Published on March 5, 2014
Sourcing World-Class Motor Components in China Michael Bloom, President Sinotech | Custom Engineered Motors & Mechanical Parts Sinotech.com
03/05/14 Sinotech.com 2
03/05/14 Sinotech.com 3
Why China? Abundant raw materials Well developed industrial base Aerospace/Defense technology drivers Communications and transportation infrastructure Stable economy One of World’s lowest labor rates ($100 to $300 per month) 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 4
How Will Chinese Sourcing Affect Costs? Savings of 20-50% on production costs and more than 50% on tooling costs The “ritual” of price determination Reasons for price variations: Level of automation Short term vs long term profit orientation Gov’t owned vs JV vs privately owned Rural vs Village vs City 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 5
What Motor Components Are Available from China? Commutators Brushes & Brush Assemblies Motor Shafts Laminations Magnets Wound Armatures Cast and Forged Components 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 6
Quality… Quality… Quality If quality control is not properly addressed, the sourcing project is almost guaranteed to fail. At the early stages of negotiations make it clear to the factory what the quality issues are. 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 7
On-Site Audits Begin With Inspection of Raw Materials An on-site audit showed that this manufacturer imported raw materials, carefully labeled them and stored them in a temperature/humidity controlled environment. 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 8
… and Ends With The Finished Goods Warehouse On-Site inspection reveals high quality inner and outer packing 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 9
An On-Site Audit Reveals Test Methodologies, Equipment and Training Hi-Pot testing of motor components 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 10
An On-Site Audit Can Also Reveal Serious Problems!! This factory sent its shafts for knurling to this one-man shop, squeezed between buildings, roofed only with a tarpaulin. QS9000? NOT!! 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 11
Consider Independent Auditing of Factory Capabilities Auditing the motor stator winding process 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 12
Quality Should Be Apparent At Every Stage of Manufacturing Automatic machining of motor shafts 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 13
Logical Organization of Production Line Is An Indicator of Quality Automated coil armature winding machines 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 14
Quality (cont’d) Surface finishes, weight tolerances, standards (such as UL/CSA approval), metallurgical considerations, test methods etc. should be provided in written or electronic form. Increasing numbers of Chinese factories are achieving ISO9000 certification. However even factories that are not ISO qualified are often willing to learn and implement Statistical Process Control (SPC) methods if taught. 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 15
Quality (cont’d) Verify that quality control processes are in place and that they are being adhered to Use US-based test labs Perform random sampling of production parts prior to shipping 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 16
Quality (cont’d) Quality and Chinese Cultural Norms Chinese cultural norms may make it very uncomfortable for a Chinese engineer or manager to verbalize negative feelings or admit problems. Production issues and delays occur that are not admitted by the factory. 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 17
Case Study: Auditing a Commutator factory 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 18
The opening interview After introductions, ask that the following join the meeting: General Manager Quality Control Manager Manufacturing Manager Test Lab Manager 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 19
Introductory Interview Who owns the factory? What is the factory’s history? Who are its major export customers? What is its annual turnover? How many employees? engineers? managers? Explain that you will be asking for certain documents and that you will ask to tour the facility in a specific order Bring a written list of questions! 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 20
Documents to request Ask to see the following documents: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Copies of any ISO or QS certifications An equipment/machine list for the factory A Control Plan and Process Flow Chart for a similar product A Process Failure Mode Engineering Analysis for a similar product A Capability Study for a similar product Gage R&R’s 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 21
The Equipment List Does the list confirm the processes that are required? Is the equipment domestic or imported? What level of process control is indicated by the equipment list? 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 22
ISO/QS Certificates How meaningful is an ISO9000 certification? QS9000? Ask for the latest audit result Ask “What needed to be improved?” Ask “What was done to improve” 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 23
Process Flow Chart 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 24
Process Control Plan A VERY important document Make sure you understand the process flow . . . Ask questions Look for in-process inspection steps “Walk” the process!! 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 25
03/05/14 Sinotech.com 26
Capability Study Does the factory do capability studies? Ask for one for a similar part Check on the Cpk/Ppk values. Is the Cpk acceptable? 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 27
Capability Study (p.1) 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 28
Capability Study (P.2) 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 29
Production FMEA Purpose of Production Failure Mode Engineering Analysis PFMEA also demonstrates a proactive approach to quality PFMEA will help with later corrective actions 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 30
03/05/14 Sinotech.com 31
Suggested order of audit 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Design area Tooling shop Raw material storage Incoming material inspection Process step #1 to process step #n 03/05/14 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. Sinotech.com Final inspection Defective part rework/scrap Packaging Laboratories Record storage 32
Transitioning from a domestic commutator source Most domestic sources use proprietary resin For the most part it will not be possible to find direct substitutes Some 03/05/14 reverse engineering will be needed Sinotech.com 33
Commutators (cont’d) S e le c t in g t h e R ig h t R e s in S u b m it te s t m o to r to c o m m fa c to r y In c lu d e e x tr a s h a fts a n d fu ll m o to r s p e c ific a tio n s F a c to ry S e le c t s R e s in B u ild c o m m u ta to r p r o to ty p e s P e rfo rm te s ts o n c u rr e n t m o to r to v e r ify s p e c ific a tio n P e r f o r m s h a f t in s e r t io n te s ts S u b s titu te c o m m u ta to r s R e - ru n p e rfo rm a n c e te s ts S p in te s t 03/05/14 L ife - c y c le te s t Sinotech.com 34
Brushes Special issues Graphite/carbon compound must be reverse engineered Lead pull test required Grinding requirements Durability testing suggested 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 35
Shafts Special issues Complex geometry (offsets, splines, knurled surfaces) Heat treatment Repeatability Difficult metrology 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 36
Magnets Special issues Achieving magnetic specifications Correlation of magnetic measurements Allowable chips B , H , H vs motor performance measures r c ci Surface 03/05/14 porosity Sinotech.com 37
Conclusion World-class motor components are available from China including commutators, brushes, shafts, and magnets Due diligence in factory selection is key to project success An on site audit is mandatory with focus on adherence to quality systems 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 38
6663 SW Beaverton-Hillsdale Highway Portland, Oregon 97225 Tel: 503-828-9882 Fax: 503-291-6192 Web: www.Sinotech.com 03/05/14 Sinotech.com 39
Manufacturers who build DC gear motors, BLDC motors and other components often look to China to source components like brushes, magnets, and wound coils to ...
China Sourcing of World Class Motor Components: BLDC ... components often look to China to ... “Sinotech Reveals Secrets of China Sourcing: ...
China DC Brushless Motor for Ykbl36-001, Find details about China Motors, Electric Motor from DC Brushless Motor for Ykbl36-001 ... » BLDC Motor ...
BMC) is exclusively engage in Design & manufacturer of High efficiency Brushless permanent magnet electric motors for automotive, aerospace, medical ...
China 78mm Pm DC Gear Motor, ... or Post Sourcing Request. Gold Member Since 2009. ... BLDC Motor; PMDC Motor; AC Gear Motor;
... from China Motor & Engine suppliers to ... Diesel Generator Mini Motor China Gearbox Micro Motor Engine ... Equipment & Components Motor & Engine
China 6V-36V BLDC Electric Geared Brushless DC Motor for Electric Tool, ... BLDC Motor, Synchronous ... Made-in-China.com - The world of "Made in China ...
... Find details about China Engine, Electrical Motor from 57bly05 NEMA23 103W 0.33n. ... BLDC MOTOR: MODEL : 57BLY01: ... INSULATION CLASS : B: ROTATING ...