advertisement

Analysing Welfare Policy - Week4

60 %
40 %
advertisement
Information about Analysing Welfare Policy - Week4

Published on October 28, 2007

Author: johnhudson

Source: slideshare.net

Description

Slides for Second Year 'Analysing Welfare Policy' lecture on 'Political Economy of Welfare'
advertisement

Changing Political Economies of Welfare AWP Week 4

Session(s) Objectives   (1) To examine broad changes in economic ideas and economic policy

  (1) To examine broad changes in economic ideas and economic policy

Session(s) Objectives   (2) To critically assess the validity of key policy positions and theoretical paradigms relevant to economic policy

 

(2) To critically assess the validity of key policy positions and theoretical paradigms relevant to economic policy

Session(s) Objectives (3) To assess the impact on welfare of changing approaches to economic management

(3) To assess the impact on welfare of changing approaches to economic management

Session(s) Objectives (4) To consider the power of the state in the face of a changing world economy

(4) To consider the power of the state in the face of a changing world economy

Session Overview   (1) Context (2) History (3) Theorisations (4) Exploring Change

  (1) Context

(2) History

(3) Theorisations

(4) Exploring Change

Part I – Context

Last Week Globalisation core ideas competing interpretations of evidence does it exist? how can we know if it exists? What is reality? double hermeneutic

Globalisation

core ideas

competing interpretations of evidence

does it exist?

how can we know if it exists?

What is reality?

double hermeneutic

Political Economies of Welfare Overarching ideational paradigm Frames political action at given moment Broad consensus – not total agreement Parties compete at margins > Differences important Paradigm shifts occur >

Overarching ideational paradigm

Frames political action at given moment

Broad consensus – not total agreement

Parties compete at margins >

Differences important

Paradigm shifts occur >

Part II - History

Key Paradigm Shifts Post-war Welfare Consensus Thatcherism Third Way

Post-war Welfare Consensus

Thatcherism

Third Way

Post-War Welfare Consensus increased state intervention social rights of citizenship Keynesian economics demand management full employment economic growth (male breadwinner model)

increased state intervention

social rights of citizenship

Keynesian economics

demand management

full employment

economic growth

(male breadwinner model)

Post-War Welfare Consensus Marked a significant shift in PEW New social contract Catalysts: war depression

Marked a significant shift in PEW

New social contract

Catalysts:

war

depression

Consensus Under Pressure Sluggish economic growth stop-go cycle Rising unemployment Stagflation Structural weaknesses? productivity innovation State Overload Thesis

Sluggish economic growth

stop-go cycle

Rising unemployment

Stagflation

Structural weaknesses?

productivity

innovation

State Overload Thesis

Consensus Under Pressure IMF Crisis credibility conditions > Corporatist Economic Structures industrial unrest Winter of Discontent

IMF Crisis

credibility

conditions >

Corporatist Economic Structures

industrial unrest

Winter of Discontent

Thatcher & New Right Rolling back the state Individualism Monetarism (Supply Side) Control of inflation ‘ unemployment a price worth paying’ Markets as wealth generators Marked Contrast with PWC

Rolling back the state

Individualism

Monetarism (Supply Side)

Control of inflation

‘ unemployment a price worth paying’

Markets as wealth generators

Marked Contrast with PWC

Thatcher & New Right Huge rise in unemployment Foot: ‘the trick’ Boom bust Lawson’s ‘economic miracle’ Crude economic policy interest rates High government borrowing Little progress in cutting social expenditure Weak government? Responding to events rather than shaping them

Huge rise in unemployment

Foot: ‘the trick’

Boom bust

Lawson’s ‘economic miracle’

Crude economic policy

interest rates

High government borrowing

Little progress in cutting social expenditure

Weak government?

Responding to events rather than shaping them

Blair – Third Way Limits to state action – reform not retrench > Rights & responsibilities Beyond Keynes & Monetarism? > Inflation & employment Progressive supply side policies Social policies as economic policies > Flexible labour markets Human capital Modernised social democracy? >

Limits to state action – reform not retrench >

Rights & responsibilities

Beyond Keynes & Monetarism? >

Inflation & employment

Progressive supply side policies

Social policies as economic policies >

Flexible labour markets

Human capital

Modernised social democracy? >

Part III - Theorisations

Competition State Paradigm shift loose neo-liberal consensus response to globalisation competition state Economic Policy end of Keynes supply side policies control inflation & public spending free markets

Paradigm shift

loose neo-liberal consensus

response to globalisation

competition state

Economic Policy

end of Keynes

supply side policies

control inflation & public spending

free markets

Competition State Social Policy de-emphasise social rights (responsibilities) marketisation, privatisation active labour market policies (workfare) ‘ the competition state is the successor to the welfare state, incorporating many of its features but reshaping them, sometimes quite drastically, to fit a globalizing world’

Social Policy

de-emphasise social rights

(responsibilities)

marketisation, privatisation

active labour market policies (workfare)

‘ the competition state is the successor to the welfare state, incorporating many of its features but reshaping them, sometimes quite drastically, to fit a globalizing world’

Post-Fordist Welfare State ‘ relative to the earlier post-war period, social policy is becoming more closely subordinated to economic policy… and its delivery has been subject to a partial rollback of the state in favour of market forces and civil society’ ‘ [the] opening of national economies makes it harder to pursue social policy in isolation from economic policy’

‘ relative to the earlier post-war period, social policy is becoming more closely subordinated to economic policy… and its delivery has been subject to a partial rollback of the state in favour of market forces and civil society’

‘ [the] opening of national economies makes it harder to pursue social policy in isolation from economic policy’

Keynesian Welfare National State Keynesian Full employment Closed economy Demand management   Welfare Welfare rights   National Primacy of national scale State Mixed economy State corrects market failures Keynesian Welfare National State Schumpeterian Workfare Post-national Regime Keynesian Full employment Closed economy Demand management   Schumpeterian Innovation and competitiveness Open economy Supply side policies Welfare Welfare rights Workfare Social policy subordinated to economic policy Downward pressure on social wage Attacks welfare rights   National Primacy of national scale Post-national Hollowing out State Mixed economy State corrects market failures Regime Increased role of governance mechanisms to correct market and state failures

Part IV – Exploring Change

Big Mac Political Economy important operate within a paradigm conditions possibilities Variation within paradigm Different forms of SWPR Different forms of Competition State

Political Economy important

operate within a paradigm

conditions possibilities

Variation within paradigm

Different forms of SWPR

Different forms of Competition State

Big Mac Key meso forces: Institutions Policy Networks Policy Transfer Interconnected, iterative

Key meso forces:

Institutions

Policy Networks

Policy Transfer

Interconnected, iterative

Changing PEWs Exogenous shocks key? Windows of opportunity Punctuated equilibrium Ideas up for grabs at these times >

Exogenous shocks key?

Windows of opportunity

Punctuated equilibrium

Ideas up for grabs at these times >

Conlcusion Political economy frames context... ...but context shapes political economy macro, meso, micro Interact with other elements of policy process and vice-versa Ideas are important... ...but why and when?

Political economy frames context...

...but context shapes political economy

macro, meso, micro

Interact with other elements of policy process and vice-versa

Ideas are important...

...but why and when?

"The ideas of economists and political philosophers, both when they are right and when they are wrong, are more powerful than is commonly understood. Indeed, the world is ruled by little else. Practical men, who believe themselves to be quite exempt from any intellectual influences, are usually the slaves of some defunct economist. Madmen in authority, who hear voices in the air, are distilling their frenzy from some academic scribbler of a few years back... Sooner or later, it is ideas, not vested interests, which are dangerous for good or evil." — John Maynard Keynes

< number of votes left right A B median Party Competition Model Scenario A

< number of votes left right A B median Party Competition Model Scenario B

‘ We used to think that you could spend your way out of a recession and increase employment by cutting taxes and boosting government spending. I tell you in all candour that that option no longer exists, and even insofar as it did ever exist, it only worked on each occasion by injecting a larger dose of inflation into the economy, followed by a higher level of unemployment as the next step.’ Jim Callaghan, 1976 Labour Party Conference <

‘ We used to think that you could spend your way out of a recession and increase employment by cutting taxes and boosting government spending. I tell you in all candour that that option no longer exists, and even insofar as it did ever exist, it only worked on each occasion by injecting a larger dose of inflation into the economy, followed by a higher level of unemployment as the next step.’

Jim Callaghan, 1976 Labour Party Conference

Public expenditure as a proportion of national income has more or less reached the limits of acceptability. Constraints on ‘tax and spend’ force radical modernisation of the public sector and reform of public services to achieve better value for money Blair & Schroeder <

“ Beveridge, like most of his contemporaries, was committed to full employment, delivered by Keynesian demand management. The assumption of enduring full employment held good during the 1940s and 1950s… [but] began to come apart as early as the 1970s… Today the assumption has completely broken down. Globalisation has placed a premium on workers with the skills and knowledge to adapt to advancing technology” Blair <

‘ a significant redrawing of the boundaries of state activity. Rather than providing a generous safety net for the unemployed… New Labour sees the state’s role as stimulating their re-entry into the labour market’ Glyn and Wood <

“ In the economic sphere, looks to develop a wide-ranging supply-side policy, which seeks to reconcile economic growth mechanisms with structural reform of the welfare state. In the information economy, human (and social) capital becomes central to economic success. […] The principle ‘wherever possible invest in human capital’ applies equally to the welfare state – which needs to be reconstructed as a ‘social investment state’.” Giddens <

‘ Third way politics, as I conceive of it, is not an attempt to occupy a middle ground between top-down socialism and free-market philosophy. It is concerned with restructuring social democratic doctrines to respond to the twin revolutions of globalization and the knowledge economy ’ Giddens <

‘ If the paradigm ‘ain’t broke’, radical ideational suggestions to ‘fix it’, existing in the form of circulating ideas and other forms of political discourse, will not find practical expression within purview of the state. Only when a status quo is considered ‘broke’, and economic needs and political demands require change, can ideas be advanced to dramatically ‘fix’ it.’ Heffernan (2002: 750) <

Add a comment

Related pages

Social Welfare Policy Analysis | Researchomatic

Social Welfare Policy Analysis Social Welfare Policy Analysis Introduction Promoting social welfare for the people is naturally a good cause.
Read more

Understanding the Policy Process: Analysing Welfare Policy ...

Understanding the Policy Process: Analysing Welfare Policy and Practice ... Understanding the Policy Process: Analysing Welfare Policy and Practice
Read more

Social Welfare: Policy and Analysis - Andrew W. Dobelstein ...

Social Welfare: Policy and Analysis. Andrew W. Dobelstein. Nelson-Hall, Jan 1, 1996 - Human services - 298 pages. 0 Reviews Intended for use by both ...
Read more

Child Welfare Policy and Program Analysis Guide

Child Welfare Policy and Program Analysis can be considered a one ... reference for an historical and contemporary analysis of child welfare policy and
Read more

Social Welfare: Policy and Analysis / Edition 3 by Andrew ...

SOCIAL WELFARE: POLICY AND ANALYSIS, Third Edition, shows students how to apply the methods and processes of policy analysis to current American welfare ...
Read more

analysis child welfare policy | PHD Thesis Writing ...

analysis child welfare policy. analysis child welfare policy Paper instructions: The first step in completing the project is to prepare a 1- to 2-page ...
Read more

Analyzing Policy - Duke University

Analyzing Policy: Introduction to the Analysis of Choice and Management Michael C. Munger. Duke University. Table of Contents
Read more

CROSS-NATIONAL SOCIAL WELFARE POLICY ANALYSIS IN THE ...

CROSS-NATIONAL SOCIAL WELFARE POLICY ANALYSIS IN THE GRADUATE CURRICULUM: A COMPARATIVE PROCESS MODEL Martin B. Tracy This article presents an ...
Read more

Understanding the policy process (Second edition ...

The book Understanding the policy process (Second edition): Analysing welfare policy and practice, John Hudson and Stuart Lowe is published by Policy Press ...
Read more