Preparing and Presenting a Judicial Review

55 %
45 %
Information about Preparing and Presenting a Judicial Review
Business & Mgmt

Published on November 13, 2013

Author: rdsadvocate

Source: slideshare.net

Description

An updated version of a presentation given to law students at Glasgow University on the matters that need to be thought about when preparing a presenting a judicial review case in the Court of Session.

Preparing and Presenting a Judicial Review Robert Sutherland, Advocate Terra Firma Chambers

Petitioner What are you wanting to review? • a decision? • an action? • a policy? • an omission?

Petitioner The appropriate procedure? right of appeal? restrictions on grounds for appealing? restrictions on who can appeal? necessary? other proceedings where same issue relevant?

Petitioner individual, group or representative? Who Is Petitioner standing? funding? Axa General Insurance Co. Ltd v Lord Advocate, 2012 SC (UKSC) 122 Walton v The Scottish Ministers, 2013 (UKSC) 67 McGinty v Scottish Ministers, [2013] CSIH 78

Petitioner Who is Respondent Interested Party • decision maker / policy maker? • UK Minister or Scottish Government? • who else has an interest in outcome? • “devolution issue” (Scotland Act 1998, Sched. 6)?

Petitioner Remedies reduction? specific implement?

Petitioner • Rules of the Court of Session, Chapter 58A Protective Expenses Orders • R (Corner House Research) v The Secretary of State for Trade and Industry, [2005] 1 WLR 2600 • Newton Mearns Residents Flood Prevention Group for Cheviot Drive v East Renfrewshire Council, [2013] CSIH 70

Petitioner Grounds? • illegality (inc. human rights breaches) • “Wednesbury” unreasonableness • procedural impropriety • legitimate expectation

The Petition Form Structure Style • RCS, Form 58.6 • parties • concise • productions? • subject matter • clear • other relevant documents • grounds for review • consistent • remedies • pleas-in-law • Schedules and notice period

The Petition Issues to be anticipated delay • Human Rights Act 1998, Section 7(5) • mora, taciturnity and acquiescence • Portobello Park Action Group v City of Edinburgh Council, 2012 SLT 1137 PN No. 1 of 2012 immigration and asylum - prior notification caveats interim orders balance of convenience transfer to Upper Tribunal?

Respondent Standing Competency Merits Delay

First Orders caveat? interim orders? intimation and service first hearing date answers?

First Hearing Introductions Identify bare background and main issues Outline structure of submission The legal framework The factual background Where the Respondent has gone wrong Pleas-in-law and orders sought

First Hearing The Respondent’s presentation Response? Avizandum

Preparing and Presenting a Judicial Review Robert Sutherland, Advocate Terra Firma Chambers

Add a comment

Related presentations

Related pages

Judicial Review - Supreme Court BC

Judicial reviews are started by filing a document called a petition. (Petitions are discussed below.) ... Preparing for a judicial review application
Read more

Judicial Review, | LinkedIn

View 13024 Judicial Review, ... Judicial Review at 3PB, Judicial Assistant to Lord ... Preparing and Presenting a Judicial Review. ...
Read more

Clicklaw: Representing Yourself in a Judicial Review

This guide gives an overview of the judicial review process generally, from preparing ... Representing Yourself in a Judicial Review. ... presenting your ...
Read more

Judicial Review – Preparing the claim

Judicial Review . 2013. Preparing a case for Judicial Review. Jenni Richards QC. Preparing a case for Judicial Review. Introduction.
Read more

Appeals - Judicial Reviews

Solomon shepherd solicitors immigration team have years of experience in preparing and presenting Judicial review applications ... way of a Judicial Review.
Read more

ALBA Continuing Education Course 2012 Preparing a case for ...

Preparing a case for Judicial Review Jenni Richards QC . 2 ... for judicial review of a decision in that case, the prosecution must always be
Read more

MODULE 5: PREPARING FOR A JUDICIAL REVIEW

MODULE 5: PREPARING FOR A JUDICIAL REVIEW ... Preparing for the judicial review hearing is similar to the preparation for any Supreme Court
Read more

Preparing for and Presenting Cases in Court

Preparing for and Presenting Cases in Court ... judicial decisions. ... To prepare a case for court, (1) review and evalu-
Read more