Four big problems with SC Water Laws

50 %
50 %
Information about Four big problems with SC Water Laws
News & Politics

Published on February 4, 2014

Author: EdistoConcerns



Four big problems with SC Surface Water Removal Agricultural Exemptions - Learned from Walther Farms / South Edisto River. This specific presentation was given to the Aiken County Council on Feb 4, 2014.

Four Big Problems with the Exemption for Large Agricultural Withdrawals S.C. Surface Water Withdrawal, Permitting, Use, and Reporting Act 2010 Act No. 247 Section 49-4 DHEC Regulation R.61-119

Four Big Problems 1. 2. 3. 4. Secrecy Pumping the River Dry Eternal Water Grants No Input Outside of DHEC

1. Secrecy • Currently, the law allows for any agricultural user to request hundreds of millions of gallons of water from the river with no public notice. It is possible that neighbors won't know the water is being taken until AFTER the water is gone. We believe that our government should be more transparent and not give the appearance of secrecy and back room deals. • In DHEC’s public meeting held January 7, 2014, DHEC said the law requires us to approve an ag withdrawal with no public notice. (Source: 1:08:50 of audio at

2. Pumping the River Dry • The current law defines “safe yield” based on a percentage of "mean annual daily flow“. At low flow periods, the withdrawal amount could exceed actual flow, and the river would run dry. In the case of the Edisto, U.S.C. Professor Allan James has demonstrated that the initial request (805 Million gallons/month) would have actually exceeded the total flow of the river during historic low flows, meaning they were permitted by law to take ALL WATER from the river. (Source: • In DHEC’s public meeting held January 7, 2014, DHEC admitted that an ag user could actually take the river to “no water for a particular day” and “there is no minimum instream number at which they would have to stop” (Source: Listen to 49:20 of audio at

3. Eternal Water Grants • Under the current law, once an agricultural entity is granted approval of a surface water withdrawal registration, they can pump that amount of water from the river forever. We believe that large withdrawals should be reviewed and recertified regularly to ensure a fair allocation of the resource among all stakeholders. • In DHEC’s public meeting held January 7, 2014, DHEC confirmed that registrations “have no duration” and in effect are forever (Source: 54:15 of audio at

4. No Input Outside of DHEC • DHEC has interpreted the existing regulations as excluding consultation with other government entities such as the Department of Natural Resources, the Corps of Engineers, the Fish and Wildlife Service, and the Environmental Protection Agency. We believe that DHEC should provide notice to other relevant agencies and give them an opportunity to comment on the impact of any proposed withdrawal. • In DHEC’s public meeting held January 7, 2014, DHEC said there is no need to consult other agencies. (Source: 70:00 of audio at

Add a comment

Related presentations

Related pages

Regulatory Information by Topic: Water | Regulatory ...

EPA enforces federal clean water and safe drinking water laws, ... or report a problem. Main menu. Learn the Issues. Air; Chemicals and Toxics; Climate Change;
Read more

Water Environment Association of South Carolina - SCAWWA/WEASC

South Carolina's water and wastewater professional associations ... (SCAWWA) and the Water Environment Association of SC (WEASC). ...
Read more

The Problems with Waste | Toxics Action Center

The unprecedented toxicity of garbage exacerbates the problem that ... Since the waste management facilities have become big ... such as wind and water ...
Read more

S.C. Government

SC Code of Laws and Regulations; Flag Status; Voter Registration; ... strives to provide citizens with multiple options to find the help they need.
Read more

Skyrocketing water bills mystify, anger residents -

Now, it's small print but it's big enough ... we do believe we have problems in the water meter and ... a law degree to say $7,000 for a ...
Read more

Environmental policy of the United States - Wikipedia, the ...

... environmental laws were passed, regulating air and water ... looks at environmental problems ... environmental law in the ...
Read more

The Big Problem With Texas’s New Gun Law

The Big Problem With Texas’s New Gun Law. 12/31/2015 07:47 am ET. Fusion. Texas is starting off the new year with a bang: ...
Read more

Neighbor Disputes Over Water Damage |

Neighbor Disputes Over Water Damage. ... Judges also frequently order problems to be fixed if ... Research your state's water laws by searching the ...
Read more

Camp Lejeune water contamination - Wikipedia, the free ...

Camp Lejeune water contamination ... The Camp Lejeune water contamination problem occurred at Marine Corps ... President Obama signed the bill into law on ...
Read more

Tenant Rights to a Livable Place |

Tenant Rights to a Livable Place. ... Major Habitability Problems Versus Minor Problems ... These laws are usually less detailed than local codes, ...
Read more