Law Cases- Analysis

100 %
0 %
Information about Law Cases- Analysis

Published on March 2, 2014

Author: gsgurpreetsingh30



Law Cases Analysed

State Trading Corporation Vs Commercial Tax Officer


Business Law Presentation Presented By: Gunjan Sachdeva(21/014) Gurpreet Singh(21/015) Jasanpreet Kaur(21/016) Neha Diwakar(21/020) Neha Singh(21/021)

Case I: State Trading Corporation Vs Commercial Tax Officer  Appellant: State Trading Corporation  Respondent: Commercial Tax Officer  Date of Judgement: 26 July 1963

Case Brief:  State Trading Corporation sought relief, in the form of appropriate writs or directions, against various agencies of State Governments on account of Sales Tax assessed against the Corporation.  The petition was filed under Article 32 of the Constitution of India, which empowers the Supreme Court “to issue directions or orders or writs. Appropriate for the enforcement of the fundamental rights.”  The Corporation contested the claims saying that it is Government company, hence a department of the same.

Preliminary Questions: The Constitution bench of 5 Justices referred 2 preliminary questions to a larger special bench of 9 justices of Supreme Court:  Whether the State Trading Corporation, a company registered under the Indian Companies Act 1956, is a citizen within the meaning of the Article 19 of the Constitution and can ask for the enforcement of fundamental rights granted to citizens under the said Article; and  Whether the State Trading Corporation is, not withstanding the formality of incorporation under the Indian Companies Act, 1956, in substance a department and organ of the Government in India with the entirety of its capital contributed by Government; and can it claim to enforce fundamental rights under part III of the Constitution against the state as defined in Article 12 thereof.

Judgement : Appeal Dismissed

Reasons:  Distinction between person and citizens  All citizens are persons but all persons are not citizens Implied Powers of Corporate Entity: As per Companies Act, “The new legal personality of a company emerges from the moment of incorporation and from the date the persons subscribing to MOA and other persons joining as members are regarded as a body corporate or Corporation aggregate and the new person begins to function as an entity”. Thus, The Corporation has no physical existence; it is a mere “Abstraction of law”  Its functions being commercial it cannot be regarded as one of the departments of the Government of India

Case II: MACKINNON MACKENZIE AND Co. VS State of West Bengal  APPELLANT: Mackinnon Mackenzie and Co.  RESPONDENT: State of West Bengal  DATE OF JUDGEMENT: 30 November 1966

FACTS:  Mackinnon Mackenzie & Co. Private Limited was incorporated on     30th March, 1951, under the provisions of the Indian Companies Act, 1913, as a public limited company It became a private limited company on and from 27th March, 1956 The registered office of the company is situate at 16, Strand Road, Calcutta The Company wanted to relocate its registered office from Calcutta to Bombay to enhance business interest The Government of West Bengal objected on the grounds of losing revenue for the state

JUDGEMENT: Appeal upheld; Government claim dismissed REASON:  Under Section 17 of the Companies Act a company may, by special resolution, alter the provisions of its memorandum so as to change the place of its registered office from one State to another  Dominant factors in favor of the change of office were resolution of the company and interest of creditors and shareholders.

Positive grounds in support:  The head office is at Bombay since about the year 1964  The control of the company is at Bombay  It would be advantageous to have the registered office at Bombay  The volume of business is larger at Bombay because of coastal restrictions and difficulties of trade with Burma and Malaya  The number of calls of ships is larger at Bombay  The number of employees is larger at Bombay  The senior staff is at Bombay

Add a comment

Related presentations

Related pages

Case-Law analysis-Guides, Research reports

Case-Law Analysis, Guides, ... Cases pending before the Grand Chamber. Delivery of judgments. Statistics Statistical Reports. Statistics by month 2016.
Read more


3 The commentary provided by the court, usually called dicta. The standard of review, where relevant. II. USING CASES Cases are important sources of ...
Read more

Writing & Analysis – The Canadian Legal Research and ...

Tips & resources for legal writing Analysis. You need to analyze the law throughout the process ... General rules about citing Canadian cases and secondary ...
Read more

Precedent - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Case law, in common law ... The necessary analysis, ... it is somewhat difficult to apply previous decisions to the facts presented in future cases. Civil ...
Read more

Case law analysis - INCADAT

Case law analysis. Prepared by Professor Peter McEleavy (University of Dundee, ... Analysis of case law including recent developments sorted by legal issue:
Read more

U.S. Case Law, Court Opinions & Decisions :: Justia

Free Database of U.S. Case Law, Court Opinions & Decisions from Justia. ... Federal courts hear cases involving matters related to the United States ...
Read more

Case Summaries - Caselaw: Cases and Codes

FindLaw provides Case Summaries / Supreme Court Cases Summary, all thirteen U.S. Circuit Courts of Appeals, and select state supreme and appellate courts
Read more

Casebriefs | Law Cases & Case Briefs for Students

Thank you for registering as a Pre-Law Student with Casebriefs™ As a pre-law student you are automatically registered for the Casebriefs™ LSAT Prep Course.
Read more

Introduction - Case Law Research Guide - Guides at ...

Case Law Research Guide Introduction Enter Search ... Therefore, finding cases is essential to finding out what the law is on a particular issue.
Read more