Ryan Henry

40 %
60 %
Information about Ryan Henry

Published on December 23, 2007

Author: Arley33

Source: authorstream.com

Deterrence and Dissuasion for the 21st Century:  Deterrence and Dissuasion for the 21st Century Ryan Henry Principle Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for Policy IFPA-Fletcher Conference December 14, 2005 UNCLASSIFIED UNCLASSIFIED Overview:  Overview New security environment warrants a review of our approach Shift away from Cold War view of deterrence Develop better understanding of dissuasion and how to operationalize the concept Understand how we can effectively assure our allies Key documents that reflect our strategic shift: Quadrennial Defense Review (2001) Nuclear Posture Review (2002) Report to Congress on Strengthening US Global Defense Posture (2004) National Defense Strategy (2005) Quadrennial Defense Review (2006) Slide3:  Security Challenges Our approach should be tailored to deter and dissuade across the challenges Deterrence: What’s New:  Deterrence: What’s New Deterrence: Why and What:  Deterrence: Why and What Deterrence is generally preferable to going to war because it: Forestalls behavior contrary to US interests Can be less expensive in terms of human, economic, and political costs Conserves national power – but requires a focus of will Strategic interaction(s) in which a party uses threats to forestall adversaries from taking an action(s) that they otherwise would have taken had the threat not been present. The party does so by threatening to: Impose unacceptable costs upon the adversary in response to their action(s) Deny the opponent any prospect of attaining its perceived goals Deterrence requires: The ability to identify and understand that which the adversary holds dear, how it assesses its security situation, and its decision-making processes Having or developing the perceived capabilities and credibility to impose unacceptable costs and/or to deny gains to the adversary The ability to communicate effectively with the adversary Dissuasion: Why and What:  Dissuasion: Why and What To discourage others from developing capabilities and/or adopting courses of action that are hostile to the interests of the United States Dissuasion seeks to shape the nature of military competitions in ways favorable to the United States by: Inducing restraint in the behavior of adversaries; Channeling an opponent’s strategies and resources in less threatening directions; and Complicating an opponent’s military planning Dissuasion could: Make deterrence easier by reducing the robustness of an adversary’s capabilities and strategies and its confidence in them “Buy time” with some adversaries Dissuasion and Deterrence:  Dissuasion and Deterrence Deterrence Deterrence and dissuasion both hinge on understanding and influencing an opponent’s decision-making (e.g., no “mirror imaging”) Dissuasion can be thought of as a kind of “pre-deterrence” -- preventing an adversary from developing: Capabilities before they can be used; and Courses of action before they can be adopted In some circumstances, we may be trying to dissuade adversaries from expanding, improving, or transferring a capability while deterring them from using it TIME Dissuasion Example: Deterrence and dissuasion of an adversary’s capability or course of action Tailored Deterrence:  Tailored Deterrence Violent Extremists Deterring Diverse Audiences:  Deterring Diverse Audiences X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X X x x x x x x x x Volunteers from General Populace Sympathetic Patrons and Supporters Families Figureheads Tribes Cells State Sponsor Org Leaders Is there a “unified field theory” for deterrence? Deterrence and Dissuasion: Violent Extremists:  Deterrence and Dissuasion: Violent Extremists Who: Actors in a violent extremist network, including foot soldiers, leaders, financiers, radical clerics, et. al.; State supporters of terrorist networks; and Elements of the population susceptible to violent extremism Deter what: Members of the network from taking actions hostile to the United States including attacks, terrorist fund raising, preaching of incendiary fatwas, etc.; and States from supporting terrorist networks, most importantly the transfer of WMD Dissuade what: Elements of the population susceptible to violent extremism from supporting or engaging in violent extremism Rogue Powers:  Rogue Powers Who: States that pose significant regional challenges but lack the ability to project traditional military power outside of their region Deter what: A range of actions hostile to U.S. interests Dissuade what: Development, modernization, and expansion of capabilities that pose a significant challenge to the US and its allies Courses of action hostile to key US interests Near-Peer Competitors:  Near-Peer Competitors Who: States with the ability to project power globally Capabilities may include: nuclear weapons, advanced conventional military capability, and other forms of non-military power Deter what: Use of WMD against the United States and its allies Other attacks or coercion against U.S. allies and partners Dissuade what: Development of advanced military capabilities that pose a significant challenge to the US Modernization of existing capabilities that pose a significant challenge to the US Development of hostile courses of action Way Ahead:  Way Ahead USG is focusing its efforts to better understand our adversaries and develop tailored deterrence and dissuasion strategies Need to reinvigorate intellectual debate on deterrence and dissuasion Key to this debate is growing our knowledge of the world views, goals, and strategic approaches of 21st century adversaries Slide14:  BACK UP Deterrence vs. Dissuasion:  Deterrence vs. Dissuasion Deterrence Forestall adversaries from taking hostile action(s) Threats made to convince adversaries that the costs of taking hostile action will outweigh any potential gains Involves threat(s) Addresses more immediate challenge Responsive to a development Enemy understanding of US intent is important for an effective strategy Dissuasion Discourage adversaries, real and potential, from developing hostile capabilities and strategies Measures taken to convince adversaries that the development of hostile military capabilities and strategies will be ineffective, too costly, and/or unattainable Involves positive and negative measures Addresses potential long-term challenge Anticipatory of possible developments Enemy understanding of US intent may be detrimental to an effective strategy Key Tools:  Key Tools Posture Security Cooperation Intelligence Capabilities Strategic Communications

Add a comment

Related presentations

Related pages

Ryan Henry (@TheRyanHenry) | Twitter

64.2K tweets • 3,900 photos/videos • 14.8K followers. Check out the latest Tweets from Ryan Henry (@TheRyanHenry)
Read more

Who Is Ryan Henry, Owner of 9Mag, On 'Black Ink Crew ...

The star of Black Ink Crew: Chicago is Ryan Henry, owner of the tattoo shop 9Mag, which he built in honor of his sister who was murdered by her ex.
Read more

Top 10 Ryan Henry profiles | LinkedIn

View the profiles of professionals named Ryan Henry on LinkedIn. There are 287 professionals named Ryan Henry, who use LinkedIn to exchange information ...
Read more

Ryan Henry - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Ryan Henry; Country (sports) Australia: Residence: Melbourne: Born (1984-10-14) 14 October 1984 (age 31) Forster, New South Wales, Australia: Height: 6 ...
Read more

Ryan McHenry - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Ryan McHenry (13 December 1987 – 2 May 2015) was a Scottish film director best known for the film Zombie Musical in which he received a nomination for ...
Read more

Ryan Henry Profiles | Facebook

View the profiles of people named Ryan Henry. Join Facebook to connect with Ryan Henry and others you may know. Facebook gives people the power to share...
Read more

Ryan Henry (@ryanhenrytattoo) • Instagram photos and videos

Ryan Henry CHICAGO. Mason's Dad. #9MAG. Please email RyanHenryTattoo@gmail.com to schedule appt or inquire www.blackinkcrewchicagopremiere.com
Read more

Ryan Henry - Global Internal Auditor - Bunge | XING

Global Internal Auditor ... XING ist Deutschlands größtes berufliches Netzwerk: Mit XING finden Sie Ihren Traumjob, knüpfen wertvolle Kontakte, tauschen ...
Read more

ryan henry - executive manager - Cypress International | XING

Eckhard Hörner-Marass Executive Interim Manager - CEO/CRO 1. Führungsebene Maschinen-/Anlagenbau Langweid am Lech bei Augsburg
Read more

Ryan Henry - Profile | RAND

Ryan Henry is an adjunct senior fellow at the RAND Corporation. From 2003 to 2008, he served as principal deputy under secretary of defense for Policy.
Read more