluations | Open Source Research Group

Student Evaluations of Courses. This is a 5-year sliding window over student evaluations of the electives (Wahlpflicht) we teach. Please note that courses ...
Read more

Example Source Evaluations

Example Source Evaluations Each of these is written as a single paragraph, which you are welcome to do. If you’d prefer to list the information gathered ...
Read more

Source Evaluations for Drinking Age Topic

Source Evaluations for Drinking Age Topic The Amethyst Initiative is a group of college and university administrators. They have relevant expertise (what ...
Read more