Search Strings Presentation IASL 2007

50 %
50 %
Information about Search Strings Presentation IASL 2007

Published on July 19, 2007

Author: mmardis

Source: slideshare.net

Using Transaction Logs to Characterize User Needs Search Analysis of a Digital Library for Educators Marcia A. Mardis, EdD Assistant Professor Wayne State University

Michigan Teacher Network (MTN) Founded in 1998 Moved and renamed Michigan Educators’ Resources in Feb. 2007 ~8500 professional learning, support, and curriculum resources Received additional funding from the NSF 500,000 (summer)-700,000(fall/winter) page views per day 750 (summer)-1000 (fall/winter) search strings per day Governed by privacy policies

Founded in 1998

Moved and renamed Michigan Educators’ Resources in Feb. 2007

~8500 professional learning, support, and curriculum resources

Received additional funding from the NSF

500,000 (summer)-700,000(fall/winter) page views per day

750 (summer)-1000 (fall/winter) search strings per day

Governed by privacy policies

What do search logs say? Characterize user sessions Time of day (and length of time) Characterize of user queries Number of revisions Number of terms used Use of logic and advanced search techniques Characterize search terms Topic Frequency of terms

Characterize user sessions

Time of day (and length of time)

Characterize of user queries

Number of revisions

Number of terms used

Use of logic and advanced search techniques

Characterize search terms

Topic

Frequency of terms

Key IS Researchers & Studies Spink, Jansen, Wolfram & Saracevic (2000, 2001, 2002) Excite studies Not always naughty stuff Frameworks, general taxonomies Bryan-Kinns & Blandford (2000, 2001) Digital library Transaction Log Analysis (vs. Web TLA) Interactional traps (misunderstanding; premature bailout)

Spink, Jansen, Wolfram & Saracevic (2000, 2001, 2002)

Excite studies

Not always naughty stuff

Frameworks, general taxonomies

Bryan-Kinns & Blandford (2000, 2001)

Digital library Transaction Log Analysis (vs. Web TLA)

Interactional traps (misunderstanding; premature bailout)

Key IS Researchers & Studies Silverstein & Henziger (1999) AltaVista search logs Comparison of theoretical vs. actual user models Abbas (2002) ARTEMIS Influence of metadata and search scaffolds

Silverstein & Henziger (1999)

AltaVista search logs

Comparison of theoretical vs. actual user models

Abbas (2002)

ARTEMIS

Influence of metadata and search scaffolds

Consistent IS Study Findings Few queries use advanced search features like boolean; that do contain mistakes Highly skewed use of terms : few used a lot, a lot used infrequently Distribution of terms bears no relation to distribution of content Users look mainly at the first page of results Most sessions contain only 1 query Most queries are very short ( 3 terms or less )

Few queries use advanced search features like boolean; that do contain mistakes

Highly skewed use of terms : few used a lot, a lot used infrequently

Distribution of terms bears no relation to distribution of content

Users look mainly at the first page of results

Most sessions contain only 1 query

Most queries are very short ( 3 terms or less )

Key TE Researchers & Studies Teacher concerns Classroom discipline Serving diverse learning needs and special education Teaching out of immediate field Teacher use of technology Access  Use Teachers need scaffolding

Teacher concerns

Classroom discipline

Serving diverse learning needs and special education

Teaching out of immediate field

Teacher use of technology

Access  Use

Teachers need scaffolding

Key TE Researchers & Studies Teachers’ information seeking behaviors Teachers ask colleagues (D. Williams, 2004) Teachers search like humans search (D. Williams, 2004; Hanson & Carlson, 2004; T. Williams, 2005) Teachers seek specific kinds of information (Mardis & Hoffman, 2005, 2006; Fitzgerald, et al 2004, etc.) Local Curriculum linked Classroom management ( Mardis, in press ) Teachers adapt and adopt resources

Teachers’ information seeking behaviors

Teachers ask colleagues (D. Williams, 2004)

Teachers search like humans search (D. Williams, 2004; Hanson & Carlson, 2004; T. Williams, 2005)

Teachers seek specific kinds of information (Mardis & Hoffman, 2005, 2006; Fitzgerald, et al 2004, etc.)

Local

Curriculum linked

Classroom management ( Mardis, in press )

Teachers adapt and adopt resources

Research Questions What do MTN users look for? To what extent do their search behaviours reflect what we know about user behaviors and teachers’ concerns? When do MTN users look for information? What might this tell us about who is using the digital library?

What do MTN users look for? To what extent do their search behaviours reflect what we know about user behaviors and teachers’ concerns?

When do MTN users look for information? What might this tell us about who is using the digital library?

Characteristics of 2003 Windows 2:38pm 2:40pm 3:12pm Mean time of search 1.99 1.97 2.48 Mean words per string 420 530 776 Mean Searches per day 5896 7462 10870 N 4/29-5/14 3/26-4/9 2/19-3/5

Top Searches 2/19-3/5/2003 58 technology education 64 elementary education 64 economics 71 social studies 90 lesson plans 102 sciences 72 history 91 states 87 sound 300 classroom management

Top Searches 3/26-4/9/2003 31 life science 34 music 35 rainforests 39 weather 41 private schools 47 fractions 51 educational assessment 55 lesson plans 60 physical education 304 classroom management

Top Searches 4/29- 5/14/2003 27 organizational skills 28 plagiarism 30 plants 31 zookeeper 37 private schools 41 lesson plans 48 science 109 poetry of kids 146 listserv(s) 180 classroom management

1 3 2

Characteristics of 2004 Windows

Top Searches 2/19-3/5/2004 n=4048 19 ancient Japan 21 science 22 background clipart 22 teacher certification 25 Reading Strategies 31 clipart 36 core democratic values 51 lesson plans 72 solar system 179 classroom management

Top Searches 3/26 - 4/9/2004 N=2083 15 state curriculum guides 16 Michigan Educational Assessment Program 16 school districts 19 public schools 22 "choices and consequences" 22 solar system 24 teacher certification 31 colleges careers 33 lesson plans 163 classroom management

Top Searches 4/29-5/14/2004 N=12723

Characteristics of 2005 1:14 pm 2.5 385 1/1-12/31/2005 Mean time of day Mean words per string Mean Searches per day N=140012

Top Searches 1/1/05-12/31/05 378 Michigan Educational Assessment Program 401 Reference services 532 MEAP 647 Teachers reference 682 Clearinghouses 727 Teacher certification 881 Lesson plans 991 Educational research 2823 Education 4885 Classroom management

Characteristics of 2006 3 Mean words per search 1:07 pm Mean time of day 557 1/1-12/31/2006 Mean searches per day N=178,730

Cumulative Frequencies 04-06 2352 special education and special needs students 3969 teachers reference and teacher certification 1055 Michigan 1275 MEAP 1472 Internet 1659 reference services 1854 lesson plans 3062 clearinghouses 4170 educational research 8586 education 9073 classroom management

Curriculum areas 2004-2006

Implications Searches do reflect educational trends Most searches do not occur late at night (disagree) Users search very broad or very narrow concepts with few terms (agree) Classroom management, MEAP, and job searching queries dominated, then the focus shifts Science is a high need curriculum area

Searches do reflect educational trends

Most searches do not occur late at night (disagree)

Users search very broad or very narrow concepts with few terms (agree)

Classroom management, MEAP, and job searching queries dominated, then the focus shifts

Science is a high need curriculum area

Implications Users repeatedly type in the same search Many users exhibit “Search Engine Habits” Search for items beyond scope of collection Seem to be expecting to search site text, not metadata Perform searches on browsing categories

Users repeatedly type in the same search

Many users exhibit “Search Engine Habits”

Search for items beyond scope of collection

Seem to be expecting to search site text, not metadata

Perform searches on browsing categories

On his way to use MTN/MER? -During & After school -Management issues -Science teaching - New teacher

Users search the strangest things… Ozzy Osbourne cell phone etiquette pet dandruff guys worry Marriage counseling

Ozzy Osbourne

cell phone etiquette

pet dandruff

guys

worry

Marriage counseling

Caveats Are the exhibited searching characteristics due to some unique aspect of the system or collection? Are the user samples from the same or different populations? Are the searching characteristics really applicable to all teacher users? What are the implications of users who do not understand what they are searching (metadata vs. full-text)

Are the exhibited searching characteristics due to some unique aspect of the system or collection?

Are the user samples from the same or different populations?

Are the searching characteristics really applicable to all teacher users?

What are the implications of users who do not understand what they are searching (metadata vs. full-text)

Caveats Are the topic classification schemes used consistently? Is the data collection tool accurate?

Are the topic classification schemes used consistently?

Is the data collection tool accurate?

Add a comment

Related presentations

Related pages

International Association of School Librarianship - Home

IASL 2016 Conference in Tokyo, ... View the conference website for presentation information. ... The International Association of School Librarianship (IASL)
Read more

Searching Multiple PowerPoint & Word Files

Searching Multiple PowerPoint & Word Files ... all occurrences of a string, ... again after you open the presentation." The search 3 file is only 640 ...
Read more

LikeOffice - Excel String Functions

Excel String Functions : Char: Left: Search: Clean: Len: Substitute: Code: Lower: T: Concatenate: Mid: Text: ... text2 is the string to search.
Read more

MS Excel: How to use the SEARCH Function (WS)

The Microsoft Excel SEARCH function returns the location ... It is the position in string where the search will ... Excel 2007, Excel 2003, Excel XP, Excel ...
Read more

MS Excel: How to use the INSTR Function (VBA)

... How to use the INSTR Function ... string The string to search within. ... Excel 2011 for Mac, Excel 2010, Excel 2007, Excel 2003, Excel XP, Excel 2000;
Read more

Using the VLookup Function in Excel 2007

Using the VLookup Function in Excel 2007. Office 2007 Summary: ... Office Excel 2007 contains a number of search functions to address this need.
Read more

vba - How to search for string in an array - Stack Overflow

Or will I need to loop through each element and compare it with the target string? ... How to search for string in ... to search for a string within an ...
Read more

MATERIALS AND METHODS

... computer file types by adding an additional search string in the ... of PPT 2007, the file format of PPT presentations changed and is now ...
Read more

Tips and Techniques for Queries in Access 2007

Tips and Techniques for Queries in Access 2007. ... you need to search for a particular letter or digit. ... The string functions in particular ...
Read more