Paper critique Part 1 Introduction Methods

50 %
50 %
Information about Paper critique Part 1 Introduction Methods
Education

Published on January 22, 2008

Author: physioactive

Source: authorstream.com

How to criticise quantitative research? Lecture I – Introduction and Methods:  How to criticise quantitative research? Lecture I – Introduction and Methods Chee-Wee Tan Queen Margaret University, Edinburgh Slide2:  How to criticise research? Am I qualified to criticise research? All papers are not created equal:  All papers are not created equal Don’t take quality of papers for granted. There are as many poorly written papers as there are good ones. And of course, no one is perfect! Criticise papers with a grain of salt, preferably with an entire shaker! Aims:  Aims Know basic structure of papers Systematic reflection of a paper Appreciate some aspects to look out for criticism in each section of a paper Definition of criticise:  Definition of criticise Criticize: to consider the merits and demerits of and judge accordingly (Merriam-Websters Online Dictionary, http://www.m-w.com) Types of papers:  Types of papers Theoretical (formal or qualitative) Experimental Clinical studies Focus of this lecture Quantitative (could be laboratory or clinical) Empirical Methodological Systematic reviews Qualitative (not covered here) Anatomy of a research paper:  Anatomy of a research paper Introduction Hypothesis & Aims Methods Results Discussion Conclusion Paper structure used as critique approach Section: Introduction:  Section: Introduction Background May or may not assume reader’s prior knowledge of topic Important for setting tone of paper Essential info: Relevant background of research question Reason prompting conduct of research Section: Introduction:  Section: Introduction Common errors: Irrelevant information Background not adequate Weak justification Section: Hypothesis & Aims:  Section: Hypothesis & Aims Not usually explicitly stated But should be clear from introduction Common error: The aim is not stuck to in the study Magical appearance of extra aims A word on assumptions:  A word on assumptions All of us hold assumptions Research isn’t exempt Assumptions may be theory, discipline or method related. Questions to ask: What assumptions are explicitly or implicitly held by the researchers? Are the assumptions appropriate? Section: Methods – Research design:  Section: Methods – Research design What sort of research design? Does it do what it says on the tin? Simplest designs comparing differences or finding relationships? Does the context of research allow researcher to make causal inferences? Section: Methods - Recruitment:  Section: Methods - Recruitment How were participants recruited? Any problems with this recruitment approach? Is it ethical? 2 goals of recruitment strategy Comparability of intervention and control groups Confidence in generalisability Avoid selection bias Section: Methods - Groups:  Section: Methods - Groups Method of allocation to groups. Random? Any other procedures randomised? Blinding of researchers and/or participants Is intervention reasonably administered, or similar to practical situations? Validity and reliability of the procedures Procedures standardised? Section: Methods - Analysis:  Section: Methods - Analysis How was sample size determined? Was anticipated power stated explicitly? Were types of analysis and statistical tests planned a priori? Conclusion:  Conclusion Introduction Background and rationale Hypothesis and aims Clearly justified? Assumptions Appropriate? Methods Participants Procedures Planned analysis

Add a comment

Related presentations

Related pages

Step'by-step guide to critiquing research. Part 1 ...

research. Part 1: quantitative research ... Critiquing is a systematic method of ... the introduction to the study ...
Read more

Quantitative Research Critique Paper - transtextsolutions.com

Browse and Read Quantitative Research Critique Paper. Title Type best topics for a research paper PDF research paper on pollution PDF research paper india PDF
Read more

Quantitative Research Critique Paper - kloep.brasilia.me

Browse and Read Quantitative Research Critique Paper. Title Type best topics for a research paper PDF research paper on pollution PDF research paper india PDF
Read more

How To Write A Psychology Critique Paper - Verywell

Psychology students are often asked to write a critique paper, ... to critique. 1. Read the introduction ... methods, or conclusions. Your critique ...
Read more

Quantitative Research Critique Paper - skiodrix.tredx.net

Browse and Read Quantitative Research Critique Paper. Title Type best topics for a research paper PDF research paper on pollution PDF research paper india PDF
Read more

How to critique a journal article - UIS

How To Critique A Journal Article ... approach or methods, hypothesis, ... Is the purpose of the article made clear in the introduction? 4.
Read more

Quantitative Research Critique Paper - rav.informed-ibs.com

Browse and Read Quantitative Research Critique Paper. Title Type best topics for a research paper PDF research paper on pollution PDF research paper india PDF
Read more

Using a Scientific Journal Article to Write a Critical ...

Using a Scientific Journal Article ... "Writing your Critique," discusses two possible ways to structure your critique paper. ... Introduction, Methods, ...
Read more

Writing Methodology - Describing the Data Collection

Writing Methodology at the Core of the Research Paper. ... 5 Parts of a Paper. ... 5.3 Introduction; 5.4 Methods; 5.5 Results; 5.6 Discussion; 5.7 Conclusion;
Read more