Are Listed Equity REITs the Same as Unlisted Real Estate? Bibliography

50 %
50 %
Information about Are Listed Equity REITs the Same as Unlisted Real Estate? Bibliography
Real Estate

Published on February 14, 2014

Author: casebrad



This bibliography has web links and quotations from 14 independent academic studies of the relationship between listed equity REIT returns and unlisted real estate returns (direct holdings or private equity funds).
These papers do not address which real estate investments provide better returns. See my separate bibliography at for studies comparing performance.

Bibliography on Relationship BetweenListed Equity REITs and Unlisted Private Real Estate Ang, Andrew, NeilNabar and Samuel Wald *2013+, “Searching for a Common Factor in Public and Private Real Estate Returns” ( “Investors can obtain exposure to real estate through liquid publicly traded REITs or illiquid direct real estate investment. In the long run, REITs and direct real estate should be driven by common shocks because they both represent ownership of real estate. … Our finding that both REITs and private real estate investments have different, idiosyncratic components further suggests there may be a short- and medium-term diversification benefit to holding both in an institutional portfolio.” Bond, Shaun A. and Qingqing Chang *2013+, “REITs and the Private Real Estate Market,” in H. Kent Baker and Greg Filbeck, eds., Alternative Investments: Instruments, Performance, Benchmarks, and Strategies: “The findings suggest that REITs and the private real estate market adjust together toward a long-run equilibrium.” Hoesli, Martin and Elias Oikarinen *2013+, “Are Public and Private Asset Returns and Risks the Same? Evidence from Real Estate Data” ( “The results provide evidence of cointegration between the public and private markets in the four U.S. sectors included in the analysis and in one fo the two U.K. sectors. Thus, the analysis shows that while in the short run the observed REIT and direct real estate returns can substantially deviate from each other due to factors such as data complications, market frictions, and slow adjustment to changes in the fundamentals in the private market, in the long term public and private real estate returns are tightly linked after catering for the effects of property type, leverage, and management costs. … We also find that volatilities generally do not differ significantly between REIT and direct real estate regardless of sector and investment horizon. … As securitized real estate assets enable diversification with smaller amounts of capital, and the liquidity is better and transaction costs are lower in the public market than in the private market, investors who have limited amounts of capital and highly value liquidity and small transaction costs should tile their real estate holdings towards REITs.” Boudry, Walter I., N. Edward Coulson, Jarl G. Kallberg and Crocker H. Liu *2012+, “On the Hybrid Nature of REITs,” Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 44(1-2):230249( “Using transaction rather than appraisal based data we find significant evidence that REITs and the underlying real estate markets are related. Furthermore, the relation appears to be stronger at longer horizons: in particular in annual rather than quarterly data.” Stefek, Dan and Raghu Suryanarayanan [2012]. Private and public real estate: what is the link? Journal of Alternative Investments 14(3):66-75 ( “After accounting for appraisal smoothing and for the lead-lag relationship between public and private returns, we reveal a strong link between U.K. public and private real estate. Further, the link is stronger at longer horizons.” Yunus, Nafeesa, J. Andrew Hansz and Paul J. Kennedy [2012]. Dynamic interactions between private and public real estate markets: some international evidence. Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 45(4):1021-1040 ( “This

study analyzes the dynamic interaction between the private (unsecuritized) and public (securitized) real estate markets of Australia, Netherlands, UK, and the US. … There exist stable, long run relationships between the private and public real estate markets of each country.” Hoesli, Martin and Elias Oikarinen [2012]. Are REITs real estate? Evidence from international sector level data. Forthcoming Journal of International Money and Finance ( “Our findings, based on sector level REIT and direct real estate indices for the U.S. and U.K., suggest that securitized and direct real estate markets are tightly linked in the long run. … The resemblance between REITs and direct real estate is substantially greater than that between REITs and the general stock market.” Oikarinen, Elias, Martin Hoesli and Camilo Serrano [2011].The long-run dynamics between direct and securitized real estate.Journal of Real Estate Research 33(1):73-103 ( “Due to the tight long-run interdependence, the longer the investment horizon is, the greater the degree of substitutability between REITs and direct real estate in a mixed-asset portfolio. In other words, the correlation between NAREIT and NCREIF returns approaches one as the investment horizon lengthens. … Since the two real estate indices are cointegrated with one another and not with the stock market, REITs are likely to bring similar long-term diversification benefits to a stock portfolio as direct real estate.” Kutlu, Vesile [2010]. The long-term relation between indirect and direct real estate. MSc thesis, Tilburg University ( “This thesis investigates the relationship between direct and indirect real estate both in the short run and in the long run in a panel based framework. Panel cointegration analysis confirms the presence of a cointegration relation between the two assets which means that they are substitutes for investors in the long run. As a consequence, investors should treat the two real estate categories as a single asset class in the long run since they imply the same level of risk and return characteristics over long horizons….” Chiang, Kevin C.H. [2009]. Discovering REIT price discovery: a new data setting.Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 39(1):74-91 ( “Our study of lead-lag relationship between real returns and public returns indicates that lagged public returns are useful in predicting private returns. That is, the information contained in the lags of public returns is subsequently transmitted into the private appraisal-based sector. The result is consistent with the idea that public markets are more efficient in incorporating information into prices.” Lee, Ming-Long and Kevin C.H. Chiang [2010].Long-run price behaviour of equity REITs: become more like common stocks after the early 1990s?Journal of Property Investment & Finance 28(6):454465 ( “The results show that REITs behave like common stocks during the earlier 1978-1993 sub-period. In contrast, REITs become less like common stock and more like private real estate after the early 1990s structural change.” Li, Jinliang, Robert M. Mooradian andShiawee X. Yang [2009].The information content of the NCREIF index.Journal of Real Estate Research 31(1):93-116 ( “The general result of the paper is that appraisal-based returns lag NAREIT returns and there is a

causality effect implying that NAREIT returns provide ‘information flow’ into the appraisal-based returns. This suggests that appraisers use REITs as a proxy for performance.” Lee, Ming-Long, Ming-Te Lee and Kevin C.H. Chiang [2008]. Real estate risk exposure of equity real estate investment trusts. Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 36(2):165-181 ( “Our results have implications. First, equity REITs are capable of providing investors real estate exposures. … Second, our evidence supports a long list of studies…which advocate the use of REITs to capture the real estate factor.” Morawski, Jaroslaw, Heinz Rehkugler and Roland Füss [2008].The nature of listed real estate companies: property or equity market?Financial Markets and Portfolio Management 22(2):101-126 ( “The fact that correlations between returns of real estate stocks and direct real estate are clearly higher for longer holding periods corresponds to expectations. Since direct real estate qualifies as a long-term investment, it should also influence the performance of real estate stocks in a similar manner. This was demonstrated with the correlation coefficients between long-term returns on the one hand, and with the cointegrating vectors of respective time series on the other hand for both the USA and the UK.”

Add a comment

Related presentations


Find out our slection of luxury properties in Provence and on the French Riviera (...

Find out this lovely recent and luxury property in the soth of France near airport...

Map of the Boston Commercial Real Estate market by industry and area.

29 Palms Residential Lot

29 Palms Residential Lot

November 10, 2014

29 Palms residential lot in developing area of 29 Palms. Clean pristine desert vi...

Palm Bay Home Inspector

Palm Bay Home Inspector

November 6, 2014

We Provide Home Inspections and commercial inspections in Brevard County, FL and I...

Related pages

Listed Equity REITs Were Top-Performing Asset In Study Of ...

“The strong correlation and comparable volatility of Unlisted Real Estate and Listed Equity REITs is very logical, ... the same as U.S. Large Cap Stocks.
Read more

Unlisted REITs: What Went Wrong? - Forbes

Unlisted REITs: What Went Wrong? ... are essentially the same kind of vehicles as their listed ... market for commercial real estate, many ...
Read more

Real Estate Investment Trusts -

Private Equity Real Estate Listed Equity REITs ... Same as listed REITs ... unlisted U.S. real estate returns measured by the NCREIF Transaction
Read more

CEM Benchmarking© Study: Disconnect Between Capital ...

Listed Equity REITs outperformed all other 11 assets in the study, ... REITs also outperformed Unlisted Real Estate, ... the same as U.S. Large Cap Stocks.
Read more

Real Estate Investment Trusts - EY

Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) ... •Minimum experience of 5 years in real estate industry for each sponsor and ... listed and unlisted debt, ...
Read more

Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT) Definition | Investopedia

... 75% of gross income must be derived from real estate. REITs are required by ... listed property ... the equity or value of their real estate ...
Read more

The use of listed real estate securities in asset management

The universe of listed real estate ... profile of real estate rather than the equity ... that the relationship between REITs and the underlying real estate ...
Read more

Listed Equity | LinkedIn

View 1575 Listed Equity posts, presentations, experts, and more. Get the professional knowledge you need on LinkedIn.
Read more