Published on March 14, 2014
How Can We Scale Land Based Social Enterprise? Learning Lessons from Social Innovation
Today’s workshop • About the research • Case study overviews – relevance to land based social enterprise • Break • Concepts and tools – putting it into practice
The Research: Why, Who, How? • Managing environmental assets: the need for innovation • Risks and difficulties in scaling social movements • Our approach: critically examine the development trajectory of other community led social innovations • Methodology: desk research, case studies, interviews with the final five sectors • Outputs: informing the innovation debate- blog posts, workshop, audience summaries, final report and….
Innovation is…. the process by which an idea that is new to an organisation gives rise to a new set of activities the process that starts with the emergence of an idea that is developed into a new set of organizational activities, technologies, products, or service a process not an outcome, it can have positive and negative spin offs a pathology that can hinder the development of a social organisation
Social innovation is… a new idea that meets unmet needs good ideas that, when applied, work to generate social value and drive changes in established culture, behaviours or organisational systems a complex process that profoundly changes the basic routines, resource and authority flows, or beliefs of the social system in which it occurs
… about system change Social entrepreneurship: how an individual operates Social enterprise: how an organisation operates Social innovation: how a system operates
Scaling Scaling is: • extending the value of the investments made • doing more of A or doing A better to generate more of B • “expanding impact” not “becoming large” Scaling can happen by: • Organisational / sectoral growth • Directed diffusion • Takeover or emulation • Diffusion
HIV/AIDs Community-Led Health Services History: • Epidemic - fear, ignorance, isolation, stigma, & outrage Form: • Community groups and charities providing services, campaigning Development: • Statutory funding, changing patient demography and new activities • Mergers between NGOs, government partnerships and competition Getty Images
HIV/AIDs Community Led Health Services Themes: • The freedom to innovate, experiment and to criticise systems • A trade-off between service provision and campaigns, professionalism and volunteers, community involvement • Distortions caused by large amounts of central funding and changes in policy focus and priority • Tensions between the need for national plans and local knowledge
Development Trusts History • 1970s formal origin, surge since 2000s from public bodies Form • Communities focused on an asset, diverse spectrum of uses and arrangements, shifting mix of income Development • Growing push from government and local authorities
Development Trusts Themes: • Replication allowing diversity to be maintained, each meeting local needs • Strongly focused on localities so need to balance scaling and innovation • As public bodies ‘push’ for asset transfer, but with reduced support - trusts (and others) may take on too much, acquire liabilities • Does taking on ownership of assets help or hinder the delivery of an organisation’s social value?
Community Recycling History • Excess waste from throwaway products, decline in municipal recycling collection Form • Collection groups with grants, job creation income and sale of materials Development • Easy availability of money and legislative change • Bidding for local authority contracts, competing with private sector who appropriated their innovation and shut them out, social value lost Plastics and the lorax
Community Recycling Themes: • Move from community pull to government and funding pull • Importance of financing, leadership and administration • Scaling vs. continuous innovation / diversification • Impact vs. value - what is lost when an innovation mainstreams in this way?
The Land Management Sector Supply side • Large numbers of small groups • Often informal • Range of forms and motivations • Traditional “friends of groups” • Organised, values-driven groups • People meeting their own needs • Unorthodox groups Demand side • An openness to new approaches from (some) public landowners • Linked to austerity and budget cuts • Localism agenda is helping provide legitimacy & a framework - but no funding • Enthusiasm from (some) individuals within landowning organisations • Barriers to implementing new practices
DISCUSSION • What resonates? • What is relevant for the land-based sector? • What is different with land?
Local Food Growing History • Food scares, health and localism concerns Form • Diverse groups with sales, volunteers and external funds Development • Big Lottery and government pushing with programmes • Network of local providers / producers must be rebuilt - possibility of ‘local food hubs’ Local food network
Local Food Growing Themes • Striking a balance between being ‘good’ and being a business • Scaling means networks – an ecology of producers, processers, retailers • Practitioners feel the need for policy changes e.g. planning, investment and definitions to help – what does ‘local food’ mean?
Community Energy History • Rising energy costs, energy security, environmental concerns Form • Renewable energy generation (of different forms) and energy efficiency • Partly or wholly owned by the local community, majority at least partially grant funded Development • Sector growing with some policy push, government programmes, feed in tariffs, and strategies, though infrastructure needed badly. Click Green
Community Energy Themes • The need for external input - finance, infrastructure, policy • Financial concerns seen as a ‘trojan horse’ to produce social value • Practitioners fearful of appropriation/abuse by private sector
How Can We Scale Land Based Social Enterprise? Learning Lessons from Social Innovation
Key Concepts and Tools • Push vs pull • Types of scaling vs transferability of knowledge • Scaling vs innovation • Social impact vs social value • Niche vs mainstream
Pull vs push • Demand side “pull” Recognition of needs that are not being adequately met, by social entrepreneurs and campaigners, who then seek to address these needs • Supply side “push” Social entrepreneurs and campaigners are encouraged by funders and policy-makers to meet needs through a particular innovation
Scaling vs replicability Controlled Uncontrolled Low replicability High replicability Organisational growth Directed diffusion Takeover or emulation Diffusion HIV Recycling Asset transfer Energy Food
Scaling vs innovation • scaling successful past innovations may make future innovations less productive • scaling of a single service mitigates against trying new approaches, leading to scale rather than radical innovation • ongoing cycles of innovation may make scaling less productive • pushing innovation at the expense of strengthening more routine activities may actually destroy rather than create value
Social impact vs social value Social impact: the value created for beneficiaries, society, and the world - value that cannot be reduced to economic wealth for owners or consumption benefits for customers • Social value = the how e.g. creating training and employment opportunities or building social capital • Social impact = the what e.g. normalising recycling or changing the face of palliative care
Niche vs mainstream “If the private sector comes into a niche market, open up and let the service get mainstreamed – move on, create new products and services, and conquer new markets” - Liam Black
Discussion 1. What resonates for you / your organisation? 2. What feels useful about these concepts? 3. What feels difficult about these concepts? 4. How / when might you use them? 5. What would help you in using them in your own context? e.g. toolkit / checklist / video / animation etc
Social innovation includes the social processes of innovation, ... Social innovation can take place within government; ... like social enterprise, ...
We can see that innovation is not ... Helping to grow the reach and scale of the innovation within ... Tides is a unique social enterprise organized as ...
... (especially when contrasted with Social Businesses). Social enterprise can ... Social Enterprise Network. Its members, based ... social innovation, ...
... business with a social or environmental mission. We support business where society ... And Social Enterprise UK members can post their jobs for free.
The Centre for Social Action aims to ... in 215 social action projects. We have also developed ... Centre for Social Action Innovation ...
... structures of government and business can scale up to effect widespread social ... Social Enterprise ... Social Innovation ...
What is a Social Entrepreneur? Over ... that citizens who channel their ideas into action can do almost anything. Why "Social ... of the Land Gift ...
Welcome to SkollWorldForum.org former Social Edge ... closed as we have focused efforts on the ... and comments have been saved and can be ...
Now let’s look at our list of 22 Awesome Social Enterprise Ideas! Social ... Workshop; Social Enterprise ... can unsubscribe at any time, but we ...