Concept mapping and text analysis (WRAB3 poster)

50 %
50 %
Information about Concept mapping and text analysis (WRAB3 poster)
Education

Published on February 18, 2014

Author: rolenzo

Source: slideshare.net

Description

A low text representation of the content of text can reveal rhetorical structure or orchestration (or their absence). Cmap representation can have a valuable place in the writing center toolkit.

Writing Research Across Borders III Concept mapping and text analysis -a composite tool for EAP writers and mentors Lawrie Hunter Kochi University of Technology

Problem: argument block Engineering EAP PhD students have trouble articulating their arguments. Factors 1.The structure of an engineering RP is not the structure of an argument. 2. Continuous text does not reveal rhetorical structure. 3. Teaching argument leads poorly to abstraction skill.

Intervention 2: Use Cmap Tools -force articulation of relations between core content elements (The link relations are only communication moves verbs from argument discourse.)

Study 1: interventions 1 and 2 Map source text Critique the map Make a consensus map Write a summary from map Results Lack of rhetorical awareness led to the inclusion of background information in summaries. Absence of visual metaphors led to narrative order confusion.

Intervention 3: identify core text

Intervention 4: Institute visual metaphors abstract overarching more important less important concrete subordinate more salient rhetorical flow argument direction less salient passage through time cause-effect

Study 2: Instruction in text analysis interventions 3 and 4 Map source text Write a summary from map Results Core content dominant in summaries; sentence order much better. Some learners extended the process to a second text analysis for further abstraction.

Reflection Teachers of writing: -built-in bias against low-text work? Outreach: just ask me! Whatever Lawrie Hunter you need. I love to help. Kochi University of Technology http://www.core.kochi-tech.ac.jp/hunter http://lawriehunter.com

Concept mapping and text analysis: A composite tool for EAP writers and mentors This presentation demonstrates how a low text representation of the content of text can reveal rhetorical structure or orchestration (or their absence). It also argues that Cmap representation can have a valuable place in the writing center toolkit. Cmap representation has gained a wide usership, particularly in science education, thanks to the popularity of the freeware Cmap Tools. Cmap Tools forces the user to label each link between two nodes with a phrase specifying the relation between those nodes. As well, applying several visual metaphors (e.g., up is abstract, down is concrete; up is overarching, down is subordinate) can make the representation even more compressed. This presents an altogether more powerful representation than mind maps. This presentation reports several cases of fruitful application of Cmap Tools, wherein EAP learners of academic writing discovered intellectual leverage in mapping. In each case the learners drew constrained maps of the content of a text (academic or popular genre), critiqued their maps, arrived at consensus on an accurate mapping, and then set out to write a new version of the text based only on the content of the map. In each case the subsequent work was rich regarding writing strategy and proactive use of tools. The learners developed their own approaches, cycling between moves analysis and concept mapping as they worked to unpack text that they had initially identified as 'good models'. In each case too the end product was significantly closer to the target form. The observations made here point to numerous applications in EAP writing, and suggest that the Cmap deserves a place amongst the essential tools for EAP instruction and writing center work, being of particular use in the analysis of source texts where the identification of rhetorical orchestration is difficult; where argument is often masked by other rhetorical devices; and in situations where one's thinking about an approach to a problem is complex and difficult to encode directly in extended text.

Concept mapping and text analysis: A composite tool for EAP writers and mentors This presentation demonstrates how a low text representation of the content of text can reveal rhetorical structure or orchestration (or their absence). It also argues that Cmap representation can have a valuable place in the writing center toolkit. Cmap representation has gained a wide usership, particularly in science education, thanks to the popularity of the freeware Cmap Tools. Cmap Tools forces the user to label each link between two nodes with a phrase specifying the relation between those nodes. As well, applying several visual metaphors (e.g., up is abstract, down is concrete; up is overarching, down is subordinate) can make the representation even more compressed. This presents an altogether more powerful representation than mind maps. This presentation reports several cases of fruitful application of Cmap Tools, wherein EAP learners of academic writing discovered intellectual leverage in mapping. In each case the learners drew constrained maps of the content of a text (academic or popular genre), critiqued their maps, arrived at consensus on an accurate mapping, and then set out to write a new version of the text based only on the content of the map. In each case the subsequent work was rich regarding writing strategy and proactive use of tools. The learners developed their own approaches, cycling between moves analysis and concept mapping as they worked to unpack text that they had initially identified as 'good models'. In each case too the end product was significantly closer to the target form. The observations made here point to numerous applications in EAP writing, and suggest that the Cmap deserves a place amongst the essential tools for EAP instruction and writing center work, being of particular use in the analysis of source texts where the identification of rhetorical orchestration is difficult; where argument is often masked by other rhetorical devices; and in situations where one's thinking about an approach to a problem is complex and difficult to encode directly in extended text.

Add a comment

Related presentations

Related pages

Concept mapping and text analysis (WRAB3 poster) - Education

1. Writing Research Across Borders IIIConcept mapping and text analysis-a composite tool for EAP writers and mentors Lawrie Hunter Kochi University of ...
Read more

Water Mapping Poster - Documents - docslide.us

Water Mapping Poster. by bpwwc. on Jul 06, 2015. Report Category: Documents. Download: 0 Comment: 0. 22. views. Comments. Description.
Read more

Story analysis method, mapping and tools - Design

Text. 1. ... Concept mapping and text analysis (WRAB3 poster) Step 2: Preliminary Market Mapping and Analysis. Direct Analysis Method Tips.
Read more

mapping studies text mining.pdf - Documents

Text Mapping Power Point Presentation Textmapping A Simple Tool for Improving Reading Comprehension © 2004 Kimberly Burke reprinted by permission ...
Read more