Paper critique Part 2 Results Discussion Conclusio

67 %
33 %
Information about Paper critique Part 2 Results Discussion Conclusio

Published on March 9, 2008

Author: physioactive


How to criticise quantitative research? Lecture II – Results, Discussion and Conclusion:  How to criticise quantitative research? Lecture II – Results, Discussion and Conclusion Chee-Wee Tan Queen Margaret University, Edinburgh Section: Results:  Section: Results Were all planned outcomes reported? Anything missing? Is something dubious going on here? Anything added not previous set out? Section: Results - Presentation:  Section: Results - Presentation Were the figures and tables clear? Any misleading figures or tables? Figure A Figure B Section: Results - Analysis:  Section: Results - Analysis Were appropriate statistics used? Were interpretations of analysis reasonable? Any additional tests conducted that were not planned? (c.f. discussion) Common error: If you throw a lot of tests at it, something is bound to stick! Section: Discussion:  Section: Discussion Was a concise summary of the main results offered? Were interpretations of their results reasonable? Guernica – Picasso, Pablo (1881-1973) Section: Discussion:  Section: Discussion Common errors: Non-significant results ignored Non-significant results interpreted as proof of no effect Correlation does not imply causation Ad hominem Appeal to tradition/authority Confirmation bias Etc… Section: Discussion - Application:  Section: Discussion - Application Basic studies - onus on reader to apply it. Sometimes, they do offer potential applications. Clinical – some indication how findings may influence practice Section: Conclusion & Abstract:  Section: Conclusion & Abstract Conclusion consistent with the rest of paper? How to be good at this?:  How to be good at this? Never take any statements at face value. Criticise, criticise, criticise!

Add a comment

Related presentations

Related pages

Writing a Discussion Section - Interprete the Results

In this critical part of the research paper, ... in your discussion section. Whilst your results may not be ... a Paper; 7.5 Example of a Paper 2;
Read more

Writing a Conclusion - Answering the Research Question

Writing a conclusion is the last part of the research paper, ... of the results and discussion. Writing a conclusion involves summing ... 2 Writing a Paper;
Read more

A guide for writing scholarly articles or revi ews for the ...

A guide for writing scholarly articles or reviews for the ... critiques and forum papers. ... between different topics like results and discussion.
Read more

How to write the Results and Discussion - University of ...

How to write the results and discussion. ... Table 2 shows ... Table 3 shows ... Cuddy PG, Elenbaas RM. Evaluating the medical literature Part III: Results ...
Read more

How to critique a journal article - University of Illinois ...

How To Critique A Journal Article Sponsored by The Center for Teaching and Learning at UIS Last Edited 4/9/2009 Page 1 of 2 So your assignment is to ...
Read more

Strategies for Writing a Conclusion - Welcome to LEO ...

Strategies for Writing a Conclusion: Strategies for Writing a Conclusion. ... Your conclusion should be the best part of your paper. A conclusion should.
Read more

Conclusion of a Research Paper: Check Excellent Pieces of ...

Conclusion of a research paper is extremely ... 4 hours when buying a 2 page custom paper. ... of a research paper should be its best part.
Read more

Sample Research Critique Free Essays - Free Term Papers ...

... largest database of quality sample essays and research papers on ... Critique Part 2 This paper will review a ... dementia: results of ...
Read more

How To Write a Psychology Critique Paper - Verywell - Know ...

Psychology students are often asked to write a critique paper, ... 2. Thesis Statement. The final part of your introduction should ... results and discussion.
Read more

Organizing Your Social Sciences Research Paper: 7. The Results

Organizing Your Social Sciences ... how you interpreted the results in the discussion ... your paper. Think of the results section as the ...
Read more