Published on February 28, 2014
Introduction to SNOMED Guru Kini
Overview What is SNOMED Applications of SNOMED Concepts, Hierarchies & Relationships SNOMED vs. ICD9 Post Co-ordination and Pre Co-ordination Things to consider before opting for SNOMED This may be useful for requirement analysts, project managers or software developers who are faced with implementing SNOMED support in the healthcare related software. This is not a How-To guide or a detailed technical analysis of SNOMED. However, there are several useful references in the notes and the slides for these contexts. Apologies for the heavily bulleted slides
What is SNOMED? Systemized NOmenclature of MEDicine It is an organized lists of a wide variety of clinical terminology defined with unique codes Perhaps the most comprehensive clinical terminology in the world It is older than you think! Started as early as 1965 Has had several iterations since Currently used variant: SNOMED Clinical Terms (SNOMED CT) Provides cross maps to various terminologies such as ICD9, ICD10 and LOINC Continued…
What is SNOMED? (contd.) SNOMED covers a wide no. of medical terminologies for Disorders and finding (what was observed) Procedures (what was done) Event (what happened) Substance/Medication (what was consumed/administered) Pretty much anything that may be used to capture Medical data SNOMED is designed as an Ontology Each Concept could have relationships with other Concepts
What is an ontology? Ontology is a formalized model for particular domain Consists of 4 basic elements: Individuals/Objects – an actual, concrete instance of something that can described as a part of the ontology (viz., Angina, Class 1) Classes – abstract concepts (Procedure, Disease, etc.). Essentially a “category” for a set of Individuals Attributes – certain properties associated with a class Relations – define who certain classes (and objects) are related to each other Yes, a class diagram of a program written in an OO programming language is a visual representation of an ontology
Where can I find SNOMED codes? National Library of Medicine’s UMLS is the one stop shop for SNOMED codes SNOMED is now freely available for use for U.S. users It is now maintained by International Health Terminology Standards Development Organization (IHTSDO)
Concepts, Hierarchies & Relationships A “Concept” is the basic unit in SNOMED Has a numeric representation (Concept ID), which is assigned arbitrarily Can represent anything that may have a possible use in recording clinical information The same Concept could have several “Synonyms” to accommodate variations in name. E.g., “Myocardial infarction” could also be called “Infarction of heart” or just “Heart Attack” All Concepts are divided in “Hierarchies” Hierarchies do not overlap Clinical Finding/Disorder, Procedure, Substance, etc. are all examples There are some 20+ main hierarchies, more can be added over time “Relationships” between Concepts can be defined “Is a” is most common relationship Other relationships could be defined as “Attributes” of a Concept
Example: using SNOMED relationships Disease Is a type of Disorder of body site Is a type of Legend Disorder Synonym Body Structure Disorder of body system Is a type of Is a type of Disorder of endocrine system Disorder of foetus or newborn Is a type of Is a type of Relation Diabetes mellitus Is a type of Endocrine pancreatic structure Found in Neonatal disorder Is a type of Neonatal diabetes mellitus AKA Diabetes mellitus syndrome in newborn infant
Top SNOMED Hierarchies 80000 70000 60000 50000 40000 74758 30000 50060 20000 41221 27623 10000 26210 23700 0 Disorder Procedure Finding Organism Body Substance Structure
Disorder vs. Finding • Disorders and findings often used interchangeably • “Finding” is a general observation or a judgment of the patient’s physical, mental or social condition (current or historical). A finding need not be an “abnormal” state and can be somewhat vague. E.g.: • Patient complaints/Symptoms (e.g., cough, shivering) • Lab result observations (e.g., Allergy Skin Test Positive) • Social setting (e.g., Unsafe play area, Patient’s dependents) • A “Disorder” or “Disease” is a sub-set of “Finding” concept that are necessarily abnormal physical or mental conditions for the patient. E.g.: • Tuberculosis • Angina, Class I • A Finding may be the initial diagnosis of the patient’s condition which may lead to the discovery of a Disorder. E.g., • A complaint of Chest pain (Finding) may lead to a final diagnosis of Angina, Class I (Disorder) • Bleeding of Gums (Finding) may lead to Hematoma of gingivae (Disorder) • Cough (Finding) may lead to Tuberculosis (Disorder)
SNOMED vs. ICD ICD is a relatively ancient code family Late 19th century roots ICD9 was developed in 1970s! Even ICD10 is ~30 years old! ICD is a classification whereas SNOMED is a terminology ICD tends to be more abstract. With SNOMED the user can get a more accurate description ICD9 (or ICD10) tend to have a “unspecified” catch-all slot for most disorders. SNOMED is far more extensive than ICD9 ICD only covers disorders SNOMED is implemented as an ontology Any number of relationships can be defined for each concept Continued…
SNOMED vs. ICD (contd.) SNOMED CT – is better suited for capturing relevant data during an encounter Allows the user to capture the various aspects associated with a disorder (Post Coordination) This encourages the user to capture associated information like Severity, Body part affected, Cause (force or substance), laterality (viz., left or right), Morphology (form) in structured form ICD9/10 – used in cases where data need not be very granular Each code is very rigidly defined and does not support qualifiers Used in Insurance billing, Morbidity recording (death cause etc.), Epidemiological tracking (public health surveillance) These use-cases usually can work with a general disease class Usually, SNOMED CT is considered a good way to enter the medical information and ICD9/10 is considered a good way to export information
SNOMED CT to ICD9/10 Conversions Why convert? Business requirements - e.g., your Billing Clearing house may insist on ICD9/ICD10 Interoperability – to import CCD/CCR from other sources that use ICD9/ICD10 Future-proofing – ICD10 may eventually be the de facto standard SNOMED CT provides cross-mapping with ICD9 and ICD10 terminologies Since SNOMED CT is much larger in size and because ICD9/10 primarily deal with disorders, only a portion of SNOMEC can be mapped. ICD9/ICD10 to SNOMED is mostly 1:1, however SNOMED to ICD9/ICD10 may have a number of 1:Many mapping May need user input or context based intelligence to convert
Post Coordination Post Co-ordination: representing a medical term using two or more SNOMED concepts. E.g., “Wound in the right hand” could be coded in parts Wound (Disorder) 399963005 Found in Hand (Body Structure) 302539009 Laterality Right (Qualifier) 24028007 SNOMED’s ontological structure naturally lends itself to Post Coordination based capturing of data. However, it can cause confusion as the same concept can be represented in more than one way! E.g. Wound in hand (Disorder) 283059006 Laterality Right (Qualifier) 24028007 Continued…
Post Coordination (contd.) ICD9/10 is design to be Pre Co-ordination oriented. That is, there is usually one unique code for a given medical term. It also implies that one cannot capture much of term’s associative data using ICD9/10 itself Some of the SNOMED “leaf” concepts are specific enough to be used as Pre Co-ordinated terms For any system, Pre- vs Post- arguments essentially deal with one question: “For capturing a medical term, what do you need more: uniqueness or granularity”?
Things to consider before implementing SNOMED CT in your system Familiarize yourself Use a SNOMED CT Browser Look at some existing SNOMED subsets (CORE, VA/KP) Consider your use-cases Determine which hierarchies will the system use (Finding, Procedure, Disorder) Determine which concepts will the system use (Create a Subset) Determine when will your system use primitive (generic/vague) and nonprimitive (specific) concepts Consider your conversion requirements Look at the UMLS Metathesaurus and see if you can use that instead of SNOMED Allow room for updates SNOMED CT releases updates twice a year Your system should be able to accept the updates without going out-ofaction
References http://protege.stanford.edu/publications/ontology_de velopment/ontology101-noy-mcguinness.html - What is an Ontology http://perspectives.ahima.org/a-comparison-betweena-snomed-ct-problem-list-and-the-icd-10-cmpcs-hipaacode-sets/ - Comparing ICD10 and SNOMED CT http://www.connectingforhealth.nhs.uk/elearning/sn omedct/flash/ - SNOMED Intro by NHS
Vendor Introduction to SNOMED CT May 2015 6 | P a g e These general benefits lead to SNOMED CT being increasingly included as part of clinical system
4 • SNOMED CT: Introduction • Benefits of SNOMED CT: Interoperability Agenda • What is SNOMED CT? • SNOMED CT Terminology Structure o Concepts
IHTSDO releases Vendor Introduction to SNOMED CT. IHTSDO is launching an extensive programme of vendor engagement underpinned by a comprehensive Vendor ...
SNOMED CT . The chosen terminology for the NHS England. Use of Synonyms helps cater for different expressions with the same meaning. SNOMED CT . GP’s
These tutorials are available without registering for a SNOMED CT course. They provide an introduction to some of the key benefits and features of SNOMED CT.
Using Snoflake to access SNOMED CT An Introduction to SNOMED CT. SNOMED Clinical Term (SNOMED CT ®) is a comprehensive and precise clinical reference ...
Webinar 1: Introduction to SNOMED CT The first in this series of webinars is an introduction to SNOMED CT. This webinar looks at why a single terminology ...
This book is for professional training as well as a reference book on SNOMED CT; Aims to provide the reader with a gentle introduction to SNOMED CT in a ...