rmode potsdam04

50 %
50 %
Information about rmode potsdam04

Published on November 15, 2007

Author: Arley33

Source: authorstream.com

Slide1:  INSTABILITIES OF ROTATING RELATIVISTIC STARS John Friedman University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee Center for Gravitation and Cosmology outline:  I. NONAXISYMMETRIC INSTABILITY II. DYNAMICAL INSTABILITY III. GW-DRIVEN (CFS) INSTABILITY & R-MODES IV. SPIN-DOWN AND GRAVITATIONAL WAVES FROM A NEWBORN NEUTRON STAR V. INSTABIILTY OF OLD NEUTRON STARS SPUN-UP BY ACCRETION VI. DOES THE INSTABILITY SURVIVE THE PHYSICS OF A REAL NEUTRON STAR? (MUCH OF THIS LAST PART TO BE COVERED BY NILS ANDERSSON’S TALK) outline Slide3:  NONAXISYMMETRIC INSTABILITY MINIMIZING ENERGY AT FIXED ANGULAR MOMENTUM: GRAVITY BUT NO ROTATION: MINIMIZE ENERGY BY MAXIMIZING GRAVITATIONAL BINDING ENERGY Slide4:  NONAXISYMMETRIC INSTABILITY MINIMIZING ENERGY AT FIXED ANGULAR MOMENTUM: ROTATION BUT NO GRAVITY, MINIMIZE KINETIC ENERGYAT FIXED J BY PUSHING FLUID TO BOUNDARY Slide5:  NONAXISYMMETRIC INSTABILITY MINIMIZING ENERGY AT FIXED ANGULAR MOMENTUM: RAPID ROTATION AND GRAVITY: COMPROMISE: SEPARATE FLUID INTO TWO SYMMETRIC PARTS Slide6:  DYNAMICAL INSTABILITY GROWS RAPIDLY DYNAMICAL TIMESCALE = TIME FOR SOUND TO CROSS STAR SECULAR INSTABILITY REQUIRES DISSIPATION – VISCOSITY OR GRAVITATIONAL RADIATION SLOWER, DISSIPATIVE TIMESCALE Slide7:  CONSERVATION LAWS BLOCK NONAXISYMMETRIC INSTABILITY IN UNIFORMLY ROTATING STARS UNTIL STAR ROTATES FAST ENOUGH THAT T ( ROTATIONAL KINETIC ENERGY ) . |W| ( GRAVITATIONAL BINDING ENERGY) DYNAMICAL INSTABILITY t= > 0.26 UNIFORMLY ROTATING STARS WITH NS EQUATIONS OF STATE HAVE MAXIMUM ROTATION t < 0.12 Slide8:  Bar-mode instability of rotating disk (Simulation by Kimberly New) BUT A COLLAPSING STAR WITH LARGE DIFFERENTIAL ROTATION MAY BECOME UNSTABLE AS IT CONTRACTS AND SPINS UP Slide9:  TWO SURPRISES FOR LARGE DIFFERENTIAL ROTATION m=2 (BAR MODE) INSTABILITY CAN SET IN FOR SMALL VALUES OF t m=1 (ONE ARMED SPIRAL) INSTABILITY CAN DOMINATE Recent studies of dynamical instability by Gondek-Rosinska and Gourgoulhon Shibata, Karino, Eriguchi, Yoshida Watts, Andersson, Beyer, Schutz Centrella, New, Lowe and Brown Imamura, Durisen, Pickett New, Centrella and Tohline Shibata, Baumgarte and Shapiro Slide10:  GROWTH OF AN l=m=1 INSTABILITY IN A RAPIDLY DIFFERENTIALLY ROTATATING MODEL SAIJO, YOSHIDA Slide11:  SECULAR INSTABILITY cfs1:  If the pattern rotates forward relative to , it radiates positive J to GRAVITATIONAL-WAVE INSTABILITY Chandrasekhar, F, Schutz Outgoing nonaxisymmetric modes radiate angular momentum to cfs1 cfs2:  If the pattern rotates backward relative to , it radiates negative J to cfs2 cfs3:  That is: A forward mode, with J > 0, radiates positive J to A backward mode, with J < 0, radiates negative J to Radiation damps all modes of a spherical star cfs3 cfs4:  But, a rotating star drags a mode in the direction of the star's rotation: A mode with behavior that moves backward relative to the star is dragged forward relative to , when m W > s The mode still has J < 0, because Jstar + J mode < J star . This backward mode, with J < 0, radiates positive J to . Thus J becomes increasingly negative, and THE AMPLITUDE OF THE MODE GROWS cfs4 surprise:  OBSERVATIONAL SUPRISE: 16 ms pulsar seen in a supernova remnant surprise surprise2:  In a young (5000 yr old) supernova remnant in the Large Magellanic Cloud, Marshall et al found a pulsar with a 16 ms period and a spin-down time ~ lifetime of the remnant This, for the first time, implies: A class of neutron stars have millisecond periods at birth. OBSERVATIONAL SUPRISE: 16 ms pulsar seen in a supernova remnant surprise2 th_surprise:  A nearly simultaneous THEORETICAL SURPRISE: A new variant of a gravitational-wave driven instability of relativistic stars may limit the spin of newly formed pulsars and of old neutron stars spun up by accretion. The newly discovered instability may set the initial spin of pulsars in the newly discovered class. th_surprise These surprises led to an explosion of interest: :  Andersson JF, Morsink Kojima Lindblom,Owen, Morsink Owen, Lindblom, Cutler, Andersson, Kokkotas,Schutz Schutz, Vecchio, Andersson Madsen Andersson, Kokkotas, Stergioulas Levin Bildsten Ipser, Lindblom JF, Lockitch Beyer, Kokkotas Kojima, Hosonuma Hiscock Lindblom Brady, Creighton Owen Rezzolla, Shibata, Asada, Lindblom, Mendell, Owen Baumgarte, Shapiro Flanagan Rezzola,Lamb, Shapiro Spruit Levin Ferrari, Matarrese,Schneider Lockitch Rezania Prior work on axial modes: Chandrasekhar & Ferrari These surprises led to an explosion of interest: STILL MORE RECENT :  Stergioulas, Font, Kokkotas Kojima, Hosonuma Yoshida, Lee Rezania, Jahan-Miri Yoshida, Karino, Yoshida, Eriguchi Rezania, Maartens Andersson, Lockitch, JF Lindblom, Mendell Andersson, Kokkotas, Stergioulas Andersson Ushomirsky, Cutler, Bildsten Bildsten, Ushomirsky Andersson, Jones, Kokkotas, Brown, Ushomirsky Stergioulas Lindblom,Owen,Ushomirsky Rieutord Wu, Matzner, Arras Ho, Lai Levin, Ushomirsky Madsen Lindblom, Tohline, Vallisneri Stergioulas, Font Arras, Flanagan, Schenk, JF, Lockitch Sa Teukolsky,Wasserman Morsink Jones Lindblom,Owen Ruoff, Kokkotas, Andersson,Lockitch,JF STILL MORE RECENT AND MORE :  Karino, Yoshida, Eriguchi Hosonuma Watts, Andersson Rezzolla,Lamb,Markovic, Arras, Flanagan, Morsink, Shapiro Wagoner, Hennawi, Liu Shenk, Teukolsky, Wasserman Morsink Jones, Andersson, Stergioulas Haensel, Lockitch, Andersson Prix, Comer, Andersson Hehl Gressman, Lin, Suen, Stergioulas, JF Lin, Suen Xiaoping, Xuewen, Miao, Shuhua, Nana Reisnegger, Bonacic Yoon, Langer Drago, Lavagno, Pagliara Drago, Pagliara, Berezhiani Gondek-Rosinska, Gourgoulhon, Haensel Brink, Teukolsky, Wasserman AND MORE Slide22:  ELECTROMAGNETIC RADIATION MASS QUADRUPOLE CHARGE DIPOLE ENERGY RADIATED C Slide23:  ELECTROMAGNETIC RADIATION MASS QUADRUPOLE CHARGE QUADRUPOLE ENERGY RADIATED Slide24:  GRAVITATIONAL RADIATION MASS QUADRUPOLE MASS QUADRUPOLE ENERGY RADIATED Slide25:  AXIAL GRAVITATIONAL RADIATION MASS QUADRUPOLE CURRENT QUADRUPOLE ENERGY RADIATED Slide26:  AXIAL GRAVITATIONAL RADIATION MASS QUADRUPOLE CURRENT QUADRUPOLE ENERGY RADIATED Slide27:  PERTURBATIONS WITH ODINARY (POLAR) PARITY Slide28:  l = 0 Slide29:  l = 0 Slide30:  PERTURBATIONS WITH AXIAL PARITY BECAUSE ANY SCALAR IS A SUPERPOSITION OF Ylm AND Ylm HAS, BY DEFINITION, POLAR PARITY, EVERY SCALAR HAS AXIAL PARITY: BUT VECTORS (& TENSORS) CAN HAVE AXIAL PARITY Slide31:  l = 0 NONE l = 1 Slide32:  l = m = 2 View from pole View from equator Slide33:  l = 0 NONE l = 1 l = 2 Below equator Slide34:  GROWTH TIME: ENERGY PUMPED INTO MODE = ENERGY RADIATED TO I+ Slide36:  THE QUADRUPOLE POLAR MODE (f-mode ) HAS FREQUENCY s OF ORDER THE MAXIMUM ANGULAR VELOCITY WMAX OF A STAR. INSTABILITY OF POLAR MODES Slide37:  THAT MEANS A BACKWARD MOVING POLAR MODE IS DRAGGED FORWARD, ONLY WHEN A STAR ROTATES NEAR ITS MAXIMUM ANGULAR VELOCITY, WMAX Stergioulas Slide38:  BECAUSE AN AXIAL PERTURBATION OF A SPHERICAL STAR HAS NO RESTORING FORCE – ITS FREQUENCY VANISHES. IN A ROTATING STAR IT HAS A CORIOLIS-LIKE RESTORING FORCE, PROPORTIONAL TO W Slide39:  THE UNSTABLE l = m = 2 r-MODE Newtonian: Papaloizou & Pringle, Provost et al, Saio et al, Lee, Strohmayer The mode is a current that is odd under parity dv = r2 r [ sin2 q ei(2f + 2/3 Wt) ] Frequency relative to a rotating observer: sR = 2/3 W COUNTERROTATING R Slide40:  FLOW PATTERN OF THE l = m = 2 r-MODE Slide41:  Rotating Frame Animation shows backward (clockwise) motion of pattern and motion of fluid elements Ben Owen’s animation Slide42:  Inertial Frame Pattern moves forward (counterclockwise) Star and fluid elements rotate forward more rapidly VISCOUS DAMPING:  Above 1010K, beta decay and inverse beta decay n Below 109K, shear viscosity (free e-e scattering) dissipates the mode’s energy in heat tSHEAR = CT-2 produce neutrinos that carry off the energy of the mode: bulk viscosity tBULK = CT6 VISCOUS DAMPING Slide44:  105 107 109 1011 (From Lindblom-Owen-Morsink Figure) Temperature (K) Wcrit/Wmax 1 0.5 0.1 Star is unstable only when W is larger than critical frequency set by bulk and shear viscosity Star spins down as it radiates its angular momentum in gravitational waves GRAVITATIONAL WAVES FROM SPIN-DOWN :  hc = 1024 (W/WK)3 (20 Mpc/D) a AMPLITUDE, dv/RW Owen, Lindblom, Cutler, Schutz, Vecchio, Andersson Brady, Creighton Owen Lindblom GRAVITATIONAL WAVES FROM SPIN-DOWN Slide46:  GRAVITATIONAL WAVES FROM SPIN-DOWN hc = 1024 (W/WK)3 (20 Mpc/D) a AMPLITUDE, dv/RW IF ONE HAD A PRECISE TEMPLATE, SIGNAL/NOISE WOULD LOOK LIKE THIS FOR WAVES FROM A GALAXY 20 Mpc AWAY: Slide47:  GRAVITATIONAL WAVES FROM SPIN-DOWN With sensitivity 10 times greater, one may be able to detect a cosmological background of waves emitted by past GW-driven spin-downs Ferrari, Matarrese, Schneider Slide48:  INSTABILITY OF OLD ACCRETING STARS: LMXBs Slide49:  BINARIES WITH A NEUTRON STAR AND A SOLAR-MASS COMPANION CAN BE OBSERVED AS LOW-MASS X-RAY BINARIES (LMXBs), WHEN MATTER FROM THE COMPANION ACCRETES ONTO THE NEUTRON STAR. MYSTERY: THE MAXIMUM PERIODS CLUSTER BELOW 642 HZ, WITH THE FASTEST 3 WITHIN 4% Slide50:  FASTEST 3: 619 Hz, 622 Hz, 642 Hz From Chakrabarty, Bildsten VERY DIFFERENT MAGNETIC FIELDS – IMPLIES SPIN NOT LIMITED BY MAGNETIC FIELD Slide51:  PAPALOIZOU & PRINGLE, AND WAGONER (80s) ACCRETION MIGHT SPIN UP A STAR UNTIL J LOST IN GW = J GAINED IN ACCRETION FOR POLAR MODES, VISCOSITY OF SUPERFLUID DAMPS THE INSTABILITY AND RULES THIS OUT BUT AXIAL MODES CAN BE UNSTABLE Andersson, Kokkotas, Stergioulas Bildsten Levin Wagoner Heyl Owen Reisenegger & Bonacic R-MODE INSTABILITY IS NOW A LEADING CANDIDATE FOR LIMIT ON SPIN OF OLD NSs Slide52:  CAN GW FROM LMXBs BE OBSERVED? IF WAGONER’S PICTURE IS RIGHT, R-MODES ARE AN ATTRACTIVE TARGET FOR OBSERVATORIES WITH THE SENSITIVITY OF ADVANCED LIGO WITH NARROW BANDING BUT YURI LEVIN POINTED OUT THAT IF THE VISCOSITY DECREASES AS THE UNSTABIILITY HEATS UP THE STAR, A RUNAWAY GROWTH IN AMPLITUDE RADIATES WAVE TOO QUICKLY TO HOPE TO SEE A STAR WHEN IT’S UNSTABLE Slide53:  LEVIN’S CYCLE T 107 108 109 Wcritical .Wmax SPIN DOWN TIME < 1/106 SPIN UP TIME IS A STAR YOU NOW OBSERVE SPINNING DOWN? PROBABILITY < 1/106 Slide54:  POSSIBLE WAY OUT (Wagoner, Andersson, Heyl) AS WE MENTION LATER, DISSIPATION IN A QUARK OR HYPERON CORE CAN INCREASE AS TEMPERATURE INCREASES: T 109 109.5 108.5 108 Wcritical (Hz) Slide55:  DOES THE INSTABILITY SURVIVE THE PHYSICS OF A REAL NEUTRON STAR? Will nonlinear couplings limit the amplitude to dv/v << 1? Will a continuous spectrum from GR or differential rotation eliminate the r-modes? Will a viscous boundary layer near a solid crust windup of magnetic-field from 2ndorder differential rotation of the mode bulk viscosity from hyperon production kill the instability? Slide56:  Will nonlinear couplings limit the amplitude to dv/v << 1? Slide57:  Fully nonlinear numerical evolutions show no evidence that nonlinear couplings limiting the amplitude to dv/v < 1: Nonlinear fluid evolution in GR Cowling approximation (background metric fixed) Font, Stergioulas Newtonian approximation, with radiation-reaction term GRR enhanced by huge factor to see growth in 20 dynamical times. Lindblom, Tohline, Vallisneri Slide58:  GR Evolution Font, Stergioulas Slide59:  Newtonian evolution with artificially enhanced radiation reaction Lindblom, Tohline, Vallisneri Slide60:  BUT Work to 2nd order in the perturbation amplitude shows TURBULENT CASCADE The energy of an r-mode appears in this approximation to flow into short wavelength modes, with the effective dissipation too slow to be seen in the nonlinear runs. Arras, Flanagan, Morsink, Schenk, Teukolsky,Wasserman Brink, Teukolsky, Wasserman (Maclaurin) Slide61:  Newtonian evolution with somewhat higher resolution, w/ and w/out enhanced radiation-driving force Gressman, Lin, Suen, Stergioulas, JF Catastrophic decay of r-mode Slide62:  Fourier transform shows sidebands - apparent daughter modes. Slide63:  RELATIVISTIC r-MODES Andersson, Kojima, Lockitch, Beyer & Kokkotas, Kojima & Hosonuma, Lockitch, Andersson, JF, Lockitch&Andersson, Kokkotas & Ruoff Slide64:  Newtonian axial mode Relativistic corrections to the l=m=2 r-mode mix axial and polar parts to 0th order in rotation. r/R 1 0 Lockitch Slide65:  Lockitch Lockitch, Andersson, JF Slide66:  Will a continuous spectrum from GR or differential rotation eliminate the r-modes? IN A SLOW-ROTATION APPROXIMATION, AXIAL PERTURBATIONS OF A NON-BARATROPIC STAR SATISFY A SINGULAR EIGENVALUE PROBLEM (Kojima), [s – mW + (W-w)/l(l+1)] hrr + Ahr+Bh= 0. IF THE COEFFICIENT OF hrr VANISHES IN THE STAR, THERE IS NO SMOOTH EIGENFUNCTION. Slide67:  INSTEAD, THE SPECTRUM IS CONTINUOUS. THIS COULD BE DUE TO THE APPROXIMATION’S ARTIFICIALLY REAL FREQUENCY AND WHEN THE STAR IS NEARLY BARATROPIC, AXIAL AND POLAR PERTURBATIONS MIX THE KOJIMA EQUATION IS NOT VALID. Lockitch, Andersson, JF Andersson, Lockitch Slide68:  BUT NEWTONIAN STARS WITH SOME DIFFERENTIAL ROTATION LAWS ALSO MAY HAVE A CONTINUOUS SPECTRUM Karino, Yoshida, Eriguchi NUMERICAL EVOLUTION OF SLOWLY ROTATING MODELS SEEM TO SHOW THAT AN r-MODE IS APPROXIMATELY PRESENT, EVEN WHEN NO EXACT MODE EXISTS. Kokkotas, Ruoff BUT THAT APPROXIMATE MODE DISAPPEARS WHEN THE SINGULAR POINT IS DEEP IN THE STAR. STILL HAVE UNSTABLE INITIAL DATA (JF, Morsink) BUT GROWTH TIME MAY BE LONG Slide69:  VISCOUS BOUNDARY LAYER NEAR CRUST (NILS ANDERSSON’S TALK) Bildsten, Ushomirsky Rieutord Wu, Matzner, Arras Lindblom, Owen, Ushom. Levin, Ushomirsky Andersson, Jones, Kokkotas, Yoshida Stergioulas Slide70:  VISCOUS BOUNDARY LAYER NEAR CRUST VISCOSITY MUCH HIGHER NEAR CRUST: SHEAR DISSIPATION: dE/dt = -2h dV (ds)2 Boundary width d Bulk ds ~ dv/d ds ~ dv/R dE/dt (boundary) ~ (R/ d ) dE/dt(core) But, we don’t know to what extent the crust moves with the modes. Slide71:  (Prepared by Ben Owen) Red curves show the much higher shear viscosity when a crust is present (for upper red curve, a superfluid has formed) Slide72:  DOES NONLINEAR EVOLUTION LEAD TO DIFFERENTIAL ROTATION THAT DISSIPATES r-MODE ENERGY IN A MAGNETIC FIELD? Spruit Rezzola, Lamb, Shapiro Levin, Ushomirsky R, Markovic, L, S A computation of the 2nd order r-mode of rapidly rotating Newtonian (Maclaurin) models and slowly rotating polytropes shows growing differential rotation Sa JF, Lockitch Slide73:  A GROWING MAGNETIC FIELD DAMPS INSTABILITY WHEN tGW /tB > 1 B-field 1010 G to 1012 G allows instability for 2 days to 15 minutes Rezzolla, Lamb, Markovic, Shapiro Slide74:  GRAVITATIONAL WAVES FROM SPIN-DOWN WITH DAMPING BY MAGNETIC FIELD WINDUP Slide75:  FINALLY Will bulk viscosity from hyperon production kill the instability? P.B. Jones Lindblom, Owen Haensel, et al Slide76:  n n Slide77:  d u d n n u s p Slide78:  p Slide79:  n p n Slide80:  p V Equilibrium With no neutrinos emitted, dissipation comes from the net p dV work done in an out-of-equilibrium cycle Slide81:  With no neutrinos emitted, dissipation comes from the net p dV work done in an out-of-equilibrium cycle p V The work is the energy lost by the fluid element in one oscillation Slide82:  105 107 109 1011 (From Lindblom-Owen-Morsink Figure) Temperature (K) W/WK 1 0.5 0.1 Bulk viscosity from hyperons cuts off instability below a few x 109 K Bulk viscosity kills instability at high temperature Slide83:  Density above which the core has hyperons is not well understood. Few hyperons at low density implies few hyperons at low mass: Critical angular velocities for an EOS allowing hyperons above 1.25 M . Lindblom-Owen Slide84:  T 109 109.5 108.5 108 Wcritical (Hz) OLD ACCRETING NEUTRON STARS HIGHER MASSES, SO MORE LIKELY TO HAVE HYPERON OR QUARK CORES. REACTION RATES IN CORE INCREASE WITH T. BULK VISCOSITY INCREASES WITH T Slide85:  Young stars: Nothing yet definitively kills the r-mode instability in nascent NSs, but there are too many plausible ways it may be damped to bet in favor of its existence. Old stars: Surprisingly, the nonlinear limit on amplitude and the more efficient damping mechanisms allowed by hyperon or quark cores enhance the probability of seeing gravitational waves from r-mode unstable LMXBs

Add a comment

Related presentations

Related pages

Jackpot Potsdam in Potsdam | Die-oeffnungszeiten.de

Opening times of Jackpot Potsdam, Brandenburgerstr. 62, 14467 Potsdam (Kleidung und Mode, Damenbekleidung)
Read more

Mode Express - Potsdam in Potsdam | Die-oeffnungszeiten.de

Opening times of Mode Express - Potsdam, Friedrich-Ebert-Strasse 14, 14467 Potsdam (Kleidung und Mode, Damenbekleidung, Herrenmoden)
Read more

Weiterbildung in Potsdam - WBS TRAINING AG

Weiterbildung in Potsdam bei der WBS TRAINING AG. Bildungsgutschein geförderte Kurse und offene Seminare von Ihrem anerkannten Bildungsträger.
Read more

Potsdam 04 - YouTube

Hans-Otto-Theater @ LOCALIZE Potsdam 04 - Duration: 4:32. by queerkopf 188 views. ... Restricted Mode: Off History Help
Read more

Vergangene Termine - mod.EEM - modulares ...

CEB® CLEAN ENERGY BUILDING - Internationale Fachmesse und Kongress für Energieeffiziente Gebäude, Technische Gebäudeausrüstung und Regenerative ...
Read more

Medienboard - Veranstaltungskalender

Medienboard Berlin-Brandenburg ... Festivals, Kongresse, Podiumsdiskussionen oder Netzwerkveranstaltungen - hier finden Sie Termine von Veranstaltungen des ...
Read more

Katzen in Potsdam - FOCUS Online Kleinanzeigen

Mode, Wellness & Beauty; Tiere; Dienstleistungen ; Anmelden | Registrieren. ... Potsdam. 04.01.2016. Hallo ich und meine Freundin suchen auf diesen Weg 2 ...
Read more

Veranstaltungen - Zentrum für Zeithistorische Forschung ...

Potsdam: 04.02.2016: ZZF-Institutskolloquium im Wintersemester 2015/16 Benno Nietzel (Bielefeld): Propaganda, Feindbeobachtung und Kommunikationsforschung ...
Read more

Dachgeschosswohnung Potsdam - wohnung kaufen

Mode, Wellness & Beauty; Tiere; Dienstleistungen ; Anmelden | Registrieren. Was: Kategorie: Wo: Immobilien / Wohnung kaufen / ... Potsdam. 04.12.2015.
Read more