50 %
50 %
Information about ASPC2007

Published on August 18, 2007

Author: johnhudson



Hudson & Kuhner - Towards Productive Welfare? Paper presented to 2007 Australian Social Policy Conference

Towards Productive Welfare? A Comparative Analysis of Welfare State Effort in 23 OECD Countries John Hudson & Stefan Kühner University of York, UK Australian Social Policy Conference 2007

Productive Welfare • Challenges: Globalisation, Knowledge Economy • Response: Investment in Human Capital? – Active Labour Market Policies – Education • Variously: – A new type of welfare regime – A reorientation of welfare state – Neglected dimension of welfare state modelling – Incompatible with strong social protection – Compatible with strong social protection

Welfare State Modelling • Esping-Andersen dominates – Three Worlds of Welfare – Focus on social rights – Decommodification Index (+) • Protective not Productive Dimensions • Distinct & Differing Dimensions?

Multi-Dimensionality • How best to capture the welfare state? • Dependant variable problem: – How to capture the multidimensional character of welfare states? • Decommodification index: – One dimensional? – Too narrow? • Means mask important differences → ‘compensation effects’: – Standardised aggregated indices, factor analysis, cluster analysis • Solution: Fuzzy Set Ideal Type Analysis

Fuzzy Sets • Cases have varying membership of sets – 0 Fully Out – 1 Fully In • Boundaries of sets drawn conceptually – Not all variation matters – Reflect substantive knowledge

Fuzzy Set Ideal Type Analysis • Combines n-fuzzy sets to categorise ideal types • Number of types determined conceptually Generous – 2k property spaces Redistributive GR ~GR • Establishes membership G~R ~G~R of types via Boolean logic

Productive-Protective Types • Four Fuzzy Sets: – Protective: • Income Protection • Employment Protection – Productive: • Investment in Education • Investment in Labour Market Training

Operationalising Our Sets Productive: • Education spending as share of public social & education spending • Training component of ALMP budgets as share of total ALMP budgets Protective: • Net replacement rates for single, long-term unemployed • OECD Employment Policy Legislation (EPL 2) Index Sample: • 23 Countries • 1994, 1998, 2003

Productive-Protective Types Productive Protective Productive-Plus Protective-Plus Weak Productive Protective Productive Protective Weak Productive Weak Protective Weak

Findings: 2003 Productive-Protective Finland Productive-Plus Protective-Plus Denmark Sweden Norway Netherlands Austria Finland Productive Weak-Product-Protective Protective Greece Belgium United States Germany Ireland New Zealand Switzerland Italy Weak-Productive Weak-Protective Korea Canada Spain France Czech Republic Japan Portugal Weak United Kingdom Australia United Kingdom

Findings: Time-Series 1994 1998 2003 Productive-Protective Productive-Plus NOR NZ Productive USA Weak-Productive SWE Protective-Plus NET AUT Weak-Productive-Protective SWI Protective BEL Weak-Protective SPA Weak

Findings: Time-Series 1994 1998 2003 Productive-Protective FIN Productive-Plus DEN Productive Weak-Productive Protective-Plus GRE Weak-Productive-Protective ITA Protective Weak-Protective Weak

Findings: Time-Series 1994 1998 2003 Productive-Protective Productive-Plus Productive Weak-Productive CAN Protective-Plus Weak-Productive-Protective KOR IRE GER Protective CZR Weak-Protective JAP POR FRA UK Weak AUS

Conclusions • Utility of fuzzy set ideal type analysis • East Asian states not the exemplars of productivism • Protective & Productive dimensions can be combined • Finland and the USA alternate models? • Little evidence of general shift towards productivism

Add a comment

Related pages

Ateneo Summer Programming Camp

... Systems and Computer Science (DISCS) of Ateneo de Manila University at 426-6071 or e-mail you applications to on or before March ...
Read more

Divorce and personal wellbeing of older Australians

Divorce and personal wellbeing of older Australians David de Vaus, Matthew Gray, Lixia Qu & David Stanton Paper presented for the Australian Social Policy ...
Read more

Who’ll get the super money if you break-up?

... of Family Studies: ...
Read more

Towards Productive Welfare? A Comparative Analysis of 23 ...
Read more

Who’ll get the super money if you break-up? | Benjamin ...

Who’ll get the super money if you break-up? Benjamin Collins. Move Aside Millennials: Let’s Talk Gen Z Nikki Sun. Cities and COP21: For climate ...
Read more

Email Newsletter June 2009 - Permanent Care and Adoptive ... PPSS Referral List – we provide a list of counsellors who have been recommended to
Read more

uniformNZ Custom Sports Selection

Product Link: Custom Singlet Design Your Own Product Description: 100% Polyester Dye Sublimated fabric.
Read more

AUSTRALIAN SOCIAL POLICY CONFERENCE - Carers NSW - Home . SPECIAL SESSIONS In addition, we also invite proposals for special sessions (to be organised by the proposers).
Read more