Published on January 29, 2014
TRENDS IN MENA Bancassurance PERSPECTIVES FROM THE REGION’S LEADING ORGANISATIONS A STUDY BY BANCASSURANCE EXPANSION TRENDS IN MENA: INSIGHT, CHALLENGES AND DIFFERENTIATORS In the GCC, insurance products are gaining in popularity, but the region is still lagging when it comes to insurance penetration. Consequently there are many opportunities in the market, and one of the most significant of these is the opportunity offered by bancassurance. Insurance really does provide banks with a great opportunity to grow their business and diversify their product range. Jamie McNish, Regional Director – Partnership Distribution, Friends Provident International First Gulf Bank figures indicate that insurance penetration in the region is currently at just 1.4 percent, compared to 7.9 percent in the US and 7.1 percent in Europe. They believe that factors such as a young population and high disposable incomes, combined with low penetration make bancassurance an attractive proposition. IIR Middle East conducted this qualitative study with leading bancassurance providers, to gain insight into the key issues facing the market, how they see the industry developing, how they have built their businesses and what advice would this give to banks looking to enter the market. © IIR MIDDLE EAST. All rights reserved 1
Q1. Why Is Bancassurance Particularly Attractive To Banks In MENA? There was a general consensus amongst the survey respondents that bancassurance is attractive because banks are able to leverage their existing customer bases and build on their product offerings, providing a wide range of financial products which will contribute to customer retention. Bancassurance, which offers a stable profit stream, is also a way for banks to diversify their product ranges in a non capital intensive manner. OPPORTUNITIES ABOUND The survey respondents pointed to what they see as considerable opportunity for bancassurance products in the GCC market. They mentioned both the low penetration levels of insurance products, and the scope that bancassurance products provides for banks to become comprehensive financial service providers which will help build customer loyalty and retention. Ashish Sood, Deputy CEO, Retail & Private Banking, Ahli Bank, highlights the large foreign workforce in the region and the lack of a government linked insurance or savings plan available to this workforce post-retirement as key factors that make bancassurace attractive. The transitional nature of much of the population, high disposable income levels and low penetration of insurance products are also cited by Amol Shah, Business Head Bancassurance, First Gulf Bank, as factors which contribute to the attractiveness of bancassurance. LEVERAGE NETWORKS Another major reason that bancassurance is regarded as being so attractive is because banks already have an established distribution network, via their branches. Banks that have already invested in building customer loyalty will be able to leverage this loyalty by offering a wider range of products and services in a way that Ahmed Ali Al Mamari, Director, Financial & Technical Regulations of Oman’s Capital Market Authority, believes will introduce ‘choice, competition and convenience’. On the business banking side, J G Shields, Head Bancassurance, Absa Business Banking , states that, ‘A proper bancassurance model in business banking, where insurance products are applied through innovative concepts, should improve the bank’s ability to advance money to customers.’ © IIR MIDDLE EAST. All rights reserved A SOURCE OF ADDITIONAL AND RECURRING INCOME There is widespread agreement that introducing insurance products will provide banks with a strong source of additional and recurring income. It is regarded as comparatively risk-free and provides a fee-based income. Such diversification is seen as positive by the banks, particularly as the introduction of bancassurance is seen as requiring very little additional investment. Introduce customers to other products An additional reason for bancassurance’s attractiveness is that it creates opportunities to offer a wider range of financial products to existing and new customers. This is seen as a way to: • Build customer loyalty • Increase the ‘stickiness’ of the customer to the bank • Helps increasing the wallet share of the customer • Offer customers convenience in the form of a ‘one stop banking solution’. • Provide opportunities for cross-selling Jitender (Kumar) Nangia, Vice President & Cluster Head, HDFC Bank, India, suggests that the provision of bancassurance can be a factor in the market’s perception of the bank as a ‘more reliable entity.’ Globally, banks increasingly see insurance products as a way to offer a more comprehensive range of additional products and service. Ahmed Ali Al Mamari, Director, Financial & Technical Regulations, Capital Market Authority, Oman [Bancassurance offers] potential to on board customers for other products and services (stickiness of customers increase if they purchase more than one product). Ashish Sood, Deputy CEO, Retail & Private Banking, Ahli Bank, Oman 2
Q2. What Top Tips Would You Give To Banks Looking To Penetrate The MENA Bancassurance Market? When it comes to penetrating the MENA bancassurance market, banks can focus on a range of issues to help them make the most of the available opportunities. UNDERSTAND THE MARKET AND YOUR ROLE IN IT Understanding the market was cited by many respondents as one of the most important things that a bank can do as it prepares to introduce bancassurance offerings. This is not just about the demographics, but also about regulatory frameworks. In a July 2013 report, Alpen Capital states, ‘Bancassurance, which is a popular medium of selling insurance products in several mature insurance markets across the globe, has so far seen restricted progress in the GCC due to insufficient training, improper incentives structure, and regulatory issues.’ (http://www.alpencapital.com/downloads/GCC%20 Insurance%20Industry%20Report%202013_1%20July.pdf accessed 4 Jan 2014). Clyde and Co, in a September 2013 statement, said that, ‘Bancassurance undoubtedly represents a great potential opportunity for the insurance industry. However care needs to be taken to ensure that the arrangements are properly drafted in order to reflect the parties’ expectations and to adequately define their respective roles, duties and the service standards to be maintained. As and when the Draft Circular is implemented insurers, and their bank partners will need to obtain approval from the UAE Central Bank and the Insurance Authority for their arrangements. Accordingly, they should be seeking to ensure that their arrangements are compliant with the requirements of the Bancassurance Regulations.’ (http://www.clydeco.com/insight/updates/ banking-on-bancassurance accessed 4 Jan 2014) Preparation is the key. Before making a decision to diversify into bancassurance, banks need to conduct in-depth research into the government policies and the regulations in each market. It is also important for them to have a clear understanding of their competitors. Other tips relating to the understanding of the market provided by the survey respondents included: Look at medium to long term goals, forget about the short term ones. Emad Louis, Vice President, Head of Barclays Direct Business, Barclays, Egypt Bancassurance doesn’t start giving results immediately … you need to invest time and effort and, more importantly, have the patience to see the opportunity giving the desired results. Banks fail because they give up too easily and too early.. Gautam Duggal, Regional Head: Wealth Management, Priority & International Banking - Africa, Standard Chartered Bank, UAE Don’t look at short term gains. Sreenath Manghat, Head, Bancassurance Products & Services - Consumer Banking, Bank Muscat, Oman Focus on the customer Focusing on the customer is seen as a key factor when looking to further realise the potential in the bancassurance business. Customer-centricity was a constant theme in the survey responses, and survey respondents emphasised the importance of having the right data, that will give you valuable insights into your market if you are going to be successful. It is also seen as vital to consider bancassurance as part of the Customer Value Proposition and not as ‘just another product’. Jamie McNish, Regional Director – Partnership Distribution, Friends Provident International says, ‘Focus on the customer – intimately understand their attitudes, needs and behaviors.’ Colin Harrison of HSBC Bank Middle East suggests that banks should start by determining what their customers need, rather than deciding what they want to sell them. • Identify what you want to get out of bancassurance Adopt a customer centric focus with a clear priority on delivering exceptional levels of sales and service throughout the customer journey. • Make sure that your bancassurance and retail banking strategies are congruent Ahmed Ali Al Mamari, Director, Financial & Technical Regulations, Capital Market Authority, Oman • Understand the local socio-economic challenges • Consider who your competitors will be in a few years time. Amol Shah of First Gulf Bank suggests that the competition may not be limited to banks, but might also include technology companies, telecom companies, broking firms and the like. Think long term Bancassurance does not lead to immediate results is the general consensus among survey respondents. They advised that as well as investing time and effort, banks need to be patient because the gains are ones that will be achieved over the medium to long term. © IIR MIDDLE EAST. All rights reserved Place customer centricity above income opportunity within the bank’s vision and strategic approach. Income will look after itself in a proper Bancassurance model. JG Shields, Head, Bancassurance, Absa Business Banking, South Africa Understand your customer needs and adopt a customer centric focus with an aim to offer products throughout the customer life cycle. Sreenath Manghat, Head, Bancassurance Products & Services Consumer Banking, Bank Muscat, Oman 3
Innovate Another tip offered by survey respondents was to be innovative. This involved creating innovative propositions and products that were designed to meet the customer needs in each local market. Amol Shah of First Gulf Bank also emphasises the need to ‘keep it simple, actionable and relevant for each local market’. Innovative products should also be designed to outpace inflation according to Jitendar (Kumar) Nagia of India’s HDFC Bank, while Ashish Sood of Oman’s Ahli Bank suggested the need to link savings schemes to customers’ end goals, such as children’s education. Work with the right partner Of course having the right partnership in place is going to be important for the success of any bancassurance business. Sreeenath Manghat of Bank Muscat mentions the importance of ensuring ‘strategic alignment between the insurance provider and the bank with an agreed approach to distribution, products, technology and operating models’. Other tips included: Think carefully about distribution Clearly one of the principal advantages of bancassurance is the ability of the business to take advantage of existing distribution networks such as branches. It is important that banks carefully consider the behavior of the customers such as which channels they prefer to interact with as well as offer services through multiple channels such as face-toface, telephone and online. Amol Shah of the UAE’s First Gulf Bank suggests, ‘Think about your distribution like Unilever, sell like McDonald's and service your customer like the Ritz-Carlton’. Support the business unit appropriately As well as collaborating with the right partner and developing a robust multi-channel distribution network, it is vital that the bancassurance business unit be appropriately supported. A strong back office processing capability and a dedicated, experienced sales force will help ensure that the customer experience is positive and contributes to customer retention. • Select your partner based on where you would like the business to be in the next five years • Request transparency, with joint business models, sales and marketing plans as well as a single governance structure Many business problems are really customer experience problems. Set up a strong backend processing capability and invest in a Retention Unit. • Get the right insurance partner who also believes in the opportunity. If you fail in this, the pace of the two organisations might be different leading to frustrations down the track Amol Shah, Business Head Bancassurance, First Gulf Bank, UAE Adopt a customer centric focus with a clear priority on delivering exceptional levels of sales and service throughout the customer journey. Ahmed Ali Al Mamari, Director, Financial & Technical Regulations, Capital Market Authority, Oman © IIR MIDDLE EAST. All rights reserved 4
Q3. What Are The Key Factors Of Creating A Strong Partnership In Bancassurance? Creating a strong partnership is not the result of simply choosing the right partner. The survey respondents also identified the need to select the right product (or products), the importance of having a strong, committed management team and the right operational support, as important factors in the development of a strong bancassurance partnership. The right partner When it came to partner selection the emphasis was on the fit between the two organisations in terms of shared goals, subject matter expertise and investment. But top of the list was the issue of trust. • Developing a good relationship, based on understanding each other’s strengths and weaknesses, and promoting excellent team work between bank and the product provider • A long term commitment from both parties to stay in the game The right products Selecting the ‘right’ products was cited as an important component of the partnership. Key tips included: Gautam Duggal, Regional Head: Wealth Management, Priority & International Banking, Africa, Standard Chartered Bank, UAE Mutual Trust – First and foremost, like-minded professionals, on both the bank and the insurance company’s side, who trust each other. Amol Shah, Business Head Bancassurance, First Gulf Bank, UAE Other important components of the partnership included: • • Creating a partnership where both the insurance company and the bank focused on creating the best customer proposition, rather than focusing on the model Developing a relationship where both parties share services and develop products together where possible, sharing expertise across all functions • Contributing both financial and non-financial investment from both parties • Agreeing jointly on the strategic partnership objectives and developing detailed Service Level Agreements and Key Performance Indicators, designed for long term sustainable growth and to protect customers and the investments made by both partners Keep it simple – products , sales and service • Build propositions rather than products, because propositions will help you differentiate yourself from the competition The right team and management With any partnership between organisations it is imperative that the management and teams suit each other, and have shared values. To be successful in the bancassurance market requires engagement of the management team from the top down. The senior managers of the bank need to be completely committed to bancassurance and treat it with the same respect as the rest of the bank’s products. In the words of Gautam Duggal of Standard Chartered Bank, ‘ownership’ is important. ‘The message has to come right from the top of the organisation that this is an opportunity that merits investment.’ Joint governance is also important with high quality, accurate, timely management information reviewed regularly by the two parties. Get your operations right While a good strategic fit between the partners, and the selection of the right products, are important, the venture can fail if the operational aspects of the program are not in place. Survey respondents suggested: • Create a single, scalable platform and operating model which drives synergies in IT, operations and customer service • Focus on ease of application process, payment, clear and concise policies as well as putting in place a simple method of claims’ payment • Keep the products, sales and service as simple as possible • Embed a sales culture in the organisation. Make sure the sales force can deliver what the customer wants through all of your distribution channels Developing shared goals • Select products that suit major customer segments and not just the ones that you like • TRUST – insurance companies are not here to take the bank’s customers away and the banks are not here to sell only insurance products. Both parties need to understand and accept this. • • Choosing a partner with a similar business vision and approach to customers © IIR MIDDLE EAST. All rights reserved 5
Q4. Life, non-life and corporate? Which products are the most attractive for Banks? The consensus on the question of which products are most attractive comes down firmly as ‘it depends’, with each product category having its own advantages and challenges. According to Oman’s Capital Market Authority, ‘Within MENA, the most successful insurance products have traditionally been related to compulsory insurance requirements, such as auto and, in some jurisdictions, medical and mortgage. Non-mandatory insurance classes, such as personal property, individual life and SME have also been introduced and are gaining traction.’ Offering products which complement the bank’s core products is seen as a strategy which is likely to ensure good returns and allow the bank to leverage its existing customer base effectively. Again the survey respondents emphasise the importance of focusing on the customers and accurately identifying their needs to identify key customer segments. They also state that it is vital that products be offered through appropriate distribution channels. Life Non-life • Life insurance is a much bigger ticket item, but it needs a significant investment in the sales force development, management and oversight • Non-life insurance is less complex than life insurance, but it is highly transactional and needs significant volumes to generate returns • Volumes are generally small, but with high margins • • Life insurance is mandated by all regulators for all lending products (for example, personal loans) Volumes are fairly high, and non-life products are relatively easy to sell, so require less investment in the development of the sales force • Insurance-linked saving schemes are fast becoming attractive in terms of both customer benefits and fee income for banks • They help increase customer loyalty and retention Corporate • The corporate market is complex, and access to it is made challenging by a strong and highly competitive broker market • Offering corporate products would help the bank be a one-stop shop for a customer’s complete financial needs Q5. Are some distribution channels progressing better than others for certain products? Which ones and why? Within MENA, multiple and integrated distribution is key to the future of successful bancassurance models and, depending on the product, the channel preference will alter over time, and at different speeds of consumer adoption. Banks are ideally situated to take advantage of their existing channels and relationships to sell bancassurance products. Put simply, those products which require considerable knowledge on the part of the sales force, and which require a substantial investment, have traditionally been sold through direct selling and wealth management services, and this is likely to continue. On the other hand, sales of auto, travel and home insurance, which were traditionally sold face-to-face and by brokers, are shifting more towards online, phone and ATM channels. Customers generally appreciate the opportunity to switch between channels as part of their bank relationship and it is likely that they will appreciate being able to do this when it comes to bancassurance as well. Simple, template products are perfect for distribution through branches or by telemarketing, but are also highly suitable for online channels. ... the opportunity or next wave is technology driven. Gautam Duggal, Regional Head: Wealth Management, Priority & International Banking - Africa, Standard Chartered Bank, UAE Customers require the convenience of choosing which channel to adopt. This will develop as a requirement to switch between channels as part of their bank relationship. Wealth management is widely acknowledged as the best channel for distributing insurance products; one of the major drivers for this is the significant revenue opportunity it provides. Ahmed Ali Al Mamari, Director, Financial & Technical Regulations, Capital Market Authority, Oman Sreenath Manghat, Head, Bancassurance Products & Services Consumer Banking, Bank Muscat, Oman © IIR MIDDLE EAST. All rights reserved 6
Q6. How can you go about creating a more customer centric approach in Bancassurance? Friends Provident International sum up the approach that organisations need to take perfectly. ‘We need to understand the customers’ needs, attitudes and behaviors. The bank has a wealth of information on their customers which, if used correctly, can greatly assist in building a customer centric approach and proposition focused on the needs of the customer rather than the bank or insurer.’ It is all about understanding the customer and putting the customer at the center of the process. Some key aspects of customer behavior that banks need to understand include: • Expectations of customer experience are evolving – speed, convenience and low effort are increasingly important • Customers are adopting digital technologies which is shifting control from organisations to customers • Customers interact with the bank across multiple channels and expect integrated experiences • Customer relationships are becoming more complex, with customers becoming less loyal Build relationships Ahmed Ali Al Mamari, of Oman’s Capital Market Authority, states, ‘Continued advances in technology, communications, data capture and analytics have given rise to a more empowered global consumer which is forcing insurers to dramatically change their operating model.’ Consumers have more choices than ever, meaning that the customer relationship is more important than ever. As the industry landscape changes, product remains important. But customers are willing to buy more from companies that they trust, and from companies that make the experience easy and convenient. ‘This means that every employee, whether they deal directly with a customer or not, should understand how his or her actions every day, affect everyone who purchases and uses the company’s products or services’, states Amol Shah of First Gulf Bank. ‘Customer centricity is everyone’s job…it begins at the top and permeates through the entire organisation.’ Shah continues by suggesting that there are three critical areas involved: Profiling and segmentation Segmentation is absolutely essential when it comes to customer centricity. The survey responses indicate that profiling helps ensure that the product is suitable for the customer and that the customers will gain real benefits from the products. By profiling your customer base you will develop a deep understanding of their product needs and will be able to match them. This helps organisations select the best products for their existing customers, and also allows them to focus staff training efforts on a few well-targeted products that will meet the needs of the most valuable customers. 1. Experience design - review the portfolio of products and services, understand the customer journey and align your insurance proposition from the customers’ perspectives 2. Understand the voice of the customer, regarding all of your services, not just insurance, using information gleaned from social media, online reviews and call center data 3. Bring the customer experience to life – help employees understand the impact their roles have on the customer experience Other suggestions for developing a customer-centric approach included: Jamie McNish, Regional Director – Partnership Distribution, Friends Provident International Employees should take clear ownership for customer problems and manage issues through to resolution • We need to understand the customers’ needs, attitudes and behaviors. The bank has a wealth of information on their customers which, if used correctly, can greatly assist in building a customer centric approach and proposition focused on the needs of the customer rather on than the bank or insurer. • Design true integrated Customer Value Propositions including the correct sales channels, sales tools, pricing benefits etc • Approach the model design from a customer needs perspective and not from an income perspective Banks should work with a mantra of acquiring, retaining and up-selling to customers and should move away from selling/pushing insurance products. Sreenath Manghat, Head, Bancassurance Products & Services - Consumer Banking, Bank Muscat, Oman Profiling is a must and ensures product suitability to the customer. Emad Louis, Vice President, Head of Barclays Direct Business, Barclays, Egypt Make sure through phone banking that customers have understood each and every aspect of the policies they have bought. Jitender (Kumar) Nangia, Vice President & Cluster Head, HDFC Bank, India Segmentation is a key factor – knowing the profile of the customer will always help in choosing the right product for them. Break down organisational silos and structure incentives to promote a customer-centric culture. Ashish Sood, Deputy CEO, Retail & Private Banking, Ahli Bank, Oman Amol Shah, Business Head Bancassurance, First Gulf Bank, UAE © IIR MIDDLE EAST. All rights reserved 7
CONCLUSION Our study suggests that bancassurance truly is an attractive area for growth and diversification in the financial services sector. The survey respondents agree that the customer should be at the center of the process, and that by profiling their existing customers, they will be well placed to make insurance offerings that are carefully designed to meet the customers’ needs. Whilst bancassurance is seen as a relatively low-risk business, with high growth potential, the survey respondents offer some cautionary notes. They emphasise the importance of selecting the right partner and working within a framework of trust, where each side of the partnership, banking and insurance, are equal. They also highlight the necessity to select the appropriate channel for each product and the importance of a multichannel distribution strategy. As the population becomes increasingly familiar with the products, and as technology develops, it is likely that customers will change channels, and will look for simpler ways to purchase bancassurance products. Providers need to keep abreast, even ahead, of these developments if they are going to maintain and grow market share. Perhaps the strongest message coming through from the responses is the need to know and deeply understand the market – to know the customers, the products, the regulatory framework, as well as the competition. © IIR MIDDLE EAST. All rights reserved 8
ABOUT The Bancassurance Mena Summit, taking place at The Address Hotel, Dubai Mall, Dubai, on 17 – 19 February 2014. For more information, please visit: www.iirme.com/bancassurance/brochure THANKS IIR Middle East would like to thank all the Bancassurance MENA speakers for their contributions to this report, with special thanks to: Headline Sponsor Respondents Ahmed Ali Al Mamari, Director, Financial & Technical Regulations, Capital Market Authority, Oman Jamie McNish, Regional Director, Partnership Distribution, Friends Provident International, UAE Silver Sponsor Emad Louis, Vice President, Head of Barclays Direct Business, Barclays, Egypt Gautam Duggal, Regional Head, Wealth Management, Priority & International Banking Africa, Standard Chartered Bank, UAE Colin Harrison, Regional Insurance, Retail Banking & Wealth Management, HSBC Bank Middle East, UAE Official Media Partner Ashish Sood, Deputy CEO, Retail & Private Banking, Ahli Bank, Oman Amol Shah, Business Head Bancassurance, First Gulf Bank, UAE Media Partners Sreenath Manghat, Head, Bancassurance Products & Services, Consumer Banking, Bank Muscat, Oman Nur Ain Ramli, Vice President & Head of Wealth Management Department, Bank Muamalat Malaysia Berhad, Malaysia Jitender (Kumar) Nangia, Vice President & Cluster Head, HDFC Bank, India JG Shields, Head, Bancassurance, Absa Business Banking, South Africa © IIR MIDDLE EAST. All rights reserved Organised By 9
IIR Middle East conducted a qualitative study with leading bancassurance providers, on key issues facing the market and also to gain insight into, how they ...
Bancassurance Mena Summit, 23 - 25 Feb 2015, Dubai, Event Coverage by Dr. R. L. Bhatia ... Sign in to report inappropriate content. Sign in.
Cost of Living Reports; ... Bancassurance MENA Summit is the ONLY forum ... officials and high profile bancassurance professionals ...
... frameworks in place according to the 2015 Bancassurance MENA Summit Report, ... seminarsession at the Bancassurance MENA Summit, David ...
... strong regulatory frameworks in place according to the 2015 Bancassurance Mena Summit Report, ... the Bancassurance Mena Summit brings together ...
Title: Az3051 bancassurance mena brochure proof 5, Author: Neville, ... , implementing and embedding a bancassurance model to enable successful execution.
... as a recent report estimates the insurance industry across the ... distribution channel as experts discuss way forward at Bancassurance MENA Summit .