Patent Prosecution Lunch Presentation February 2014

33 %
67 %
Information about Patent Prosecution Lunch Presentation February 2014
Business & Mgmt

Published on February 24, 2014

Author: wemmh

Source: slideshare.net

Patent Prosecution Luncheon February 2014

Defective Priority Claim Means No Priority Claim • Each intermediate application in the chain of priority must refer to the prior applications – Ex: If Application C claims priority through Application B to Application A, not only must Application C say so, but Application B must have said that it claims priority to Application A. – “this application” means the present application  Not “application B” when recited in application C  Not “what a reasonable person would understand it to mean in context” – Medtronic CoreValve LLC vs. Edwards Lifesciences Corp. (CAFC Jan 22, 2014)

PTA Calculation • Reminder: – – – – Only applies to applications filed on or after June 8, 1995 Does not extend past a terminal disclaimer Only applies to Plant and Utility patents (not design) Different analysis for applications filed on or after May 29, 2000 Aterm •>14 months from 1st Action •>4 months for PTO to respond to formal transmittal •>4 months for PTO to take action on BPAI or Fed. Ct. action* •>4 months for issuance after payment of issue fee

PTA Calculation • Reminder: – – – – Only applies to applications filed on or after June 8, 1995 Does not extend past a terminal disclaimer Only applies to Plant and Utility patents (not design) Different analysis for applications filed on or after May 29, 2000 Aterm + B term •>3 years from filing before issuance •Subtract continued exam (RCE) •Subtract interference actions •Subtract secrecy orders •Subtract Appeal •Subtract applicant requested delay

PTA Calculation • Reminder: – – – – Only applies to applications filed on or after June 8, 1995 Does not extend past a terminal disclaimer Only applies to Plant and Utility patents (not design) Different analysis for applications filed on or after May 29, 2000 Aterm + B term + Cterm •Add days for interference •Add days for secrecy order •Add days for successful appeal

PTA Calculation • Reminder: – – – – Only applies to applications filed on or after June 8, 1995 Does not extend past a terminal disclaimer Only applies to Plant and Utility patents (not design) Different analysis for applications filed on or after May 29, 2000 Aterm + B term + Cterm - ABoverlap

PTA Calculation • Reminder: – – – – Only applies to applications filed on or after June 8, 1995 Does not extend past a terminal disclaimer Only applies to Plant and Utility patents (not design) Different analysis for applications filed on or after May 29, 2000 Aterm + B term + Cterm - ABoverlap - ACoverlap

PTA Calculation • Reminder: – – – – Only applies to applications filed on or after June 8, 1995 Does not extend past a terminal disclaimer Only applies to Plant and Utility patents (not design) Different analysis for applications filed on or after May 29, 2000 Aterm + B term + Cterm - ABoverlap - ACoverlap - Applicantdelay •>3 months to respond to OAs •Requests for suspension or deferring issuance •Reviving an abandoned application •Late payment of issue fee •Procedural “conversion” of provisional to non-provisional

PTA Calculation • Reminder: – – – – Only applies to applications filed on or after June 8, 1995 Does not extend past a terminal disclaimer Only applies to Plant and Utility patents (not design) Different analysis for applications filed on or after May 29, 2000 Aterm + B term + Cterm - ABoverlap - ACoverlap - Applicantdelay PTA

PTA Calculation • Reminder: – – – – Only applies to applications filed on or after June 8, 1995 Does not extend past a terminal disclaimer Only applies to Plant and Utility patents (not design) Different analysis for applications filed on or after May 29, 2000 Aterm + B term + Cterm - ABoverlap - ACoverlap - Applicantdelay PTA Novartis thought this only applied if the RCE was filed within three years of the filing date. Time consumed by an RCE is subtracted regardless of when the RCE is filed! …But, you can start counting B period again after notice of allowance. Novartis AG v. Lee (CAFC, Jan. 15, 2014)

RCE Impact on PTA • The exclusion from PTA in 35 U.S.C. § 154(b)(1)(B)(ii) excludes from PTA any time consumed by a Request for Continued Examination (RCE), even if that RCE is filed more than 3 years after the “actual filing date” of the patent application. – “ [PTA] time should be calculated by determining the length of the time between the application [filing date] and patent issuance, and then subtracting any [RCE time period] and determining the extent to which result exceeds three years.” – “Such a reading ensures that applicants recover for any ‘delay[s] due to the failure of the [PTO],’ without allowing the applicant to recover for ‘any time consumed by continued examination,’ as the statute requires.” – Novartis AG v. Lee (January 15, 2014)

USPTO Proposed Rule Change • The proposed changes to the rules would require that the "attributable owner" be identified: – at the time an application is filed (or shortly thereafter), – during the pendency of an application when there is a change in the attributable owner (within three months of such change), – at the time the issue fee is paid, – when maintenance fee payments are made, and – if a patent becomes involved in supplemental examination, ex parte reexamination, or a trial proceeding before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board. • Comments on the notice of proposed rulemaking, which must be submitted by March 25, 2014, can be sent by e-mail to AC90.comments@uspto.gov

Add a comment

Related presentations

Related pages

August | 2014 | Woodard, Emhardt, Moriarty, McNett ...

February 2015; December 2014; ... September 2014; August 2014; August 2014 Patent Prosecution Lunch Presentation ... This month’s patent prosecution ...
Read more

Patent Prosecution | LinkedIn

Patent Prosecution Lunch Presentation February 2014. 582 Views. clarkemodet. ... August 2014 Patent Prosecution Lunch Presentation. 394 Views. clarkemodet.
Read more

First Action Interview Program | Woodard, Emhardt ...

First Action Interview Program. Categories. ... February 2015; December 2014; ... Topics covered in this month’s patent prosecution presentation include ...
Read more

Patent Docs: 2014 BIO IPCC Spring Conference

The conference will offer presentations on the following topics: ... February 28, 2014. ... Patent Prosecution; Patent Prosecution ...
Read more

Patent Docs: BIO International Convention 2014 Preview ...

BIO International Convention 2014 ... There will be a focus on the lessons learned from Europe in the launch of the ... Patent Prosecution
Read more

Austin Intellectual Property Law Association

February, 2014 "Patent Law Update: ... "Ethical Issues for Patent Prosecution Attorneys and Patent Litigators ... February CLE Lunch "Taking Design Patents ...
Read more

Resources - Murgitroyd, European Patent & Trade Mark ...

Presentation Slides; 12 November 2014 ... The Enabler for Worldwide Patent Prosecution? ... Presentation Slides; 7 February 2014 ...
Read more

Global Patent Prosecution Highway simplifies existing network

Global Patent Prosecution Highway (PPH) pilot has launched on 6 January, 2014. ... Austrian Patent Office (APO), ...
Read more