advertisement

Civil Military Relations

50 %
50 %
advertisement
Information about Civil Military Relations
Education

Published on December 6, 2008

Author: raj.rana

Source: slideshare.net

Description

Comprehensive presentation that looks at the question of civil-military relations, specifically the relationship between multi-national military forces and international humanitarian organizations.
advertisement

Unpacking the Civil-Military Relationship French Armed Forces Recruiting Poster

aim • PRTs are not the problem • Accommodate the realities • Be careful what we wish(ed) for- calls for ‘military intervention’, ‘security’, etc. ICRC Delegation Baghdad • Can we learn anything from armed forces?

outline Tsunami- Military Assistance • Basic Definitions • Background- Military/Humanitarian • ʻKosovo Crossroadsʼ • ICRC Guidelines on Civil-Military Relations • Broader Environment • 2005 onwards

basic definitions CIMIC is the co-ordination and co-operation, in support of the mission, between the NATO Commander and civil populations, including national and local authorities, as well as international, national and non-governmental organizations and agencies. •interface; public face of the military, press campaign, intelligence •cooperation, coordination, information sharing, security briefing, •...humanitarian projects, reconstruction, nation building CMCoord (UN) CMR (ICRC/SCHR) CIMIC (NATO) CA (USAF)

background- military • armed forces looking for a new role in post Cold War context • rise of peace-keeping then peace-enforcement Streets-cape- Sarajevo • need to be seen as ‘taking action’ • development of new roles

background- humanitarian Outside Basra- 25.03.03 • protest the ‘militarization of humanitarian action’, birth of ‘humanitarian space’ • risk of such UN-mandated forces becoming belligerents risked blurring the distinction between political, military and humanitarian action • orbiting in a simplistic debate about coordination, principles of last resort, armed escorts, intelligence vs. information

kosovo crossroads • humanitarians ‘lost the thread’ • new threshold for military-humanitarian action- NATO, KBR, joint deployments • military consolidated their learning and experience • wave of new policies and doctrine

9/11 onwards- Afghanistan, Iraq Darfur • armed forces taking on civilian roles/tasks has become a mainstream approach- Afghanistan, Iraq, Haiti, Sierra Leone, Liberia, DRC... • distinction between combat and PSO is increasingly vague • limit our criticisms: states/armed forces meeting their obligations under IHL is part of the ideal of war • increasingly pluralist community of ‘neutral’, ‘humanitarians’

Increasing Sophistication of Armed Forces

Integrated Approaches Distinction between Political, Military and Humanitarian Action? • Confusion of actors • Neutrality? • “With us or against us” 9/11 flight

ICRC Civil-Military Guidelines- 2001 In our relationship with multinational military forces, the ICRC advocates for: • Independence of decision making and action • Dialogue at all times and levels, with multinational military missions • Clear distinction of roles and actors in times of armed conflict

broader environment and consequences • UN push towards integrated approaches- humanitarian, political, DPKO, others • US-driven nation-building agenda and the compatibility with humanitarian action • blurring of lines and roles • divergence of views in the humanitarian community • competition

2005 reality check- Tsunami • military faster and equally professional • new ‘wave of optimism’ for military • divergence of perspectives in the humanitarian community- for, against, indifferent • integrated missions debate, nation/regional evolutions (PCRU, NATO/EU)

SCHR position paper • clarity of message- for it? against it? aware of it? addressing it? • reflection of SCHR member’s positions? • confusion with IHL, UN mandates and parties to a conflict? • ... what do we want to say?

calling for military intervention • compatibility with Code of Conduct • neutrality and apolitical action • confusion with IHL, UN mandates and parties to a conflict?

conclusions • PRTs are not the problem • Accommodate the realities • Be careful what we wish(ed) for- calls for ‘military intervention’, ‘security’, etc. • Can we learn anything from armed forces?

questions/comments?

Add a comment

Related presentations

Related pages

Civil–military relations - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Civil–military relations (Civ-Mil or CMR) describes the relationship between civil society as a whole and the military organization or organizations ...
Read more

Civil–military relations - Military Wiki - Wikia

Civil–military relations (Civ-Mil or CMR) describes the relationship between civil society as a whole and the military organization or organizations ...
Read more

Civil-Military Relations | Political Science | MIT ...

This course centers on mechanisms of civilian control of the military. Relying on the influential texts of Lasswell, Huntington, and Finer, the first ...
Read more

Civil-Military Relations | RAND

RAND research on civil-military relations includes studies of how a military employs civilian contractors, how military bases interact with their neighbors ...
Read more

Civil-military relations - definition of civil-military ...

Published widely on the American presidency, civil-military relations, and American political development, he is author of The Cold War Presidency: A ...
Read more

Center for Civil-Military Relations - Naval Postgraduate ...

Who We Are. The Center for Civil-Military Relations (CCMR) is a Department of Defense (DoD) organization within the Naval Postgraduate School. The Center ...
Read more

Civil-Military Relations: A Selected Bibliography

CIVIL-MILITARY RELATIONS A Selected Bibliography U.S. ARMY WAR COLLEGE LIBRARY May 2011
Read more

Civil-Military Relations in Europe eBook by ...

Lesen Sie Civil-Military Relations in Europe Learning from Crisis and Institutional Change von mit Kobo. This new book illustrates how democracy cannot ...
Read more

The Soldier and the State - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The Soldier and the State: The Theory and Politics of Civil-Military Relations; Author: Samuel P. Huntington: Country: United States: Language: English ...
Read more

Civil-Military Relations in Perspective eBook by ...

Lesen Sie Civil-Military Relations in Perspective Strategy, Structure and Policy von mit Kobo. The topic of civil-military relations has high significance ...
Read more