Published on September 30, 2013
Shiva Bidar-Sielaff, M.A. Karin Ruschke, M.A. Presented by: Jorge U. Ungo American Translators Association 49th Annual Conference A Health CareA Health Care Interpreter’s BestInterpreter’s Best Friend: The NationalFriend: The National Code of Ethics forCode of Ethics for Interpreters in HealthInterpreters in Health CareCare
Creating the National Code ofCreating the National Code of Ethics for Interpreters in HealthEthics for Interpreters in Health CareCare Overview of the NCIHC Review of the process used to develop the Code of Ethics for Interpreters in Health Care Review the principles of Code of Ethics Case Studies
The National Council on InterpretingThe National Council on Interpreting in Health Care (NCIHC)in Health Care (NCIHC) 1994 - informal working group 1998 - formally established Multidisciplinary membership: medical interpreters interpreter service coordinators and trainers clinicians policymakers advocates researchers Mission: to promote culturally competent professional health care interpreting as a means to support equal access to health services for individuals with limited English proficiency Website: www.ncihc.org
Building a ProfessionBuilding a Profession Create and build support for a single Code of Ethics that will guide the practice of interpreters working in health care venues Develop a nationally accepted, unified set of Standards of Practice based on the Code of Ethics that will define competent practice in the field Develop standards for health care interpreter training Contribute to the development of a national certification for health care interpreters as part of the National Coalition on Healthcare Interpreter Certification
Challenges in Creating theChallenges in Creating the National Code of EthicsNational Code of Ethics To design a code that built on and solidified existing work To expand upon this existing work to ensure its relevance to all health care interpreters, irrespective of the languages or particular venue in which interpreters work
Designing the National Code ofDesigning the National Code of Ethics for Interpreters in HealthEthics for Interpreters in Health Care: The ProcessCare: The Process
Step 1:Step 1: Reviewed Existing Codes of EthicsReviewed Existing Codes of Ethics Identified and collected existing codes of ethics in health care and other related areas such as legal and sign language interpreting Focused on ten codes that were considered most relevant to our work Compared and identified the elements that were held in common and analyzed how each approached those issues that were most difficult and controversial in the field
Step 2: Created a Draft CodeStep 2: Created a Draft Code Drafted a code that included the elements shared across these existing codes as well as a few that were controversial but relevant Included a short commentary after each principle that further explained and illustrated that principle
Example of Draft PrincipleExample of Draft Principle Principle #2. Accuracy and Completeness The interpreter strives to render the message faithfully, conveying the content and spirit of the original message, while taking into consideration its cultural context. It is the interpreter’s responsibility to interpret everything the speaker says without changing the meaning. The interpreter should attempt to convey what is said and how it is said without additions, deletions or alterations, but with due consideration of the cultural context of both the sender and the receiver of the message. Whenever possible, the interpreter should convey the meaning of gestures, body language, and tone of voice that add significantly to the content of the message. Additionally, when the interpreter becomes aware of a mistake they have made, the interpreter must reveal and correct the error.
First Draft Code of EthicsFirst Draft Code of Ethics Confidentiality Accuracy and Completeness Impartiality Professional Boundaries Professional Development Cultural Competence Respect for all Parties Professional Integrity
Step 3:Step 3: Conducted National FocusConducted National Focus Groups to Review the Draft (Fall 2002)Groups to Review the Draft (Fall 2002) 17 focus groups across the country Broad representation of language groups and modes of service delivery (e.g. face to face and telephone interpreting) Groups confirmed the need for a unified national code of ethics and affirmed its development as a positive step for the profession Feedback also concluded that the draft code was fundamentally complete and appropriate although some principles were seen as more or less controversial
Step 4: 2Step 4: 2ndnd Draft Code of EthicsDraft Code of Ethics Included focus group commentaries and incorporated recommended changes: Confidentiality Accuracy and Completeness Impartiality Professional Boundaries Professional Development Cultural Competence → Cultural Intervention Respect for all Parties Professional Integrity →Advocacy
Step 5: National SurveyStep 5: National Survey 2nd draft introduced to a larger cross-section of working interpreters through a survey survey disseminated through the NCIHC website and state associations of health care interpreters approximately 2,500 surveys were distributed, with a return rate of 20%
Sample Survey QuestionsSample Survey Questions Principle #9. Advocacy Advocacy is an action that is taken on behalf of an individual that goes beyond facilitating communication with the intention of supporting good health outcomes. In some special circumstances, the interpreter may advocate for the interests of any individual patient, provider, or community. Advocacy must be undertaken carefully, if at all, only if other mechanisms for addressing a problem do not work.
Sample Survey QuestionsSample Survey Questions Principle #9. Advocacy 1. This final principle is being considered for inclusion in the Code of Ethics. Do you think the code should include a principle regarding advocacy? ___ Yes ___ No 2. Do you agree with this principle? ____ Yes ____ No Please explain. 3. When do you think it is appropriate for a health care interpreter to act as an advocate for the patient? (Check one or more) a. When the interpreter has tried all other avenues to resolve the problem. b. When the health, well-being or dignity of the patient is at risk. c. Never. A nurse in the pre-operative area of a hospital tells a patient that her left leg is being amputated. The patient becomes increasingly agitated, insisting that her right leg was to be amputated. The interpreter interprets what the patient is saying, and the nurse in charge ignores the patient’s protests. The interpreter is aware from a previous appointment that the patient is correct and the doctor had been planning on amputating the right leg. The patient continues to protest, even as the anesthesia is being prepared. The interpreter continues to interpret for the patient, attempting to convey his frustration and fear, but when the situation is not resolved, the interpreter leaves the room and calls the nurse’s supervisor. Do you agree with this application of the advocacy principle? ____ Yes ____ No
Survey ResultsSurvey Results Strong agreement on the principles as stated in the draft. Most controversial principle was “Advocacy” Commentaries generated most controversy Commentaries generated unresolved questions about implementation
Step 6: The National Code of Ethics forStep 6: The National Code of Ethics for Interpreters in Health CareInterpreters in Health Care Code of ethics highlights the consensus there was on the principles themselves - published without commentary Final draft was also reviewed by a select number of health care providers and medical ethicists Companion document is created that offers a more thorough discussion of the issues raised places the code in the context of ethical behavior in general provides an elaboration and discussion of each principle and the interrelationships among them, acknowledging that controversies still exist while offering the working interpreter a way to think about these controversies
National Code of Ethics forNational Code of Ethics for Interpreters in Health CareInterpreters in Health Care “The role of interpreter is a‘tightrope’ balancing act: A code of ethics is a good guide for the ‘bar’ carried on such a walk on the tightrope. It offers balance, some security and especially is a comfortable way to face the unknown risks faced on the interpreter’s path.” Anonymous Respondent to Code of Ethics Survey
Core ValuesCore Values Support health and well-being of patient and do no harm Remain faithful to original message Take into consideration culture and cultural differences to ensure understanding
The interpreter treats as confidential, within theThe interpreter treats as confidential, within the treating team, all information learned in thetreating team, all information learned in the performance of their professional duties, whileperformance of their professional duties, while observing relevant requirements regardingobserving relevant requirements regarding disclosure.disclosure. Shared with other health care professionals Sharing information with the treating team does not violate confidentiality Avoid situations that expose you to confidential information Explain your role Avoid being alone with the patient If information is shared in confidence, encourage patient to disclose information to provider decide, based on core values and legal obligations, whether or not to share
The interpreter strives to render the messageThe interpreter strives to render the message accurately, conveying the content and spiritaccurately, conveying the content and spirit of the original message, taking intoof the original message, taking into consideration its cultural context.consideration its cultural context. Essence of interpreter role Remain unbiased Do not omit, add or distort message Offensive language, derogatory remarks Possible exception: if not intentional, warn speaker Interpret meaning, not words Correct all mistakes
The interpreter strives to maintainThe interpreter strives to maintain impartiality and refrains from counseling,impartiality and refrains from counseling, advising or projecting personal biases oradvising or projecting personal biases or beliefs.beliefs. Provider-patient relationship is key Refrain from judging No personal biases and beliefs Last resort: Withdraw from assignment Disclose limitations Impartial ≠ Uncaring
The interpreter maintains the boundaries ofThe interpreter maintains the boundaries of the professional role, refrainingthe professional role, refraining fromfrom personal involvement.personal involvement. DO NOT mix roles Know your limitations Accept assignments you can manage Withdraw from assignment Disclose limitations Maintain professional relationship Do not provide personal information Avoid personal involvement
The interpreter continuously strives toThe interpreter continuously strives to develop awareness of his/her own and otherdevelop awareness of his/her own and other (including biomedical cultures) encountered(including biomedical cultures) encountered in the performance of their professionalin the performance of their professional duties.duties. Culture is a central factor in health care and necessary to interpret meaning Be aware of your own culture Possess enough understanding of patient and biomedical culture to facilitate communication across cultures Cultural competence should be a value shared by the whole medical team
The interpreter treats all parties withThe interpreter treats all parties with respect.respect. Treat everyone with courtesy and dignity Respect autonomy and expertise of all parties
When the patient’s health, well-being, or dignity areWhen the patient’s health, well-being, or dignity are at risk, the interpreter may be justified in acting asat risk, the interpreter may be justified in acting as an advocate. Advocacy is understood as an actionan advocate. Advocacy is understood as an action taken on behalf of an individual that goes beyondtaken on behalf of an individual that goes beyond facilitating communication, with the intention offacilitating communication, with the intention of supporting good health outcomes. Advocacy mustsupporting good health outcomes. Advocacy must only be undertaken after careful and thoughtfulonly be undertaken after careful and thoughtful analysis of the situation and if other less intrusiveanalysis of the situation and if other less intrusive actions have not resolved the problem.actions have not resolved the problem. Most controversial principles Advocacy ≠ taking sides, judging, personal opinions Only after careful and thoughtful analysis Seek supervisor advice whenever possible Only when clear and/or consistent observation that something is not right and action needs to be taken to protect patient’s health and well-being
The interpreter strives to continuallyThe interpreter strives to continually further his/her knowledge and skills.further his/her knowledge and skills. Continue to sharpen your skills Language is dynamic Keep abreast of developments in your profession Attend trainings/workshops/conferences
The interpreter must at all times act in aThe interpreter must at all times act in a professional and ethical manner.professional and ethical manner. Monitor own performance and behavior Do not use knowledge to your personal advantage Do not exploit the vulnerability of the patient Ethical business practices Compensation Punctuality Keeping appointments
Case StudiesCase Studies Which ethical principles apply to each case study? What would you do?
The National Council on InterpretingThe National Council on Interpreting in Health Care (NCIHC)in Health Care (NCIHC) www.ncihc.orgwww.ncihc.org
Calcification Inhibitors in CKD and Dialysis Patients
1.Shiva Bidar-Sielaff, M.A. Karin Ruschke, M.A. Presented by: Jorge U. Ungo American Translators Association 49th Annual Conference A Health CareA Health ...
A Man’s Best Friend . 2. Veterinarian . 3. Feeding Time . 4. Grooming . 5. House . ... A Healthcare Interpreter's Best Friend. A Dog is a Humans Best Friend.
... lab technicians and other healthcare ... for a health care interpreter was $ ... in all of the interpreter's working ...
Working with interpreters: practical advice ... that best suits the need in the actual healthcare ... interpreter's role in a healthcare ...
Interpreting is interpreting – or is it? ... (1998: 4) sums it up best when he says ... A Sociolinguistic Analysis of the Interpreter's Role in the Turn ...
This board contains Code of Ethics for various organizations as well as articles related to this topic | See more about Articles, Business and Discus.
Even though it is the region’s second oldest multilateral mechanism, APEC continues to find relevance hard to come by. Best known for the photo taken at ...