Published on February 27, 2014
GUIDELINES FOR PEER EDITING!
thesis statement! ! Located at the end of the introduction?! ! Expresses a stand about one of the prompts in the RAFTS?!
thesis statement! ! Contains 3-5 supporting details?! ! Supporting details relevant and speciﬁc?!
organization! ! Is there an introduction? Does it start by getting the reader’s attention ﬁrst?!
organization! ! Are the supporting details explained in logical order in the body? Are they in separate paragraphs? Do the ideas ﬂow smoothly from one to the next?!
organization! ! Is there a conclusion? Does it effectively sum up the essay? Does it reemphasize the thesis?!
evidence! ! Is there sufﬁcient evidence from the text?! ! Is the evidence correct? Is it relevant to the point the writer is making?!
COPE Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers Expectations during the peer-review process On being approached to review Peer reviewers should: • respond in ...
Peer Review Guidelines. Every writer knows the feeling of getting so close to the writing that it's impossible to look at the piece objectively.
This page includes a number of tips and suggestions to provide to students before completing their first peer review assignment. A number of these ...
Wikipedia's peer review is a way to receive ideas on how to improve articles that are already decent. It may be used for potential good article nominations ...
JoVE publishes peer-reviewed scientific video protocols to accelerate biological, medical, chemical and physical research. Watch our scientific video articles.
Consider volunteering to serve in the NIH peer review process. See Becoming a Peer ... such as reviewer guidelines, ... the Integrity in Peer Review.
Evaluating Translations as Scholarship: Guidelines for Peer Review; Executive Council Deplores Open-Records Requests that Infringe Academic Freedom;
Clinical Peer Review is the process by which health care ... The American Nurses Association guidelines on peer review define peer review as the ...
Feedback from colleagues with similar backgrounds, expertise, and knowledge can be a valuable asset. Positive peer reviews contribute to increased funding ...